Hello everyone, nice to see all the familiar faces!
Am now 16 weeks upduffed and spend quite a bit of time on here but don't venture from my antenatal thread as can't face a lot of the bitchier threads at the moment
I've read your post tea, and here is my tuppence worth.
I don't think it's your parenting or him as he sounds lovely.
I have similar challenging behaviour, not with H, but with DD who is older, but more sensitive to atmosphere/hunger/tiredness, gets overwhelmed and loses control quickly and thinks afterwards and is contrite (but that isn't the point really). So it may not necessarily be a boy thing. Also when she gets challenging now, I try and see if she needs a hug for reassurance and not an argument/confrontation and can sometimes head it off that way.
I think you might find the how to talk so kids listen book useful if you can borrow a copy.
What truly worked for us with DD is consistently punishing her when she hurts someone physically and we know about it/see it. It sounds easy but it is very hard to be:
calm (bored policeman) and
consistent (not relaxed when awake and snappy & strict when tired)
We needed to use a meaningful punishment too. If they raise their fist then think 'uh-oh I'm going to lose x if I do this', that's where you want to be, so they know they've got something to lose and don't get confused about whether you are going to carry it through or not.
In our case it meant her brother got to pick and watch a film and she didn't (we only have DVD's and they don't get them often so she was very, very upset and knew I meant business).
Now I'm more consistent and try to use threats that I can carry through and they know when I'm going to do it. They get a 5 second warning while I count up to 5 and if the behaviour isn't reversed by 5, the punishment it metered. It stops me from losing my temper too
.
Good luck. You will get through this. It is yet another challenge, but one which will make you all stronger and also will weed out fake friends among the parents you know. We all get cross when other people's children misbehave but judging and tattling based on a lack of knowlege is quite another thing! I'm really sorry it has left you feeling so awful. It may be worth trying some of those 10 minute mindfulness meditations.. they really helped ground me when things are getting stressful... this too shall pass...
Sorry.. mammouth post too! Will try and pop in more often..