Recommend me a Greek island please! (And resort?!)

[Eloisedublin123]

Hello! Have never been to Greece. We are two adults and an 11 year old looking for a quiet nice authentic Greek island for the last week in May next year. But not too small - hoping there may be a few other kids for DD to knock around with. Yes, we have been watching too much mamma Mia 😆
Thank you!

Easy, Pefkos in Rhodes

Well if you love mama Mia then go to Skoppelos - (where it was filmed) you can fly to skiathos then short ferry ride to skoppelos - beautiful island, less touristy than skiathos .

Skala in Kephalonia