Eclipse - first visit

[swanriver]

• So I've finally seen it on DVD for first time. Perhaps I'm no longer in the Twilight zone (was there for some weeks with first two films and four books)...didn't have much impact on me..Or maybe it just wasn't so good as the others????

Pattinson's crooked smile beginning to wear thin. Or perhaps they are all just too pasty? And why did Bella not bring a proper anorak on a camping trip?
I liked the meadow I loved Jasper..and the matrixy fight scenes.

Maybe I should watch it again

I watched it tonight! It was horrible and stupid. It's as if Jane chooses St.John over her Rochester. Why?

I think it's much more convincing in the book, Edward seems much more passionate there. In Eclipse film he seems eclipsed by Jasper and Jacob.
Loved scenery though. (again) There is no great scenery in book after all..