Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Politics

Afraid for US

57 replies

LunaTheCat · 11/06/2025 00:52

I have been watching US politics and thinking about events in LA.
What terrifies me is the complicity of ordinary people.
I can get over a narcissistic, sociopathic leader but ordinary citizens… in the military, ICE are complicit . It reminds me so much rise of facism in 1930’s Germany…Hitler could not done what he did without ordinary Germans… feels like we are going there again.

OP posts:
TooBigForMyBoots · 11/06/2025 18:33

The whole point of what's happening in the US is that the people being detained are there illegally no matter where they are from originally, what religion they are etc etc.

That has always happened in the US. What's new are the targets and the method. In the past documented illegals whose application failed would usually be given notice. Time to quit jobs, sell stuff, close their bank accounts etc. They were given a date by which to self-deport and provide documents for their journey.

All very reasonable, civilised and at little cost to the taxpayer.

What's happening now is that parents, spouses, friends, neighbours, employees are being snatched off the streets, imprisoned and sent who knows where (Trump's talking about sending people to Guantanamo now) without notice or due process.

He is calling for the arrest of his democratically elected political opponents. He is putting the US Army on the streets of America. He is pushing the law and constitution to breaking point declaring "National Emergencies". Soon it will break.

That's reminiscent of Nazi Germany.

Goldenbear · 11/06/2025 18:35

TooBigForMyBoots · 11/06/2025 18:33

The whole point of what's happening in the US is that the people being detained are there illegally no matter where they are from originally, what religion they are etc etc.

That has always happened in the US. What's new are the targets and the method. In the past documented illegals whose application failed would usually be given notice. Time to quit jobs, sell stuff, close their bank accounts etc. They were given a date by which to self-deport and provide documents for their journey.

All very reasonable, civilised and at little cost to the taxpayer.

What's happening now is that parents, spouses, friends, neighbours, employees are being snatched off the streets, imprisoned and sent who knows where (Trump's talking about sending people to Guantanamo now) without notice or due process.

He is calling for the arrest of his democratically elected political opponents. He is putting the US Army on the streets of America. He is pushing the law and constitution to breaking point declaring "National Emergencies". Soon it will break.

That's reminiscent of Nazi Germany.

Edited

But of course, all very normal courses of action🙄

1dayatatime · 12/06/2025 07:12

@TooBigForMyBoots

I"n the past documented illegals whose application failed would usually be given notice. Time to quit jobs, sell stuff, close their bank accounts etc. They were given a date by which to self-deport and provide documents for their journey.

All very reasonable, civilised and at little cost to the taxpayer."

Or in reality:

In the past documented illegals whose applications failed would be given notice. Knowing they would be deported this allowed them time to move State quickly and disappear into the wider country, and set up again elsewhere.

All very naive and totally ineffective and a waste of taxpayers money.

MsAmerica · 20/06/2025 04:15

JasmineAllen · 11/06/2025 16:50

Why don't/haven't documented illegal immigrants apply for citizenship?

re: Stonewall, that's a fair point. As I said it was the only comparison I could think of off the top of my head.

Seems to me that if you're in a country illegally, and with no real ethical justification (e.g., you're not running away from a war zone), there's little incentive to announce yourself by applying for citizenship.

MsAmerica · 20/06/2025 04:18

IHateWasps · 11/06/2025 16:30

Though there is a certain level of tolerance/turning a blind eye, deporting illegal immigrants is not
new. The Obama administration deported over 3 million of them and ended the wet feet, dry feet policy, deporting even more than George W Bush who deported approximately 2 million. The way that Trump is doing it may be more extreme(As is just about everything that man does) but it’s certainly not unprecedented.

Also I would not advise deliberately overstaying your visa. That can get you into a lot of trouble, as it did a friend of mine, years before Trump.

Edited

What's unprecedented is Trump's flamboyant cruelty and his obvious enjoyment in creating panic.

PollyBell · 20/06/2025 05:12

A country leta an idiot run the asylum but the inmates are crazy ones i would say

I never understand there is a bunch of leaders who want to throw their toys at each other because someone took their lost marbles off them as kids sure I get it, as ridiculous as it sounds

It is the buffoons I imagine going 'bomb x sure sounds like great idea lers do it' that i can get my head around

On a much less of a scale an op (not talking this thread) starts a thread and sounds 'confused' sure get it but it is the poster's going along with them and encouraging them in their odd thinking that makes the least sense, so in a way is world leaders any different

TankFlyBossW4lk · 21/06/2025 21:50

MidnightScroller · 11/06/2025 04:02

To be honest I was amazed at the protesters - someone on the news was complaining that her dad was deported after living in the US illegally for ten years and he missed her birthday. A protester had a sign saying no-one’s illegal on stolen land. I can appreciate both sentiments but surely people understand that countries have borders and immigration rules? It’s not fair, it’s a lottery where you’re born, and yes if you go back to settlers times the occupation of Native American land and elsewhere was abhorrent, but it’s not feasible to just remove all borders on all countries - who’s going to pay taxes where? Who’s going to pay for teachers, police, roads, healthcare etc?
His language is abhorrent I agree, but I think a lot of his actions are half arsed - for now at least.
I agree it’s still a worry it starts off semi-acceptable then spreads, but he’s already losing so much support I’m not sure he could be the next Hitler…

I try and stay away from these threads because of crap like this. The US and much of the UK services wouldn't run without immigrants. Many immigrants are net contributors and if they aren't their kids may well be. Why drink the right wing Kool Aid. Are you a net contributor?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page