This is an interesting post. I always felt like this esp in my 20s and have always been interested in theology too. I like learning about religions and equally anti-capitalistic and anti-materialistic. Sone of my conclusions 20 years later:
I find people who feel “spiritual” usually say things like “I align with buddhism” but don’t actually know anything about buddhism and never been to a Buddhist temple or met buddhists. I think a lot of it is because of the media and movies portraying buddhism as a “spiritual” religion. It’s not a religion though, it’s just a way of life for some people, not very different from other faiths. You’ll also find that a lot of buddhist majority countries have committed genocides including against the Rohinga and Uyghur people. Buddhism is also closely related to confuciusm. Have you been anywhere around people who follow these? I’ve found their lives , behind the pretty quotes and incense, to be very materialistic. Spirituality is not buddhism. Buddhism is spirituality.
i think spirituality is more to do with purpose.
Btw you won’t find people who think or feel like you at work because everyone has their work face on. No one really is their true self generally, not even those who claim to be “spiritual”. It’s an area studied by Psychologist Carl Jung and others and even he is not the “god” of this topic. No one is.
My feelings now about spirituality is that it is more about privilege. You assess your privileges in this materialistic world and you see what true materialism is. It’s not just “superficial” things like nice cars, big houses, fancy clothes etc. you see that the cost of materialism is actually murdering people for oil, land and materials. I can think of quite a few people now suffering at the hands of that kind of evil: the innocent people of Palestine, DR Congo etc.
i think true spirituality is knowing that the “spiritual” feeling is the beginning of everything. That in this temporary world we have to help others. Perhaps you need to find the purpose to your spirituality rather than “feel good” conversations with others. The latter is not spiritually btw - that’s more about “belonging”. It’s natural to want to feel belonging and have others accept you but that is not spirituality.
Explore your spirituality more, by yourself, and let it lead you somewhere, to your purpose. Right now you’re floundering around the early stages of your growth so you have to push through it and see the bigger picture. The bigger picture is usually being more aware of others suffering, and less of your own.
you start to realise that talking about spiritualism is really just a narcissistic, privileged trait. A bit like when some people love yo go to Church to act holier than thou, rather than actually worship. Acting on spiritualism is the only thing that will make us closer to understanding God.