Please or to access all these features

Home decoration

House vs flat

13 replies

Mazdasi01 · 27/10/2026 02:46

We are looking to buy a property for 4 adults but we can’t decide between a spacious 2 bedroom flat and a smaller 2 bedroom house.

The flat has a huge 12m2 hallway with 2 exact same sized double bedrooms(12.25m2), the living room is 15.5m2, kitchen( 10.5m2) and bathroom(4.5m2) are pretty much the same size as the house and so is the amount of storage space ( 2.5m2). The flat has got no balcony. There is no window in the bathroom.

The house has a very small entryway for coats, shoes, bags (1.5m2) with a tiny landing( 1m2) upstairs leading to a bathroom along with the two bedrooms and one of the bedrooms is small (10m2) with master bedroom(13m2). Both listed as double bedrooms. The living room is a bit smaller at (15m2).The house has got a really spacious garden with side access which is very appealing. The bathroom has got a small window.

In terms of furniture for the house we could make it work. The lack of hallways means more spacious rooms but it feels cramped especially the entryway area and it feels claustrophobic. The house is all that we can afford. We have a lot of costs and shoes so the 1.5m2 entryway is too small.

OP posts:
Katkincake · 27/10/2026 04:25

Only you know what your must have / wants are, but for me outside space is top of them.

We moved from a small semi to a massive duplex apartment with its own tower room with 360 degree views. Even though it was an amazing space with huge hallway and high ceilings we lasted 10months before deciding it wasn’t for us. You also need to consider cost of ground rent.

iamnotalemon · 27/10/2026 05:20

I love living in a flat and being on one level but I wouldn’t buy one again because of the ground rent and service charge and the fact you have no control over it. Could you look at a different house?

parietal · 27/10/2026 05:28

what about location? Which has walkable shops and cafes etc?

4 adults is an unusual combination for buying a property. What happens if one of the couples splits up? Or has a baby?

Tortephant · 27/10/2026 06:46

Keep looking

grandporke29 · 27/10/2026 07:11

Personally, I'd go for the house, as having a garden makes such a difference, especially with four adults sharing. That said, if it already feels cramped before you've even moved in, I doubt that feeling will go away. I'd probably keep looking until you find somewhere that feels right.

Dollysfriend · 27/10/2026 07:23

I have lived in two flats, one recently. Four adults (2x DC).
No outside space made me very depressed. I couldn't put washing out or buy outdoor plants.

The only time I'd consider this is late retirement and then ground floor.

Yello24 · 27/10/2026 07:29

What is the make up of the four adults?
If it’s two couples and you’re buying an investment for DC and partners then possibly the flat for the balanced room sizes and storage.
If its parents with two adult DC then the house would be more future proof and assuming freehold vs leasehold then the house for the outside space.
We are in a tight house space with me and adult DC. We are very sensible with possessions and storage. Lots of full height furniture and have outside storage and are ruthless about clutter. Ottoman beds or under bed storage. Use the attic.
Any service charges?
Would have to be a very good reason to buy a flat instead of a house.

Pinkissmart · 27/10/2026 07:36

House. You can make the entryway functional and nice. You’re only in it for a few minutes a day.

Mazdasi01 · 27/10/2026 22:07

Thanks everyone for replying. Instead of individually responding i thought i would do a post addressing everything . Its parents with 2x DC. The flat is in a lovely area close to good transport links. It is on a one lane main road but is set back a bit. The house is in a quiet residential area but it is less affluent. The house costs almost £150,000 more than the flat . The flat has no ground rent but service charge costs £178 per month and has got a 221 year lease. Both are ex council properties which makes them slightly more affordable for us. We value side access as DC like to cycling and more convenient for gardening/ carrying waste. DC are same gender so can share a bedroom. The house will fit our existing furniture well although the 10m2 bedroom will need a smaller wardrobe. We plan on putting pegs on back of bedroom doors to hang some of our coats. Shoe storage will be a bit of a problem unless we build a porch which would solve this issue. The flat will always feel more airy unless we extend the house which will cost a lot for us. The potential in the house is what

OP posts:
ifonlytheydlisten · 28/10/2026 18:43

House with outside space every time

PropertyD · 28/10/2026 19:07

House

IDasIX · 28/10/2026 19:13

If the flat is 150k less than the house, is it possible to buy a three bed flat? You’ll all be uncomfortably on top of each other in the small house.

On the other hand, two adult DC having presumably a single bed each in a shared bedroom might mean you’ll have more space pretty quickly, as one or both of them will surely move out sharpish!

Bubbaliciousss · 30/10/2026 11:41

I have a flat with a private garden and no service/maintenance charges, I love it. However in your situation, I'd choose the house, purely for the outdoor space. If that matters to you?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page