First Choice Holiday Village Majorca or Ibiza?

[Magair]

DH and I, kids aged 7 and 3 and my mum and dad for two weeks next summer.... narrowed it down to a Holiday Village as they suit us. Just trying to decide between Majorca and Ibiza.... any one been to one or both and can recommend? Thanks

I’ve been to the one in Mallorca. The room was beautiful but I found the food terrible. For instance one day I was excited to see they’d made paella but they’d made it with noodles instead of rice??
Everyone was getting off the free coach into the nearest town and going to the nearest restaurant as they were so hungry.
If you like very basic food then you may like it (the onsite Indian restaurant was very good) but the buffet was crap.

I’ve been to Ibiza, rooms are lovely. Everything very clean.
Food is good, can be a bit repetitive. Lots to do for little ones.
Lovely location, gorgeous beach. Bit of a walk to get to San Antonio.

I’ve been to Majorca, rooms were good, kids clubs and activities fab but the buffet was a free for all, you’d swear people had never seen food before and it was dire! The hotel is in the middle of nowhere, a good 30 min walk to the town. I love Majorca but wouldn’t go back to the holiday village.

Thanks. We have ended up booking Ibiza.

For instance one day I was excited to see they’d made paella but they’d made it with noodles instead of rice

That's fideu, an actual Spanish dish. Absolutely delicious if cooked well.

Majorca is smaller and Ibiza has the water park, food similar so I guess you can choose based on other factors. Personally we liked kos and cyprus more.