"no
You do not get to tell another woman that they are having mood swings when they are telling you that they are not
YOu do not get to ascribe behaviour you dont like to "peri" etc - this is just another facet of calling someone you dont get on with a "Narc" or suggesting someone you find difficult has ASD
People get angry without it being hormonal, people get to be difficult to you without it being ASD, and this fashion for splashing labels around onto any aspect of anyone's behaviour you dont like is a nasty, insidious form of bullying, and in the case of calling women "menopausal" or accusing them of having "mood swings" it is extremely detrimental to all women, and highly sexist
And the worst thing about this utter drivel is that it isn't even originating with men! a lot of the time. It is sexism from women directed at women"
No. Is it better just to tell them they were just horrendous to live with? They were just a bitch to be around? That their rage and mood swings appeared at the time of menopause and disappeared several years later? Coincidence??? You don't seem to grasp the point that I and other posters were making. My mum doesn't admit to being moody and full of rage. She doesn't admit to the numerous physical symptoms either, that affected the quality of her life to the point she was in bed for days on end. It's not that she is saying that it was something else. Her version of what life was like at that point in our lives is very different to these around her. And the reality is her denial of that affected our relationship. And also the relationship between her and my dad. And neither relationship ever fully recovered. There is little doubt in my mind that these things were all peri and menopause related.
I'm big enough and mature enough (in both ways) to accept that my family were bearing the brunt of my mood swings before I realised what it was. It didn't feel like mood swings to me at the start either - but that's what it was. Their feelings are valid. It was affecting them but not me. I am glad that it wasn't long before I realised what was going on and did something about it. Should my family, who knew I was acting very much out of character just put up with it, because it wasn't their place to say anything??
It isn't drivel. It's reality for lots of women. The sad thing is, in my mums day women were not allowed to express it. It was described as "their nerves". They weren't allowed to be open about how they were feeling. It was (and to some still is) seen as a weakness.
You know, it is actually ok to say peri and menopause exist. Denying it is sexist bullshit that causes misery to others. It's ok to go to the doctors and get help with any of the symptoms, if needed. It's ok to understand that some will genuinely not have many if any symptoms. But it's also ok to understand that lots will experience some if not many symptoms. Much like going through puberty or having periods or even childbirth. Every woman's experience is different.
It's like puberty in reverse. If your teenager is being hormonal do you not recognise that? And try and give them the tools to deal with the rollercoaster of hormones at that point in their lives? Or do you just think they are being awful/unreasonable/emotional etc? And not try to help them? How many teenagers recognise their their outburst is due to their hormones and act accordingly?