Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Pedants' corner

Another apostrophe question

8 replies

LifeOfBriony · 24/08/2013 14:45

I am listing some items for sale on eBay.

Should I say "Boy's shirt" or "Boys' Shirt" ?

I have one shirt for sale which belonged to one boy, and will only be bought for one boy.

But I would say "Ladies' dress", not "Lady's dress" (I think), even though only one lady at a time would ever own the dress.

Help!

OP posts:
prism · 24/08/2013 14:55

Would you say "Man's Shirt", or "Men's Shirt"? I'm afraid I can't offer an answer to this one, but you might make your boy choice on the basis of your man one. I'd be inclined to go for the one boy, myself.

LifeOfBriony · 24/08/2013 14:58

Thanks Prism. I incline towards one boy (or girl; I have a ballet bag for sale, too), but so often see the plural version and am wondering what is correct.

OP posts:
CointreauVersial · 24/08/2013 15:09

Hmmm...would it even need an apostrophe?

Isn't the word "boys" acting almost like an adjective in this case, rather than a possessive?

alwaysontop · 24/08/2013 15:49

Yes Cointreau is right no apostrophe needed as its descriptive

prism · 25/08/2013 19:53

I'm struggling to see how that makes sense, as you wouldn't say "men shirt" or "women shirt", and I can't think of another plural that functions that way, sitting as I am in an Irish pub. There's the odd singular, like "horse box" or "dog kennel", but then there's "fairy princess", which is a princess who is a fairy, not a fairy who belongs to one. So by leaving out the apostrophe altogether you're getting on very dodgy ground.

IMHO. Wink

MrsWembley · 25/08/2013 20:35

No no no, you'd definitely need an apostrophe, certainly for the reason ^^. It is a possessive s, it's a shirt belonging to a boy or meant to be owned by boys.

Women's or ladies' is a good example of how you'd like to phrase it. One boy or many?

LifeOfBriony · 27/08/2013 20:26

Thanks for the replies - at the moment they say "Boy's". I will leave as is for now, but would love a definitive answer if anyone knows.

OP posts:
MissSingerbrains · 28/08/2013 00:16

I think it's definitely boys' - same as children's or men's or women's, as mentioned before. The whole 'it's just for one boy' thing is a red herring IMHO, as it was a shirt manufactured for a whole load of potential boy customers :)

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread