Which clock?

[HuntrixAreReal]

Please ignore placement and the state of the room but which clock do you looks better with my walls etc?

Forgot to add photos!

First one

I’ll be honest I’m not keen on either of them. The round one looks small. Can’t tell really what’s on top?
Unless you have other Highland cow items second one might be a bit random.
I know they can be decorative but these days there’s not much need for wall clocks. I end up taking batteries out of clocks on holiday as the ticking drives me mad if I’m trying to read!
That’s just me though. Would they go in a hall or entrance area?
Wall colour looks good.
Edited for typo oops.

First is better than the second but both rather twee and small unless you’re planning to create a gallery wall?

What sort of look are you going for?

What’s on the top of the first clock? Can’t zoom in much so looks like white monkeys?!

They're both really high up on the wall so tricky to tell. I prefer the cows but then again I like cows!

Not a big fan of the shabby chic look of the first one, plus it clashes with the room I think. The cows get my vote.

The round one, but surely the wall is too big for it? Maybe the round clock where it is, with a picture underneath, as the space is too large for the small clock, imo.
Would it look better on a smaller wall, or a bigger clock on the existing wall? ( sorry, probably not helpful, as you've got the clocks already, I'm assuming?)
I don't like the Highland cow clock, im afraid.

I prefer the one that looks like a clock.

First is awful and looks old, second I can’t see the hands.

It’s all a matter of taste isn’t it?
Don’t be offended and it depends on the other items and furniture you have but im not a fan of either.
I prefer the round one because at least it looks like a clock.

Neither unfortunately. I think you need a round clock that’s slightly bigger for the space.