carrieon interesting what you say about your DS coming into a lighter sleep. When my mother comes down she's going to have him in with her for the night so DP can get some sleep, and since she won't leap up at the first wimper it will be interesting to see if he goes a bit longer then (we're not going to try to mess with anything before then, so he may not). Love the pics of your DS and DD!
ipanemagirl I think basically that with all the advice, you just have to decide to go with what feels right at the moment, and worry about whether there are problems later. If a routine will make your life easier now, try for that, and if being a bit more 'baby led' or whatever the phrase is suits you now, do that. Personally, I like a routine, but I didn't suffer to get DS into it particularly - I eased him towards it over a couple of weeks, and as I have amply demonstrated over the past 48 hours, it's not 100% foolproof!
ponymum wow, the website has the discount too? I thought it was an instore thing? I went in the shop and couldn't face thge queues so I left again!
BBaby I had a couple of days of T waking up after 45 mins, and when I did I gave myself a 15 minute slot in which to resettle him (reasoning that if he was hungry rather than tired, he wouldn't fade away in 15 mins, but it gave me a reasonable chance of settling him) and even if he fell asleep on me for that time, at least he was getting in the habit of taking a longer sleep. Now when he goes down for his lunchtime nap he will (usually) sleep for a good 2hrs, sometimes 2hrs 30.
Pacita poor you. I reckon when they're like that it's just not worth trying to be clever - if next to you is where he will sleep, then let him until you are sure that at least he's not overtired. Once that's solved you can worry about where he's settling again.
Wouldn't worry about putting him in the cot awake - during the day I put T in the cot while still just about awake, but during the night I wait until he is well and truly unconscious, or he just wakes straight up and has to be completely resettled again.