Please or to access all these features

Home decoration

To carpet or not to carpet? Help me decide

11 replies

Hummusfiend · 29/10/2026 09:19

We have a very cold sitting room. Our house is a small edwardian end of terrace - this is improtant becase one side of the room is a cold north wall. The windows are double glazed and the radiator is under the windows (2 large-ish sashes). We have bare floorboards, which I have filled with rubber strips. We also have a sort of patchwork of rugs (which I like the look of) that covers the majority of the floor. There is a fireplace but it is not useable and already draft proofed.

We also have a dog.

I hate carpet. I feel like it traps dust and underlay creates dust as is degrades. With a dog it feels really unhygenic. Buuut I cannot stand another freezing winter. We can barely use the room from about now onwards, becasue we cannot seem to get it warm.

So - is carpet the only solution? What else can I do to warm up this room?

OP posts:
CatherinedeBourgh · 29/10/2026 09:22

Get a thermal camera (cheap on Amazon) and see where you are losing the heat, then tackle things in that order.

I wouldn’t have carpet with a dog, but I might put down insulation and parquet

Tortephant · 29/10/2026 09:45

This suggests you have some damp somewhere OP.

Re rubber strips between floorboards, that won't be helping, can you replace it with cork or scrunched up newspaper? this will be better for airflow and warmth. the rubber will be trapping vapour.

What is on the north facing wall? Is it plastered and painted? Single brick or cavity? Boarded?

5289843DM · 29/10/2026 09:46

I too was going to suggest an infrared camera to look for heat loss. There was a similar thread recently, it was more about wood vs tiles vs carpet, but might have some pointers if I can link it.

We recently renovated and installed under floor heating. Our down stairs is all tiles but the UFH takes the edge off a great deal. That might not be an option though. I wonder if the north facing wall could have anything do on the outside or maybe inside to add insulation?

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5593957-carpet-hard-wood?reply=155610850

Hummusfiend · 29/10/2026 09:47

Wall is single brick, plastered and painted.
We have checked for damp, the issue is more likely the air bricks I suspect

I am just looking at things like this: https://www.insulayers.com/ but there are no reviews for that company anywhere

Insulayers — Wall, Loft & Floor Insulation, London & South East

Insulayers installs external wall, internal wall, loft and floor insulation across London and the South East. Free surveys, itemised quotes.

https://www.insulayers.com

OP posts:
OP posts:
mugglewump · 29/10/2026 09:52

Try putting a dehumidifier in there and see if it helps. You might also wish to investigate either thermal plasterboard for the outside walls, or adding an additional heat source (eg wood burner) tho' I acknowledge that both these options cost and cause building mess.

Tortephant · 29/10/2026 10:03

Hummusfiend · 29/10/2026 09:47

Wall is single brick, plastered and painted.
We have checked for damp, the issue is more likely the air bricks I suspect

I am just looking at things like this: https://www.insulayers.com/ but there are no reviews for that company anywhere

your draught seals and your plaster are the problem.

DO NOT use that company you linked to for your era of property. It will cause you more issues

OP. Are you on Facebook? If so please join this group and ask on there. These are experts in your type of property.

www.facebook.com/share/g/1CBDSJoMxk/?mibextid=wwXIfr

Hummusfiend · 29/10/2026 11:16

@Tortephant well thank you for that! No not on facebook. Do they recommend some particular companies?

OP posts:
Tortephant · 29/10/2026 11:39

Hummusfiend · 29/10/2026 11:16

@Tortephant well thank you for that! No not on facebook. Do they recommend some particular companies?

You will get specialist advice from people not selling to you. Modern materials are what is making your home cold. Single brick homes act differently to cavity walls.

I recommend you join as this will help diagnose and solve the issue for you without lots of expensive mistakes.

LibertyLily · 29/10/2026 12:30

Hi OP, You could try joining the Period Property UK forum where there are loads of knowledgeable and helpful posters with old houses of all eras and plenty of experience dealing with similar issues.

Definitely steer clear of those insulation companies!

Our 200 year old cottage had multiple layers (hardboard, underlay, carpets) over the floorboards when we bought it two years ago. The place was quite damp (it had also been plastered in modern unbreathable plaster when last renovated in 1965), but since removing the floor coverings and layers of wallpaper, it has dried out somewhat. We have ruddy textured sandtex on the exterior which we'll be stripping off at some stage as that also prevents the house from breathing.

We're sticking with the bare floorboards with lots of rugs here as we're hardy souls, having renovated/lived in older/larger/worse houses before. Just trying to dry everything out using the newly installed wood burner and dehumidifiers, windows always cracked open etc.

Eatyourcrust · 29/10/2026 19:27

What is your budget?

We have similar and insulated between the joists underneath with sheep’s wool insulation and breather membrane. Took off the skirtings, used lime mortar to the bare wall, then refixed the original skirtings. It was a lot of work but reduced draughts and cold at floor level, so kept the boards and rugs in the living room.

The other rooms we ply boarded and fitted cork planks/parquet. They look gorgeous and are warm underfoot - visitors think we have underfloor heating. Again expensive but hubby is a builder so we did all the labour ourselves. I would really recommend, it feels cosy but still characterful and clean.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page