Please or to access all these features

Legal matters

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you have any legal concerns we suggest you consult a solicitor.

Is it worth claiming compensation for this accident at work?

28 replies

BigOuchie · 04/11/2026 15:27

Last year I was in an accident at work. A structure collapsed and I was hit on the head, had concussion and scratches and bruises. Following the accident I was given no duty of care by the company (apparently as this suggests liability).

I was signed off sick by a doctor for 8 days with concussion, and went back too soon IMO.

This was the beginning of the end for me as I wasn’t happy with the way I was treated (first aider responded, manager wouldn’t come to see if I was ok as it suggested liability so I was told, and they tried to get me to drive home as they didn’t want to cough up for a taxi). Whilst being attended to by first aid, another manager said that they’d put in 2 requests for the fixture to be fixed, but it wasn’t responded too. When I returned to work it had all been fixed.

Anyway, I’ve left the company (big household name) and I have 3 years to make a claim. I put in my claim on their insurance and their response is for me to get a solicitor.

I have a copy of the CCTV accident, the first aid write up and it’s pretty clear to me that it is absolutely their fault and they were negligent. If I had been a bit further away the item would’ve gained momentum when falling and done very serious damage or killed me.

I’m a bit annoyed that I’ve got to get a solicitor when they were so at fault. It’s to put me off claiming I think. My only concern is that if I lost, I’d have to pay their fees.

Any suggestions?

OP posts:
BigOuchie · 04/11/2026 15:29

Sorry, they don’t think I have a case?

OP posts:
Baconisawesome · 04/11/2026 15:41

What compensation are you actually claiming for?
How were you financially compromised?

Kestonno · 04/11/2026 15:53

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Kestonno · 04/11/2026 15:54

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

AFigureWalks · 04/11/2026 15:56

Have a look at no win no feel legal representation on Trust Pilot.

Ineffable23 · 04/11/2026 15:56

Does your home insurance have any legal cover?

Badbadbunny · 04/11/2026 15:59

What are your losses that you wish to be compensated for? Did you suffer loss of income whilst off work? Are there long term disabilities that cause you to spend additional money, i.e. disability aids, adapted car, etc? Compensation is mostly to cover your additional costs/loss of income arising directly from the event, that you wouldn't otherwise have suffered. The actual element of compensation for "pain and suffering" is usually pretty small in the big scheme of things, and that maybe why the "no win, no fee" firms may not be interested, i.e. if the "compo" was only say £5k or £10k for pain and suffering, the no win, no fee firm's charges would probably be that or more - they're not going to do it for say 20% of £5k or £10k - they want bigger claims to cover their fees.

Mableandable · 04/11/2026 16:00

Nobody here can tell you despite thinking they can. You need to speak to an injury lawyer and they will decide if your case has merit.

bardabunga · 04/11/2026 16:18

You mention that another manager had already reported the problem with the structure twice before. Do you have that in writing, or would you be able to ask them for confirmation?

If so, then you have proof that the employer was definitely negligent in not rectifying the problem, and that their negligence caused your accident.

Secretseverywhere · 04/11/2026 16:30

I don’t think you will get a whopping amount as (I’m assuming) you’ve since recovered. You should be able to claim for any missed pay, any expenses incurred taxis, Small amount for actual injury.

Id recommend looking up no win no fee solicitors reviews. I’d make sure you are very honest with them. Apparently some encourage you to exaggerate and then the pursuer (you) gets landed with all the fees if other side successfully disputes any facts.

Passaggressfedup · 04/11/2026 19:30

You first thought needs to be what you want to be compensated for financially.

If you can evidence loss of income, medical costs, taxis etc... you might a better case if indeed you can also evidence they were neglectful (rather than you being reckless).

If you are looking for financial compensation of trauma, if might be a lot more difficult.

MustTryHarderAndHarder · 04/11/2026 19:54

AFigureWalks · 04/11/2026 15:56

Have a look at no win no feel legal representation on Trust Pilot.

But there were cases on Rip off Britain there were cases where the injured person was left having to pay costs when they lost because there's often a loophole in the agreement.

Kepler22B · 04/11/2026 19:58

Are you claiming constructive dismissal as you felt unsafe?

Was the incident properly reported?

Beenaroundabit · 04/11/2026 20:00

Unless you suffered a financial loss there is no chance of a claim op. Maybe a refund for a taxi, or removal of sick days from your record if it was their fault.

A hospital error directly lead to my mum's death and because she had no financial dependents not a penny could be claimed. You have no chance at all for a bumped head, sorry.

Mcdhotchoc · 04/11/2026 20:03

Before you sign a no win, no fee carefully check if you have legal cover anywhere. On your contents policy, packaged with your bank account, on your motor insurance. It will save you handing 25% of your damages over.
But yes on the face of it it sounds fine.

Seainasive · 04/11/2026 20:05

You should definitely make a claim. it’s the only way to get employers to improve their processes.

We used the legal cover included in our home insurance when my husband had an accident at work. His injuries were less serious than yours and he got just under £4,000.

Limehawkmoth · 04/11/2026 20:14

Beenaroundabit · 04/11/2026 20:00

Unless you suffered a financial loss there is no chance of a claim op. Maybe a refund for a taxi, or removal of sick days from your record if it was their fault.

A hospital error directly lead to my mum's death and because she had no financial dependents not a penny could be claimed. You have no chance at all for a bumped head, sorry.

Hmm …compensation is not just losses. There is the element of pain, emotional distress, inconvenience and just plain simple that they appear to have been negligent in their duty of care.
a court caps at £10k and there are pretty good guidelines you can search online to guide over what level you would be awarded. In her case she could put in two complaints for compensation imho ..one for the injury and pain and one for the negligence and denial. She appears to have good evidence for both . And both could go through small claims court.

NimbleTaupeTiger · 04/11/2026 20:18

Get in touch with the Health and Safety Executive and take their advice. They're the arbiters of workplace accidents.

Fortuity · 04/11/2026 20:36

You really should get a solicitor. Make sure it is someone from a a firm which is a member of the Association of Personal Injury Lawyers. I suspect the insurers are just trying to bluff you out of pursuing this, but if you don't have lawyers they are likely to run rings around you.

Fortuity · 04/11/2026 20:41

Beenaroundabit · 04/11/2026 20:00

Unless you suffered a financial loss there is no chance of a claim op. Maybe a refund for a taxi, or removal of sick days from your record if it was their fault.

A hospital error directly lead to my mum's death and because she had no financial dependents not a penny could be claimed. You have no chance at all for a bumped head, sorry.

You or your mother were badly advised if you were told this. The claim would have been on behalf of your mother, with any damages going into her estate, regardless of whether she had any defendants. Assuming negligence could be proved, the hospital's insurers would be liable for damages for pain and suffering to your mother and for any other losses she suffered; also they would be liable to the family for damages for bereavement and for associated expenses including funeral costs.

If it was less than three years ago, you should get urgent advice on making a claim.

Limehawkmoth · 04/11/2026 20:46

I am unclear as to why they’ve told you to go through a solicitor, that’s not their call to make. In law “You have a legal right to represent yourself and handle the claim directly, often referred to as acting as a "litigant in person." While companies or their insurers might prefer dealing with a legal professional to ensure paperwork is handled correctly, they cannot legally reject your claim or refuse to communicate with you simply because you do not have a solicitor”

so, if you have clear evidence, and you are tenacious and determined and have righteous anger energy, continue to pursue it yourself. But you also need to be organised, detailed, pedantic and accurate, in writing.

you need to go online and swot up on how to word a formal legal complaint. As per earlier post IMHO you maybe have two complaints you can then claim for, but position them as two separate complaints. What, when who, how . Then state clearly what £ you’re claiming for eachm using guidelines you can look up on line that courts would use. Give evidence in the form of a personal impact statement, to support that clearly and unemotionally in writing. Back that up with medical certificates and reports. Also hunt out relavent section of H&S law covering duty of care, failure to take action on repairs etc to dangerous equipment or workplace, failure to investigate accidents correctly etc. quote elevent bits to them.

Make sure you know difference and rules around perosnal damages, loss of income, recovery of costs type claims for money. It matters! It also affects tax liability, so don’t get it worng. Don’t be greedy on the perosnal damage stuff…use the court guidelines ..it’s capped at very max at £10k per complaint and even with your experience it’ll be less than that considerably. Being realistic will be much more tempting to them, in face of clear evidence, to settle out of court than risk of them going to court, and a court that’s deeply unhappy they’ve dragged you there. If you have two or more complaints that are separate, and you can show you are seeking compensation for two different impacts, then you clearly can get more money overall, as it’s £10k cap on each and every unique claim!

Tell them in covering letter you are exercising your legal rights to pursue directly as “litigant in person”. Give them 21-28 days to respond (you decide) in writing to your home address provided.

do not correspond by email ever. Do not talk on phone.everythibg now goes in writing.

send letter as signed for recorded delivery to the most senior person in company. CEO etc. not to HR or complaints. State you have already tried to resolve but your complaint has been dismissed despite the clear evidence.

don’t threaten them. Don’t do any what ifs on if they don’t reply. If needed you may need to go to small claims, but don’t state this unless they don’t respond,

sadly I’ve been through a 4 year complaint with a water company that flooded my home 20 times. I couldn’t afford a solicitor, as anything to do with water companies solicitors charge £4000 in advance to even talk to you. I won. It was an obscene amount of money they had to pay out, (it did include recovery of costs as well) given it comes form their customer bills. But I did win without a solicitor or even going to court in the end. It was a nasty, exhausting and anxiety laden experience. But you can do it without a solicitor.

above all, be sure you know what you’re really wanting. No amount of money in personal damages will make up for what happened ! Not in uk courts. So much of this is a token gesture of payment that validates how you were made to feel and the shock it gave you, and their disregard for duty of care in terms of previous alerts to itssue. Make that clear in the letter. The failure to admit their failure in duty of care, and lack of responsibility and accountability.

but, as people say do check your insurance policies, some do cover personal legal issues! Mine just didn’t cover someone else flooding my home that was denying they were responsible! To persuade the claim yourself will take a lot of time and energy and precision. But you can do it if you put time and intelligence into play.

ThisLivelyRaven · 04/11/2026 20:49

It will all depend on your financial losses, and how it has effected your life since the accident

Limehawkmoth · 04/11/2026 21:01

ThisLivelyRaven · 04/11/2026 20:49

It will all depend on your financial losses, and how it has effected your life since the accident

People keep saying this.
compensation claims cover multiple facets

  1. personal damage known as “general damages” : capped at £10k normally, per claim, but covers mental impact, stress, anxiety and all sorts of other things. this doesn’t mean it’s still affecting your life since the accident. Ok payments will be much higher if it does. But at lowest level payments that simply isn’t true. There are court guidelines (JCG) clearly laid out as to what level of that £10k is recommended to courts to pay for what sort of damages
  2. recovery of costs or “special damages” : literally that, getting back anything you had to pay out for. That could include therapy etc or even transport costs to hospital . They need receipts generally or evidence you’ve paid out.
  3. Loss of income/earnings : if she took unpaid time off work. But as such it’s subject to income tax . Again would need documents to prove loss of income.
fishingtime · 04/11/2026 21:10

You need to speak with a solicitor. Find a reputable no win no fee solicitor to advise you. I am currently almost 2 years into a personal injury claim. Some of what’s been said about financial loss above is incorrect but your solicitor will explain that to you, if they feel they can take your case on. It takes months and months though. I am looking at another 6-8 months for my claim. I am in Scotland though but my case is versus an English insurance company.

Andandoporlasplayas · 04/11/2026 21:12

As others have said, I suggest speaking to a specialist personal injury solicitor to establish whether there’s a case worth pursuing.

But I’d also look into possibly reporting it to the HSE, particularly given the previous warnings and the potential risk to other employees who still work there.

Do you know if the incident was RIDDOR reportable, and, if so, reported (Eg RIDDOR Over-7-day incapacitation of a worker)