Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Home ed

Find advice from other parents on our Homeschool forum. You may also find our round up of the best online learning resources useful.

I was homeschooled as a kid and I'm struggling massively in life as an adult. Was my HE experience atypical?

100 replies

BookerDeWitt · 19/10/2014 03:43

Hi everyone. I've been searching the internet for a homeschool forum that is intended for people in the UK. I am very glad to have found this forum. I would like to share my experience of being home-educated. I went to primary school as a child, but never went to secondary school at all because my mum decide to homeschool me. She didn't want me to go to the local underperforming state comp which, at the time, had a poor reputation locally. She tried to get me in to a private school, but unfortunately I wasn't accepted. My mum seemed to have a fixed belief that state schools are crap and private schools are amazing. I also believed that to be true myself at the time. Thus began my homeschooling odyssey. If I had foreseen the destructive impact not going to school would have on me, I wouldn't have allowed it to happen. I would have made absolutely sure that I was in school. I had no idea that my life was going to be completely ruined. I'd like to explain exactly why it didn't work out for me.

To start with, I wasn't monitored at all by anyone from the local council or school. I ended up being completely forgotten about. I have no idea if my mum informed them that I was being HEd. She said that she did, but I received no contact from them until I was 16. My parents got a letter from someone at the LEA asking about how my education was going. Apparently they went to a meeting with this person and had to tell lies about me. They said I was thriving, being educated adequately and had an active social life. None of those things were remotely true. The education I received at home was completely inadequate. My mum has no educational qualifications at all, and was unable to deliver anything close to the standard of education I would have received at school (even an academically underperforming school). Many subjects were skipped entirely, such as chemistry, physics and foreign languages. I was usually left alone to read textbooks or write essays. There were no lessons and very little teaching was performed, as far as I can recall. By the time I got to 16, I was completely unprepared for doing any GCSEs. Even if I had been ready, my mum seemed to have no idea how I would be able to actually sit any exams without being in school. I didn't know either. From what I have read, there's a lot of hoop-jumping involved in trying to sit exams as an external candidate. The onus wasn't on me to find a place to sit the exams though, just like it wasn't up to me to provide my own education. That was my mum's job, and she sadly wasn't equipped for either task. I don't want to be too hard on her as she had no support from anyone. My dad was around but he just left her to get on with it. I completely missed out on doing any GCSEs or any other qualifications. I guess I fell through the system.

As tremendously damaging as my 'education' was to my life prospects, that is only one half of the story. I missed out on everything by not being in school. Friendships, relationships, experiences... I missed out on all of those completely. I had no friends or social life away from school, at all. The friends I had in primary moved on to secondary and made new friends, so they didn't need me after that. I ended up being completely isolated. As I had no siblings, cousins, or friends, my social opportunities were effectively non-existent outside of school. I talked to someone online a while back and they said it was my parents' fault for allowing me to become so isolated. No efforts were made to contact any other homeschooling families. I have never actually met another person who was homeschooled. I feel alienated from the 99%+ of people in the UK who actually went to school. I've spent all of my birthdays since I was 11 completely alone. No parties, and no friends or family to socialise with. My 18th and 21st were spent in my room at home feeling lonely and miserable (I'm 23 now). I've also had a facebook account since 2007, but have zero friends on it. I don't think I'll ever find anyone to add as a friend.

I believe very strongly that none of this would have happened if I had went to school. I would have been properly educated and I wouldn't have ended up being a friendless recluse, feeling completely rejected and ostracised by society. Secondary school provides a proven, tried and tested pathway that prepares a person for the next stage of their education. It also provides the platform a person needs as they adjust to adulthood and being independent. It also gives you a structure, purpose and routine in your daily life. I haven't really had any of those since I left school. Also, colleges and universities are specifically designed for people who attended and finished school. As I didn't, any hopes I might have harboured of continuing in education were extinguished. I have no work experience, qualifications or professional skills, which makes me about as attractive to potential employers as an Ebola victim. I believe I would have acquired those skills and qualifications quite easily if I had went to school. Instead, I have none of them and I'm going nowhere in life as a result. I recently looked up a few people on facebook who I knew growing up. All of them are thriving and excelling in life. They all went to school. The only people I looked up who aren't thriving or excelling are either dead or in prison. I don't think my prospects are any better than theirs. I feel like I'm serving my own life sentence - a lifetime of loneliness, misery and worthlessness.

I just can't understand what the benefits are of homeschooling. As far as I'm concerned there was no reason at all for me not to be in school. I had no disabilities or special educational needs. I was actually one of the top dogs academically in primary school. Is anyone out there actually doing well in life after being homeschooled? Can I just ask, how did you avoid the pitfalls that have befallen me? In particular, how the hell did you meet other kids without being in school? I have had no social life since I left school more than 13 years ago. I have actually barely had a life at all. I have no future and nothing to look forward to. I have no purpose in life beyond eating, sleeping and trying to exist from one day to another. I also hate telling anyone that I was homeschooled, not just because it's destroyed me, but because of how uncommon it is. I'm from a rough city in the north of England and home education is almost completely unheard of here. Is it more common in more affluent areas of the country? Also, I've talked to several people online who went to school and are doing fantastically well in life, and they have all basically said the same thing about it - that secondary school was an incredibly important period in their lives. I read a post on Mumsnet recently from a teacher who said they could not understand why homeschooling parents believe they are able to deliver the rich curriculum or social opportunities that school provides. I can certainly empathise with that based on my own experience of HE.

I just wanted to get all of this my chest. I found it cathartic. I only want to hear from people who were homeschooled or are homeschooling their own kids.

OP posts:
saraclara · 25/10/2022 22:28

Damn. A zombie thread

spinachmonster · 25/10/2022 22:31

OP you are very brave for posting and you write so well. Maybe you could write a book about your experiences one day? It's certainly very unusual (and cruel 😭)

My parents have an incredibly successful friend, his motto is, "Nothing is impossible, so aim high".

You could do a vision board for how you want your life to be. I also enjoyed the book 'The Secret.'

NoYouSirName · 25/10/2022 22:35

You have a very rosy view of secondary school, OP. I mean this kindly but I think because you haven’t been, you are imagining friendships and good teaching and careers guidance. The reality for me and many others was being left to it, bullied relentlessly by pupils and staff alike, and no careers advice whatsoever.

You can do an access course now or GCSE courses. You haven’t missed the boat there. You can also go and make friends. HE isn’t responsible for any social difficulties as secondary school can make these worse, not better. You may have struggled anyway. But your future is within your control now, it’s up to you what path your education takes.

NoYouSirName · 25/10/2022 22:36

Oh damn. Zombie.

Eyerollcentral · 25/10/2022 23:05

Sure Jan 🙄

WorrieaboutFIL · 25/10/2022 23:11

Hi OP your experience sounds awful bit just wanted to say I had no friends after school and university. I only made friends through restaurant work. You are young enough to turn things around, if you try an access course you could even study medicine. I'm rooting for you!

GinWithChocolate · 25/10/2022 23:29

ZOMBIE THREAD - OP HAS NOT POSTED FOR 8 YEARS

danidoodles · 26/10/2022 07:11

Its such a shame the OP diddnt reply. I posted sometime ago, wishing she would reply as her experience was almost identical to my own.
Its so so very debilitating 😪

Ohbluepeter · 26/10/2022 07:47

At 30 years old I went to the careers advisor at the local college because I wanted to improve my exam results, I am wondering if they would be able to help you, they may know others in the educational system to put you in touch with that can help you get where you want to be.

theres lot of good advice on this post and I hope you’re on the right track to happiness soon. 💐

bofski14 · 26/10/2022 08:12

You certainly didn't have a typical HE experience and I'm sorry that your parents did not facilitate it properly for you. Also I'm sorry that your local council did not complete the proper checks that all HE families should have in place. But like everyone else has said, it is not too late. You are still very young. Go to college and start the next chapter of your life.

Unseelie · 26/10/2022 08:13

I’m so sorry OP. You were massively let down by your parents, what you describe is neglect and the lack of education is illegal. I guess your parents have their own psychological issues that led them to that path. They loved you and did the best they could for you, but their best wasn’t very good.

I was home ed for primary, not secondary. Like you my dad left mum to it, but unlike your mum, mine was obsessed with finding me a social life and as well as home ed groups we went to many church activities (despite being atheist), brownies, football clubs etc etc. I have come to believe that home ed is not necessarily bad but to be done well it costs a lot of money for the activities. I still would rathet have gone to a good school though 😬

You’ve lived one life but you don’t know what would have happened if you’d lived the other one. Every year some kids are badly beaten up, some even raped, at school. Maybe you’d have had a lovely time or maybe you’d have been badly bullied and traumatised for years. We don’t know.

All we can change is the present and the future, not the past. You’re isolated and lonely and undereducated. You have the self awareness and wisdom to see those things must change. In your shoes I would

  • Join a local church (or temple or buddhist group or whatever), even if you’re atheist. Religious people are welcoming and you need the community. Introduce yourself to the vicar, explain your situation and that you’d love to get invilved with the community, and offer to volunteer. Ev maybe join the choir.
  • On Facebook, use the search bar to look for groups that you might be interested in. Say you’re in Sussex, search things like sussex walking group or sussex ramblers or sussex community or sussex writers or sussex book club. Also look at meetups.com. Find a way to get regular meet-ups in your life and when you do meet people, don’t show them how lonely and angry you are, just be pleasant, if you want to start practicing making friends.
  • See a local adult education centre / careers advisor and ask about how to get gcse maths and english.
  • If you can, get a job, any job. Ask your local supermarket / garden centre / high st shops / preschool if they have anything like that you can train for.
Unseelie · 26/10/2022 08:54

Another random thought - if you’re near London or another big city, you could try seeking work as an extra on tv (or maybe even try to get into acting). No qualifications needed and it’s a way to surround yourself with people which is so important.

chisum · 26/10/2022 09:15

Zombie

Alertthecorgis · 26/10/2022 12:25

@BookerDeWitt, how are things now eight years on?

MumzeeWarrior · 12/11/2022 09:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MumzeeWarrior · 12/11/2022 09:27

Just noticed I wrote "SAY", instead of "SAME." That is Dyslexia for you, LOL.
But on the upside I love Problem Solving, and that is how our brains are wired up.

Dyslexic Thinking is now a SKILL and mentioned in the Dictionary and Linkedin Business:
www.linkedin.com/pulse/dyslexic-thinking-now-officially-recognised-valuable-skill-griggs/

Never give up! Everyone has worth and deserves a happy life!

MumzeeWarrior · 12/11/2022 09:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

BookerDeWitt2 · 08/12/2022 03:24

Hello. I am the original poster who posted this thread back in 2014. I have not been able to log in to the account I originally posted with. I have subsequently made a new account to allow me to post this update. I am 31 now. First and foremost, I'm doing very well some areas of life, but not so well in others. I've made significant progress in life over the course of the last 8 years. I have managed to build a career for myself which I am very happy with. The bad news is that I am still in a similar position socially, in terms of having friends or being in a relationship, to where I was 8 years ago. I have neither unfortunately. I am mostly on my own except for having a wonderful Labrador dog, who I love very much. I am now on good terms with my mum as I agreed to bury the hatchet with her regarding her decision to homeschool me. I still have strong feelings about homeschooling but I have managed to move on with my life. I did read everyone's replies to my post, and appreciated them, but I wasn't ready to post an update until now.

mathanxiety · 08/12/2022 04:21

Did your mum press you to bury the hatchet?

Saracen · 08/12/2022 14:28

How lovely to hear from you! I am really glad that you've found a career which makes you happy. You must have worked hard to make that happen.

I'm sorry to hear that you're lonely and hope you will find a way forward there too in time.

Themusicis0utside · 26/01/2023 17:42

BookerDeWitt2 · 08/12/2022 03:24

Hello. I am the original poster who posted this thread back in 2014. I have not been able to log in to the account I originally posted with. I have subsequently made a new account to allow me to post this update. I am 31 now. First and foremost, I'm doing very well some areas of life, but not so well in others. I've made significant progress in life over the course of the last 8 years. I have managed to build a career for myself which I am very happy with. The bad news is that I am still in a similar position socially, in terms of having friends or being in a relationship, to where I was 8 years ago. I have neither unfortunately. I am mostly on my own except for having a wonderful Labrador dog, who I love very much. I am now on good terms with my mum as I agreed to bury the hatchet with her regarding her decision to homeschool me. I still have strong feelings about homeschooling but I have managed to move on with my life. I did read everyone's replies to my post, and appreciated them, but I wasn't ready to post an update until now.

Thank you for updating. Please may I ask: did you manage to leave home and how did you do this, with hardly any experience? It gives me hope for someone who is in a very similar position. How did you cope with living on your own; did you get homesick? How did you learn to cook, etc?

stayathomegardener · 26/01/2023 19:37

Congratulations for achieving so much @BookerDeWitt2 very pleased for you.
Thrilled about your dog companion too, dogs definitely outrank humans in my book.

Stevie99 · 31/08/2023 23:13

Hi, I've discovered this thread and saw your post. My experience was almost identical yo the the op and I'm still struggling with it to this day. I suffered a mental breakdown at 12 years old (depression and anxiety). My mother ended up deciding to teach me at home as I was refusing to enter the school. My mum was always supportive and doing the best she could but she wasn't really equipped with all she needed to know. The local authority were no help at all and I ended up missing out on all exams I should have taken. I was well educated by my mum but my lack of qualifications has made life difficult and prolonged my mental health struggles. I have a job but it's menial and I feel I can do so much more. Thanks for reading and best wishes.

danidoodles · 01/09/2023 08:17

Stevie99 I still get notifications from the post so your reply has popped up. Not sure if you can pm on here but feel free should you like a chat about it, I haven't ever met anyone who had a similar experience growing up. Sounds like your in a pretty similar place to me

SENparenting · 12/12/2023 22:12

I'm sorry about your experience.

I'm not home educating but I know lots of families who are. I think a few things about your experience are atypical. All the families I know have multiple children, so they have siblings to play/annoy/socialise with! All of them are part of Home Ed groups or classes of some sort. One or more of group maths tuition, art classes, swimming, dance, gymnastics, chess, autistic teen meet ups. All different combos but they all see other teens regularly. The other difference is that all their parents have/are/plan to facilitate external qualifications appropriate to their needs/interests/abilities. The vast majority have taken I/GCSEs and the ones which haven't are doing suitable other qualifications due to their additional needs. They might not do it in the traditional order, or might take a couple a year for a few years but they are all getting qualifications.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page