Not reopening the issue..but this was posted on one of the education blogs which clearly shows that teachers are looking at the larger picture...(Charlotte is not her real name) but she was referring to her Music cohort..
Where a student’s average GCSE result generates A level target grades, their weaker subjects are likely to show less progress – ‘value-added’ – compared to the stronger ones. Charlotte has been told that when the grades are in, the value-added measure for the class should not be significantly above the three-year average. This would be around 0, but she has a stellar group and has predicted that they will exceed this by some distance.
“We had gone through a really robust statistics-based process, using common sense and our professional judgment,” she says. “Now all the contextual information is being disregarded and we are not even submitting any evidence.”
She spent some time considering how to make the results fit Ofqual’s expectations. Should she simply drop every grade, or select individuals for whom the effect would be least severe to suffer bigger changes?
“With two students predicted As, I thought one needed the grade to get into university whilst the other didn’t, so that was the grade to drop,” she explains.
And with the GCSE group she started considering whether the student was continuing to A-level and how the grade they received would affect their confidence. All because, according to Ofqual, something must give.
“It all just felt totally wrong,” she says.
The extraordinary changes that the pandemic has enforced upon all of us are clear almost everywhere we look. ‘Unprecedented’ might become the most used word of 2020, and the government, Ofqual and school leaders had to put in place a system that, perhaps inevitably, would have its problems. And they had to guard against the annual problem of inaccurate predicted grades translating into a year of highly-questionable results.
To Charlotte, it feels like a blunt instrument designed in the image of large subjects that does not suit the nuances of smaller ones in the arts. It could be that the students in her class are the victims, and to her it does not feel necessary.