What did Bumper say? I've been looking back but there are a lot of posts.
This one?:
With something like psychology IME is you do a degree, then a postgrad/PhD assuming you get funding then you can do the following:
-Carry on working in academia do research, chasing funding and churning out paper
I'd say: And what's wrong with that? it can be very pleasant. I love my job.
-train for at least a further 2 years to become a charted psychologist trying the BPS website, maybe an educational psychologist
I'd say: True, if you want to do those things then don't really waste your time at this point with a PhD but go directly for that training.
-become a clinical psychologist which involves a very competitive battle to get on a DClinPsy for which would will have had to put in a few years as an assistant psychologist, posts like gold dust
I'd say: I know it's supposed to be competitive but actually, every one of my friends who has wanted to become a clinical psychologist has succeeded. From which I deduce it's not actually that impossible for someone bright and motivated. As policywonk sounds. Pay is quite good once you get there. certainly better than academic posts.
-go and do something completely unrelated and then wish you had chosen Economics or International Relations grin
I'd say: Maybe. But that happens with all courses/subjects.
I think the drawbacks of a psychology Msc or Phd are those of all PhDs in social science or philosophy or similar, they are years of underfunded slog and you can waste your youth or middle age in them and it won't make you rich. But, compared to the others, psychology is quite marketable to employers.