Please or to access all these features

Legal matters

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you have any legal concerns we suggest you consult a solicitor.

Will writing service v solicitor? Pros and cons?

6 replies

queenceleste · 09/11/2026 10:36

I would appreciate any advice.

I am an executor, along with a sibling, for an elderly relative’s will which needs to be updated as the existing will looks like a mess and is very out of date.

My co- executor wants to use a will writing service and I want to use a solicitor.

I think using a solicitor will protect us from more unforeseen issues than a will writing service.

I’d love to know what you think.

many thanks

OP posts:
Neilsfavechilli · 09/11/2026 10:57

Would it not be up to the relative who they want to use to update their will?

parietal · 09/11/2026 11:05

if there is anything complex, a solicitor is better. If the will just says 'I leave my entire estate equally between A and B', a will-writing service is probably OK.

be wary of charity will-writing services that put 5% or 10% of the estate to the charity in the will - some charities are very aggressive about valuing the estate as high as possible soon after the death and demanding their share when it takes time to sell a house etc. if there is a charity donation in the will, make it a fixed sum not a %.

queenceleste · 09/11/2026 11:09

The relative wants us to sort it out!

OP posts:
tarheelbaby · 09/11/2026 11:23

Since you describe the current will as 'a mess', I would choose a qualified solicitor who could read through the existing document thoroughly. You can then lodge the new will with the solicitor so that when the time comes, you know exactly where it is.
If your elderly relative is compos mentis and/or there's no POA, ER will need to interact directly with the solicitor, although I'm sure ER could stipulate that you and the other co-executor be involved. If that's not possible, ER can still give you a copy of the will.

My solicitor charged about £500 for two very simple wills. They visited DH in hospice to help him write his and also provided support (help with probate and providing certified copies) without any further fees after DH's death.

TLDR
The other thing you really need is a list of household information from your EH: Utility suppliers, bank accounts, location of property deed(s), monetary gifts and crucially, passwords!!
Your ER needs to check these annually and update with any changes.
I have these in sealed envelopes addressed to my executors.

Mosaic123 · 09/11/2026 17:38

If the relative doesn't have capacity then, sadly, the will remains as it is.

I believe the solicitor will want to see them on their own to feel confident they do have capacity and are not being influenced by anyone.
I'm not saying you are in today category, but it does happen.

Safer to use a solicitor for an elderly person I think.

SuperSugarHigh · 09/11/2026 17:47

Will writers do not have to be qualified in any way at all. Some are good; some really aren’t. They also go bust and dump their original documents in a field (true story).

New posts on this thread. Refresh page