I agree re the house. There are a lot of new builds hitting the market in the area and Yawns house is particularly niche. She thought she was getting a bargain but it’s likely to be a millstone.
HMRC recently applied a rogue calculation to my account ( self employed) my accountant dealt with it rapidly but said that they were at a loss as to why they had done it. HMRC said it was an error but the cynic in me suspects that they are looking for engagement. For me it resulted in a very small underpayment ( that was incorrect I didn’t owe any money) but for others it could have resulted in a huge bill. Possibly the quick reaction by my accountant confirmed and answered questions about red flags raised. They don’t like accounts that fluctuate. I sold my business in 2019 and with the pandemic and a long bout of illness my accounts have fluctuated.
I’m still self employed so the overall turnover has reduced dramatically then yo-yod for the last 5 years. I would imagine the steady downward trajectory of Yawn’s accounts with the associated directors loan have finally triggered the red flags. I would imagine HMRC have a target this year, they periodically target certain industries, maybe MLMs are now on the list. Social media is a gift to HMRC that can be used to identify MLM members, and with all the income claims it would be very easy to investigate.
They also monitor accountants. So will look at a number of their clients if they have noticed inconsistencies. Yawn’s accountant handles a lot of FLP bots so just the fact that they are servicing directors loans year after year may already have highlighted a problem.
Im not an accountant but have been self employed my whole working life and have a good relationship with my accountant. She has been very informative about the inner workings of HMRC investigations. Particularly when selling my business, the rules around entrepreneurs tax are a bit vague so she warned me that I might be investigated. With the pandemic they have been chasing the huge amount of fraudulent claims during that period so I’m hopeful that 6 yrs on I’m unlikely to undergo investigation.
My take is that the FLP associated accounts sussed out that most of the referrals would be short lived customers. Maybe a year or twos business then they would be dissolved as bots gave up, only to be replaced by new bots. All could be set up easily and possibly, with the bots permission, they can access the sales data directly from FLP UK with the bots just submitting expenses. The bots all have their own online accounts so easy to extract an individuals data. The fact that FLP pays bots directly and they don’t appear to have individual payment terminals ( card machines) means that they probably don’t do cash. If they do they have to enter it manually onto their account.
I’ve always wondered why they all use the same accountant but it makes sense. Head office basically controls accounts via a third party, without the liability and PAYE/NI costs.