Active discussions

Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Talk
Other subjects
Original poster

OK, clever maths peeps - explain this to me (because it's making my head hurt)

48 replies

marthamoo · 05/10/2006 19:10

My friend told me this today:

3 men go to an hotel and ask for a room for a night. The manager tells them a room will be ?30 so they give him ?10 each and go up to their room (stop it! I know where your minds are going with this!)

Then the manager remembers they have a special offer on and rooms are only ?25. So he calls the porter, explains the situation, and gives him ?5 to give back to the 3 men.

The porter takes the money and heads upstairs but on the way he starts thinking "well, ?5 doesn't really divide between 3" and he pockets ?2 and gives them a ?1 back each. That means each man has paid ?9.

Now...3 lots of ?9 makes ?27, and the porter pocketed ?2 - so what happened to the other pound?

OP posts:
Original poster
marthamoo · 05/10/2006 19:11

Why are the pound signs not working???

OP posts:
Original poster
marthamoo · 05/10/2006 19:11

£££££

OP posts:
Original poster
marthamoo · 05/10/2006 19:11

Why's it done that?

£10

OP posts:
Original poster
marthamoo · 05/10/2006 19:12

Why has it just made all my £s into question marks? Grrrrr.

OP posts:
Alibaldi · 05/10/2006 19:17

Know this is driving me mad and I know it's something really stupid/obvious but can i think of it.aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

southeastastralplain · 05/10/2006 19:17

i know it i do!!! (but can't think argh)

bran · 05/10/2006 19:19

£2 is the difference between £25 which is what the men should have paid and £27 which is what they actually paid.

Tinker · 05/10/2006 19:19

What other £

Have heard this before but can't remember official answer

Original poster
marthamoo · 05/10/2006 19:21

That's what dh said, bran - but why doesn't it work the way I wrote it? And why are all your £ working and mine didn't?

OP posts:
TwigTwoolett · 05/10/2006 19:22

so the men paid £27 out of which the hotel got £25 and the porter got £2

they each gave a £10 note and got £1 change

what extra pound?

TwigTwoolett · 05/10/2006 19:23

the other pound only exists when you think they paid out £30 .. there was never a £30 payment

there were 3 x £9 payments

Original poster
marthamoo · 05/10/2006 19:24

I hate maths. My head is hurting more.

OP posts:
SoupDragon · 05/10/2006 19:24

They each handed over £10 = £30
The room was £25 so the "change" was £5 which was split £1 per man (£3) plus £2 for the porter. £25 + £3 + £2 still = £30

southeastastralplain · 05/10/2006 19:25

i get it now, it's designed to do your head in!!

Original poster
marthamoo · 05/10/2006 19:25

But they each paid £10 - that's £30.

OP posts:
Original poster
marthamoo · 05/10/2006 19:26

But 3 9's are 27...aren't they ?

OP posts:
Original poster
marthamoo · 05/10/2006 19:26

I'm thick aren't I?

OP posts:
bran · 05/10/2006 19:26

The £30 is a red herring you're trying to put 2 entirely separate equations together.

if the room costs £30 and they each pay £10 then
£30=£10 x 3

if the room costs £25 and they each pay £9
£25=(£9 x 3) - £2 for the porter

No missing pounds anywhere.

MegaLegs · 05/10/2006 19:26

No but they all paid £10 to start with didn't they?

TwigTwoolett · 05/10/2006 19:27

yes 3 x 9 = 27 .. of which hotel gets 25 and porter gets 2

to be honest it isn't a maths question its a semantics question

Original poster
marthamoo · 05/10/2006 19:27

I've had a really bad day with sanitary towels and leaky windows and dying goldfish and cooking a pan in the oven with mashed potato in it, you know.

OP posts:
MegaLegs · 05/10/2006 19:27

Don't know why I'm even trying to understand I scraped through my maths O'level with a C third time round.

Original poster
marthamoo · 05/10/2006 19:28

Hey, I beat you - I got a C first time round

OP posts:
TwigTwoolett · 05/10/2006 19:28

that'll be £30 please

here you go ... £10 + £10 + £10

actually no it'll be £25

Ok here's £5 change in pound coins, porter please take these gentlemen's bags upstairs

here porter take £2 for your trouble .. and then that'll be £1 each for each of us

does that help?

MegaLegs · 05/10/2006 19:29

Where you using the sanitary towels to stop the leaky windows?