Help! Soggy Toasties

[KatoPotatoHoHo]

I always blamed my old machine, but even with a new toastie maker, my toasted sandwiches take about 25minutes to produce soft floppy wet triangles!

What am I doing wrong??

What on earth at you putting in them, soup?!

*are

what are you putting in them, soup??

Yes to buttering the outside and waiting for it to heat upand only have minimal (cheese) filling...

The quality of my toasties depends on the cheese I use. I switched to value cheddar a couple of months back, toastie quality wasn't as good. There was more grease so absorbed by the bread. I just get own brand cheese again now but some supermarkets tend to be greasier than others (sainsburys).