Please or to access all these features

Legal matters

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you have any legal concerns we suggest you consult a solicitor.

Family Court issues

11 replies

UnbrokenCare · 24/10/2026 09:00

Let me be honest straight of the bat AI drafted this, I have a tbi and long winded writing is hard for me

I'm honestly at a complete loss here and hoping someone who's been through similar or knows how the family courts and social services work can offer some advice.

Sorry in advance because this is going to be long, but there's quite a bit of history that I think is relevant.

I have children with my ex. There's a significant history of domestic abuse, mainly coercive control rather than physical violence towards me, and previous involvement with social services.

Without going into too much detail, there were some pretty serious safeguarding concerns when the children were younger, including injuries. This resulted in previous court involvement and restrictions on my ex being allowed to care for the children unsupervised.

So this isn't a case of me suddenly raising concerns because we aren't together anymore. There's a documented history going back years.

Fast forward to more recent family court proceedings and he's now been granted unsupervised contact, including overnight stays and holidays.

I've had nothing but issues with how Cafcass and the court have dealt with things. There was evidence that came to light after the Cafcass report which I feel was extremely relevant, yet it wasn't properly considered. Even with the previous history, Cafcass supported unsupervised contact. My ex managed to convince Cafcass I was the problem and the judge aligned with Cafcass which makes all of this more harder to get across

Since contact started, it's been one thing after another.

The kids are regularly kept out until stupidly late, there's been ongoing issues with basic care, hygiene, meals, supervision and generally what's appropriate for young children.

I've raised concerns about these things, but they always seem to get brushed off as parenting differences.

And I do understand that parents do things differently. I don't expect him to parent exactly how I do, but surely there's a point where it goes beyond that?

Anyway, more recently things have escalated.

There have now been two separate injuries involving different children, during separate periods of contact.

With the first, my child was injured during an activity involving their father. They were clearly struggling afterwards, but I wasn't informed and no medical advice was sought. They were still expected to carry on with normal activities despite being injured.

I ended up having to get medical attention when I found out. Thankfully it wasn't anything broken, but there was an injury that needed rest and time to recover.

What makes it worse is that even after this, my ex continued taking them out doing quite physically demanding things despite knowing they'd been told to rest.

Then, after another contact, I noticed some pretty significant bruising on one of my other children.

It was in a location that immediately concerned me, particularly given what it looked like, and my child couldn't explain how it had happened.

I initially kept an eye on it, but it became more noticeable over the following days, so I contacted the school and arranged for the GP to examine it.

The school were concerned and told me to make a referral to social services. The GP documented the injury and also had concerns. He said that if contact was continuing, he'd have needed to notify the police.

By this point I'd already decided I wasn't comfortable sending them back until someone had actually looked into what was going on.

I contacted social services, told them I was suspending contact and explained that I'd be making an urgent application to the family court.

Initially, they seemed really concerned. A strategy discussion was arranged and I was told the children would be seen.

Then suddenly everything changed.

The case has been stepped down to a Child and Family Assessment, and the social worker has basically told me they're not looking any further into the bruising.

Apparently, because my child hasn't said how it happened and another child mentioned they'd been playing together, that's enough for them not to pursue it.

She also started explaining how she'd expect the bruising to look if it had happened in a particular way.

This is the bit I'm really struggling with.

Since when does a child not disclosing something mean there isn't anything to be concerned about?

I'm not saying I know what happened. I don't. That's literally why I want someone to look into it properly.

And surely a social worker making assumptions about how an injury should look isn't the same as having it assessed by someone medically qualified in safeguarding injuries?

The other injury has pretty much been dismissed as well because nothing was broken.

But surely the issue isn't just how serious the injury turned out to be? It's also the circumstances around it and the fact medical attention wasn't sought when it was needed?

When I eventually spoke to my ex about the injuries, he offered different possible explanations, but nothing that actually established what happened.

And this is what really gets to me. There's already a history of serious safeguarding concerns, including previous restrictions on him caring for the children, yet every new incident seems to be treated like it's completely unrelated to anything that's happened before.

Surely at some point the overall picture has to matter?

I made an urgent application to change the Child Arrangements Order and asked for an interim decision because I didn't feel I could safely send the children back before any of this had been properly considered.

The court wouldn't deal with it without notice to him and said there would be an urgent hearing.

But I've still had absolutely nothing in terms of an interim decision.

I've chased the court, explained what's happened and why I need something in place before the next contact, but I'm getting nowhere.

Meanwhile, the social worker has warned me I could be held in contempt of court for withholding contact.

So what exactly am I supposed to do?

The school had concerns. The GP had concerns. I've reported everything to the appropriate people, I've made the court application and I've explained why I've suspended contact.

Yet somehow I'm now the one being warned about the consequences, while the actual injuries don't seem to be getting looked into.

I'm also worried about him just turning up and collecting the children when contact is next due because the existing order is still in place, and he's already indicated he intends to do exactly that.

I know I can't just disregard a court order, and I know there can be consequences for withholding contact. I'm fully aware of that, which is why I've tried to go through the proper channels.

But equally, what am I meant to do? Just send them back and hope nothing else happens?

I feel like I'm being told I'm responsible for protecting my children, but when I actually try to do that, I'm the one potentially facing consequences.

Is it normal for social services to decide not to pursue an unexplained injury simply because a child hasn't disclosed how it happened?

Can I request a management review while the Child and Family Assessment is still ongoing?

Shouldn't the previous safeguarding history be taken into account when looking at new concerns?

Is there anything else I can actually do to get an interim decision from the family court?

And what happens if he turns up at school to collect them before the court has made that decision?

Has anyone been in a similar position where they've raised genuine safeguarding concerns but ended up feeling like they're the one being treated as the problem?

I'm not trying to stop the children having a relationship with their father. I just want them safe, and I want someone to actually look at what's happening rather than dismissing everything individually.

I'm genuinely running out of ideas at this point and would really appreciate some advice.

OP posts:
clareykb · 24/10/2026 09:05

Hi OP I'm a social worker Strategy meetings are multi agency so health and school would have been asked what they thought and a majority decision made so it wouldn't have just been for the social worker to say. Do you know if they did a section 47 report after the strategy?

Wish44 · 24/10/2026 09:17

Sorry you are going through this op.

how old are the children ?

i agree that given there were past incidents of him hurting rhe children it seems wrong that this is not being considered now.

I have been through the family courts. All in all I was lucky in my experience but contact with the father seems to be accepted as being best and I don’t know why.

good luck and your children are lucky to have you fighting their corner. Having one good parent will mean they are ok in the long run

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 24/10/2026 09:23

clareykb · 24/10/2026 09:05

Hi OP I'm a social worker Strategy meetings are multi agency so health and school would have been asked what they thought and a majority decision made so it wouldn't have just been for the social worker to say. Do you know if they did a section 47 report after the strategy?

She said 'stepped down to a CFA' so I am assuming the outcome of the strat was either outcome to assessment or a s47 that didn't proceed. They presumably determined no CP medical was required.

OP I can tell you that unless police are investigating a crime or social services are putting a child protection plan in place the court will almost definitely not view those injuries as enough to restrict contact. You're at risk of being reprimanded by the court due to stopping contact I'm afraid.

Passaggressfedup · 24/10/2026 11:33

So what exactly am I supposed to do?
Allow contact. The courts and SS will only consider stopping contact where there is evidence of harm. The two incidents you've mentioned don't fall under this category.

The first one happens all the time. My son broke his arm three times and each time I didn't think it was a break. I'd taken him a number of times to A&E when he's told me he was much more in pain than when he had broken is arm and it was just bad bruising. He used to injure himself all the time playing football. All this is normal life for some boys.

Same with the bruise. Kids get unexplained bruises often. My DD did. It turned out she is a massive kicker in her sleep and injured herself that way.

The threshold for concern is much higher than that. You might be worried, you might consider these events worrying, but the law doesn't. You need to stick to the law.

Keep a diary of any concerns, but so far, it's not worrisome enough to consider stopping unsupervised contact.

UnbrokenCare · 24/10/2026 12:56

I don't know. It was conducted with the police and health professionals not the school. The school were the ones who was concerned about father even seeing them. They also didn't go through all the other safeguarding issues given too them, I don't think they got the email in time so they only went off one incident as well

OP posts:
UnbrokenCare · 24/10/2026 12:57

clareykb · 24/10/2026 09:05

Hi OP I'm a social worker Strategy meetings are multi agency so health and school would have been asked what they thought and a majority decision made so it wouldn't have just been for the social worker to say. Do you know if they did a section 47 report after the strategy?

I don't know. It was conducted with the police and health professionals not the school. The school were the ones who was concerned about father even seeing them. They also didn't go through all the other safeguarding issues given too them, I don't think they got the email in time so they only went off one incident as well

OP posts:
UnbrokenCare · 24/10/2026 13:00

Wish44 · 24/10/2026 09:17

Sorry you are going through this op.

how old are the children ?

i agree that given there were past incidents of him hurting rhe children it seems wrong that this is not being considered now.

I have been through the family courts. All in all I was lucky in my experience but contact with the father seems to be accepted as being best and I don’t know why.

good luck and your children are lucky to have you fighting their corner. Having one good parent will mean they are ok in the long run

With this parent 10,8 and 4. I had such a positive experience when it came to my 12 year old dad but difference is he was violent so it was easier to prove but the fact that they've not taken the previous injuries to my son into account especially when it aligns with the issues that are still present is mind-blowing

OP posts:
UnbrokenCare · 24/10/2026 13:03

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 24/10/2026 09:23

She said 'stepped down to a CFA' so I am assuming the outcome of the strat was either outcome to assessment or a s47 that didn't proceed. They presumably determined no CP medical was required.

OP I can tell you that unless police are investigating a crime or social services are putting a child protection plan in place the court will almost definitely not view those injuries as enough to restrict contact. You're at risk of being reprimanded by the court due to stopping contact I'm afraid.

The police aren't investigating a crime but have done their own safeguarding referalls as I've had regular contact due to separate non mol breaches. Yeah it was stepped down as it didn't meet s47 criteria.

That's what I'm concerned about as cumatively the risks are present but where social aren't concerned despite the father since given two explanations on the cause and it not being playfighting between my sons I know the court won't take it well

OP posts:
namechangedtemporarily123 · 24/10/2026 13:12

I’d be wary OP. Services such as school and social services seem to melt away when court becomes involved. My Cafcass officer didn’t even speak to social services, or CAMHS, or the school (who reported an incident they witnessed, to social services.) They all voiced concern and social services told me to stop contact, but all just start shrugging and saying how terrible it is, but didn’t really fight, or have the tools to fight for my child’s safety. It’s like they’re scared of getting involved in litigation.

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 24/10/2026 13:21

namechangedtemporarily123 · 24/10/2026 13:12

I’d be wary OP. Services such as school and social services seem to melt away when court becomes involved. My Cafcass officer didn’t even speak to social services, or CAMHS, or the school (who reported an incident they witnessed, to social services.) They all voiced concern and social services told me to stop contact, but all just start shrugging and saying how terrible it is, but didn’t really fight, or have the tools to fight for my child’s safety. It’s like they’re scared of getting involved in litigation.

Social services don't 'fight' in court in private proceedings that's not their role. They will provide reports and evidence as directed but the 'fight' is yours/your lawyer. They 'melt away' because family court is not their remit unless they are already involved due to safeguarding concerns and even then they have no decision making power at all.

Passaggressfedup · 24/10/2026 18:54

Agencies often don't voice concern. They voice a potential concern that might need to be investigated. They do because they professionally have a duty to do so.

It might come across as them giving their views or advice but that's not what they are there for. SS will carry out an investigation if it meets their criteria for one. If they then decide they don't have serious concerns for the children, they won't take further.

Cafcass make recommendations as to concerns specifically relates to contact/residency.

It's really hard when you believe your kids are being harmed, even if not seriously, but at the same time, the courts have to deal with resident parents who will claim the children are in serious danger when indeed, the issue is no more than differences in parenting, and that is an issue that the court don't get involved with as that is the choice we make when we decide to have children with whoever we've picked as the other parent.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page