What happened to James Bulger was truly sickening. I too received the email but did not sign or forward it – I never forward anything like that because more often than not these emails are hoaxes. But …
While I do not believe that at 11 they were innocent little children, I do think that we need to look deeper and question what kind of upbringing these children (and yes they were still children) had that led them to go out and commit such a terrible crime. Recently in the news there has been the story of an 11 year old girl who is pregnant and who will be Britain’s youngest mum. For her there has been nothing but sympathy, talk of how she couldn’t possibly have known what she was getting into, how her parents are to blame and how she should be taken into care for her own safety. And yet for these boys, who were the same age as this girl, the talk is all of how they knew exactly what they were doing, how they were pure evil and how they should never have been freed. We question what kind of society we’re living in that allows children to have children, so why is it we’re not questioning what kind of society it is that enabled two children to become so disturbed that they abducted and killed a small child? I totally agree that those boys should have received harsh sentences, however I do still think that they were only children, and that they should have been given the chance to be rehabilitated. Do we really want to live in a country that treats children as adults and that would lock up two 11 year olds and keep them in prison until they died? Do you really think that the brain of an 11 year old works the same as that of an adult?
As for these boys being given new identities, again it is the society we live in that needs to be blamed for that imo. We live in a society where people think that it is their right to seak justice on behalf of the victims of crime, even though we have a legal system that tries, convicts and punishes criminals for their crimes. In the eyes of the law, those two boys had served their time and were free to go, but if they had been freed without new identities the media would have started a witch hunt and vidulanti’s would have been after them quicker than you can say “free the bulger killers”, and two wrongs don’t make a right.
For the record, I do not condone what those two boys did, but I also think that it’s not all black and white.