Which mirror for above fireplace in living room?

[DownmarketSellingSunset]

DH and I cannot agree, it's a victorian house and the fireplace is black with some burgundy tiles with vine leaves on. Which mirror would you pick to go above? Pic of the fireplace with old owner's mirror attached too.

The first one but it needs to be the same width as the fireplace (well my preference anyway).

Hard to see but a landscape not portrait hanging would be best. Not sure bout the square - would depend on how it fits with the rest of the room

Oh yes the top one, would be hung the other way up - landscape not portrait.

Surely this has to depend entirely on the vibe you're going for with your other furniture? Are you planning to do a kind of contrast house where you do modern interior design alongside the Victorian bones, or are you aiming for something more traditional?

The top one. The bottom one is too modern

First one as the second one reminds me of a bathroom mirror x

I mean third reminds me of bathroom mirror

The first one, mounted landscape. The second one looks like it belongs in a bathroom.

The first one, mounted landscape
The other one is too modern