Before answering the questions, I'll give my thoughts. I love porridge, but make proper porridge from unadulterated oats and don't sweeten it. When i received my box, I was disappointed to find that this stuff is merely chocolate flavour as opposed to chocolate flavoured. It hasn't been flavoured with chocolate - it's been given some strange flavour suggestive of chocolate. There is no chocolate and for all we know from the lack of information on the packaging, not even any cocoa in it. The less than half a gram of mysterious chocolate flavouring in each sachet certainly wouldn't amount to much if it was cocoa based. From the smell, it's more like caramel to make it brown, a bit of malt and possibly a tiny amount of vanillin and spice extract. I'm sure if it really did have anything resembling chocolate in it, Quaker would ignore the fact that they're not legally bound to list ingredients present in such small amounts and be positively bragging about it. As it stands, I'm dubious about the claims of being all natural.
To be honest, I thought we'd left this synthetic flavouring nonsense behind decades ago, particularly in premium products like this (because face it, I can buy a bag or box of oats, with more oats in than one of these boxes, for a fraction of the price). I'm very disappointed in this respect
*1. Overall, what did your DC(s) think of Quaker Oat So Simple Kids Porridge? Did they make any comments about the texture, smell, taste or appearance?
DS1, who disapproves of porridge took one look at the box and announced in no uncertain terms that he didn't want any.
DH made himself some this morning, following the instructions. Even though we have a 900W microwave, it ended up runny and took about 10 minutes to set, by which time it was almost cold. He described it as bleurrgghhhh.
I have problems with my hands, so used a measuring jug for the milk for DS2's. No way could I handle a flimsy packet or trust that the measurements were accurate, given that the volume would depend how you held the packet. (I'm a chemist by training, so naturally sceptical of these things!) I adjusted the cooking time for DS2, who normally eats ready brek every single morning. I gave it 1:45 on high and then 1:30 on simmer. It came out nicely cooked after this time. It smelt horrible, though - nothing like chocolate and I had a taste of it and found it very sweet. I usually add fruit puree to DS2's ready brek as his diet is very poor and some days he'd otherwise get no fruit or veg. I added a spoonful of apple, banana and plum to his chocolate flavour porridge for a bit of sharpness. He's non-verbal, so couldn't comment, but he did actually eat it, even though he looked puzzled by it and seemed disappointed when his bowl was empty.
After smelling and tasting DS1's, I just cooked my normal porridge for breakfast.
*2. What would you say are the main benefits of Quaker Oat So Simple Kids porridge, for you and/or for your DCs? What would be the key reason for you to buy the product?
The only temptation would be the convenience of the portion sizes, but to be honest, I have no difficulty eyeballing amounts for ready brek or ordinary porridge, so even this isn't a good reason. The ready brek that DS2 usually has is fortified with vitamins and minerals, which I like, given his poor diet, so the oat so simple loses out in this respect, too. I also don't normally need to add any sugar to his breakfast - any sugar in it comes naturally from the milk and fruit puree in it and he's fine with that.
- What did you and your DC(s) like/dislike about the packaging (including the box and the individual sachets)? Why?
DS2 was interested in the box. He normally mugs me for anything with a cadburys logo, but he was desperate to take this off me. So it's definitely eyecatching for children.
As mentioned in the previous question, the portion control is a nice idea, but not enough to justify all the extra packaging, which i think it wasteful. Not enough to justify the price for some oats, sugar and a bit of dubious flavouring, either.
I have no difficulty measuring out my porridge for myself. I use 40g of oats and 250 ml of soya milk and have learnt to use a particular mug to measure these, so I don't need the scales. It's certainly not hard.
- Do you have any ideas about how Quaker could make the Oat So Simple Kids Porridge more interesting for your DC(s)?
Make it with actual chocolate and so that it tastes nice.