Please or to access all these features

Legal matters

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you have any legal concerns we suggest you consult a solicitor.

Car accident compensation stress

10 replies

Floridamonths · 28/10/2026 22:56

I was in a car accident last year. The other party took full responsibility. They were at fault. They accepted liability.

I had multiple injuries in the accident.

I injured both my hands. When I was assessed the doctor (working for the insurers) said it would likely take 4 months for me to recover from my hand injuries. It took double that time. I was in considerable pain and had reduced strength in my hands. I have young children - I'm a single mum- my injuries made things very difficult.

The insurer sent me for physio. I think I was offered 8 sessions. I went to 4. I didn't find it very helpful and I found it very difficult to get there- one of my children was very unwell at the time (in hospital).

The insurer had told me that cost of physio would come out of final claim.

I thought I'd get more money by not going, it wasn't helping and I couldn't get there anyway.

I realise I was stupid not to go.

They are now saying I can only claim compensation for my hand injuries for 4 months. They are basing that bit of the claim on me being recovered after 4 months. But it took me 8 months to recover.

Because I didn't attend all my physio they are saying if I had, I would have recovered in original time scale (4 months).

But I suffered a lot for over 8 months. I did tell them about my injuries many times on the phone.

Is there anything I can do? I know I was stupid not going to full course of physio but it was last thing on my mind when my child was ill and I didn't think it would be a big deal.

I was in a lot of pain for a long time and feel gutted I will lose out on money.

Can anyone advise?

Many Thanks

OP posts:
prh47bridge · 29/10/2026 00:26

You were required to mitigate your losses by taking reasonable steps to quicken your recovery. That includes attending the physio sessions.

If you had attended the sessions and it had taken 8 months to recover, that would have allowed an increased claim. As you did not attend them, the only way you will get any more is if you can get medical evidence that your failure to attend the physio sessions made no difference to your recovery time - that it would have taken 8 months even if you had attended the physio sessions.

Savvysix1984 · 29/10/2026 00:57

Did you have your own lawyer/ insurance company working for you?

cityliving99 · 29/10/2026 04:25

You are lucky. My husband was in a hit and run. The other driver was not insured. We had no help and my husband had to organise everything. Our car was written off. He sustained a fractured knee and other various injuries and he only got a small amount through a government scheme.
it was all very stressful and 2 years on is still suffering with his knee.

ExpectMore · 29/10/2026 04:53

Floridamonths · 28/10/2026 22:56

I was in a car accident last year. The other party took full responsibility. They were at fault. They accepted liability.

I had multiple injuries in the accident.

I injured both my hands. When I was assessed the doctor (working for the insurers) said it would likely take 4 months for me to recover from my hand injuries. It took double that time. I was in considerable pain and had reduced strength in my hands. I have young children - I'm a single mum- my injuries made things very difficult.

The insurer sent me for physio. I think I was offered 8 sessions. I went to 4. I didn't find it very helpful and I found it very difficult to get there- one of my children was very unwell at the time (in hospital).

The insurer had told me that cost of physio would come out of final claim.

I thought I'd get more money by not going, it wasn't helping and I couldn't get there anyway.

I realise I was stupid not to go.

They are now saying I can only claim compensation for my hand injuries for 4 months. They are basing that bit of the claim on me being recovered after 4 months. But it took me 8 months to recover.

Because I didn't attend all my physio they are saying if I had, I would have recovered in original time scale (4 months).

But I suffered a lot for over 8 months. I did tell them about my injuries many times on the phone.

Is there anything I can do? I know I was stupid not going to full course of physio but it was last thing on my mind when my child was ill and I didn't think it would be a big deal.

I was in a lot of pain for a long time and feel gutted I will lose out on money.

Can anyone advise?

Many Thanks

You’re contradicting yourself. You say you “were in a lot of pain for a long time” yet going to the physio “was the last thing on your mind”. How can that have been, given it was the treatment for what was causing you pain?

I don’t entirely believe your story so suspect the insurers may not also.

FrangipaniBlue · 29/10/2026 05:12

The thing with physio is that it’s not just about the sessions you attend but that you follow any advice and guidance they give you at home as well.

it does t sound like you did that either?

So as another poster said, from the insurers perspective you haven’t done anything to help yourself get better as quickly as possible, so why should they pay out for the extended period

wanderingwillows · 29/10/2026 06:36

It’s a question of whether you failed to mitigate your loss. If you have evidence of what your child was going through with their health at the time and you’re willing to explain in your witness statement about why you stopped going, then the court might have some sympathy with you. But ultimately you’ll be penalised for not helping yourself to get better by completing the physio and may well be limited to the 4 months it should have taken, had you completed the physio.

Passaggressfedup · 29/10/2026 09:20

Who decided that physio wasn't helping? You or the physio (or other medical practitioner). It sometimes takes all sessions to take place before you really start to see the benefits.

It sounds that you couldn't be bothered to and that's prompted you to stop rather than official evidence it wasn't working.

That or you never really needed it in the first place, and you only agree to hope for financial compensation.

Whaleandsnail6 · 29/10/2026 10:18

So, their stance is that if you had continued with the physio and treatment plan, you would have recovered in 4 months but because you didn't stick to their plan, you took 8 months. Effectively, slowed down your own recovery. You admitted that you thought that not going to physio would result in a higher pay out...thats certainly backfired

I can see why this is their argument. Did you discuss with the physio that you didn't think it working and take advice? Or did you just stop going?

Floridamonths · 29/10/2026 18:16

I'm really surprised why anyone would think I would lie on an anonymous forum. But clearly people do think that. I didn't contradict myself- my child was very very sick in hospital - that was my priority. I was also in significant pain. It was a scary time.

Yes, I did follow advice from physio though there was very little advice. He was very chilled and didn't really give impression it would make a difference.

I was extremely sleep deprived and utterly focused on my child. I had no idea that it would make any difference if I attended every appointment or not.

I am stupid not dishonest.

OP posts:
Pulledbluecurtain · 29/10/2026 18:40

I totally get you, when your child is ill and you're stressed the first things to go are things for you and you feel like you can do the physio exercises yourself. I haven't had physio myself but my son has and some are brilliant but there was one who really wasn't and it was a waste of time, I say that as someone who knows how vital physio can be.

In terms of your claim, it's about evidence and the physio would have been evidence. Did you see anyone else, any medical professional? If not then you can't prove continuing pain and the lack of attendance would be supporting evidence to the other side.

It may be one of those things but you did the best you could in difficult circumstances.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread