I don't think the questions based on what others think are useful and make me want to throttle the person who wrote them. It stinks of "Oh, let the normal people decide, their judgement can't possibly be flawed/overly critical/manipulative/covering up their own issues!" I've had more than enough of that from mental health professionals.
One question - is it possible to be AS and notice social cues but not understand/agree with them? Or be able to predict other's behaviour? because people are inconsistent. So for example, if I unintentionally annoy someone, I would totally pick up on the annoyance (I seem to pick up on the 'atmosphere' in a room, or subtle things from people that others don't notice) but I wouldn't quite understand what I'd done wrong. Or, more accurately, why what I'd done had annoyed them, based on how I'd have expected them to react. I can usually pull up examples of how they've acted in (from my pov) similar situations, how their reactions contradict their apparent/stated values etc. this never goes down well, don't do it. But I do pick up on their feelings, and actually automatically obey their silent commands/manipulation, and feel guilty, start desperately trying to make it better etc. (Only realised this recently). Generally I don't get the chance to talk it through with the person and trying to ask annoys them more so I only gain insight from talking to others who are willing to explain, but often they can't explain becuse it doesn't actually make sense, it's just everyone knows, don't they?!
(The one friend who can explain is on the spectrum himself...)
Related to this is the way I try to take other's emotions into account, actually to a greater degree/in a different way than others. To give a blunt example, I act according to how upset someone is, not how upset I think they should be. So if someone appears to be 'overreacting' to something, I can usually tease out the real reason they're upset/figure it out from what else I know. So humans do kind of make sense to me, if I know all the angles, but a lot of things are explained by people deceiving themselves/protecting their inner self/cognitive dissonance caused by trying to cope in our messed up world. I do find it incredibly frustrating that others don't seem so bothered about 'understanding' and 'truth' which I seek above all else, albeit with cuddles and softly spoken for the painful bits. except when I rant online and sound like an out of touch martyr. Actually, I seem to be able to talk to someone and make suggestions/tease out their feelings, counsellor style, and people do actually seem to easily open up to me... but then freak out (?) and back off, or something.
I'm almost thinking maybe it's just groups/group behaviour/loyalty over truth, that I don't 'get', rather than an ASD. And that the spectrum is nowhere near as simple as that, with crossovers with other things eg. HSP's.
Sorry for the rather long message, quite wound up about all this atm and nowhere else to talk about it.