I made this cake from the MN recipe this evening. It was inedible - 3 out of the 5 of us could not eat more than one mouthful. The taste of the raising agents was overwhelming. The other two said "OK, but not one of your better offerings."
I was dubious about the large amount of raising agents, but followed the recipe to the letter - except for the walnuts, which are optional, and cinnamon, which dh dislikes. I don't think cinnamon and walnuts would disguise the strong baking powder flavour.
So, are the proportions wrong in the recipe, or do my family simply dislike the taste of baking powder and bicarb? It has a couple of rave reviews after all.