Not sure if this is the correct topic. However the crux of the matter is DH attended a work charity do and bid over the odds (stupidly but it was a mix of bravado and alcohol) and won an item. It'll be suffice to say it's signed world cup top from last year. Anyway the item has now been devalued as other party goer signed the shirt whilst DH wasn't looking. Now he has been left with an item which has been depreciated in a moment of madness. The culprit has offered to have it professionally cleaned and I'd think that would be hard to do without devaluing the authenticity of the shirt as it's meant to be signed but just not by this person! To make matters worse the culprit is a valued customer for Dh's company and as such can't be upset as they might lose his business!