Wow, I love this thread, it is like a walk through my childhood.
I can tell you that I grew up in Switzerland (the French-speaking part, near Lausanne) and loved it - as a child and teenager, it was a great place to live, lots of freedom, access to arts and culture, concerts, a great education (as long as you are capable), beautiful countryside, and great access to the rest of Europe.
The weather is generally good, summers are warm, with lots of pools and lakes to swim in, and the winters are fantastic for skiing and ice skating,etc..
And the people of Switzerland, in general, are warm-hearted and welcoming - although you will find LOTS of exceptions.
School was very strict and you only had a few choices on where to go. If you did not pass the exams or make the grade, then you were stuck in a lower non-academic stream. And the things about private school is true - you went to private school if you were not able to cope with the state school system. You could not question teachers' decisions, and I still love the fact that my mother fought for us tooth and nail, when Swiss Moms would never have - it must have been so hard for her, but she stuck to her guns when unfair decisions were being made about our futures.
A great example is the fact that my brother, who still lives there, has twins, 4 year olds, one of which has been recognized as Gifted & Taleted by his doctors. However, the school teacher says that is not possible, because he asks too many questions, and that must mean he is not that clever. The poor child is desperate for extra stimulation, but the teacher will not give it. My DB is trying to find a suitable private school, but does not know how it might affect his future.
However, as an adult, I did not like it and took a one-way ticket out of there: people can be very small-minded and extremely bureaucratic, the racism when I lived there was bad, and quite overt. And women are not expected to achieve great things. They do, but against high odds, and the struggle is hard.
I know things are changing all the time, but believe me, this is Switzerland and it changes slowly, tres lentement.
All the things about rules are generally true: in apartments, no baths or showers after 10pm, no toilet flushing after 10pm, no hanging out washing on Sundays, no lawn mowing on Sundays - which is why expats tend to want their own houses after a while. I know all those rules by heart, i suppose you basically internalize them as second nature, as a Swiss.
The rules do work, and generally make for a good life, as long as they do not drive you completely potty in the meantime. You are not likely to see the sort of neighbor disputes that you see in the UK, or at least not as much, but that is because they are all very regulated - there will be a rule to resolve it, whether a noise complaint or a boundry complaint, etc...
Anyway, will come back to this later, as it is fascinating.