Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Brexit

Can any genuine non-goady posters who voted for Brexit answer some of the following questions please?

412 replies

Spittingchestnuts · 12/12/2020 03:13

I would prefer to avoid a goady thread if at all possible.

I'm British but I live outside the UK and I'm interested to know - now Brexit is "done" (almost) - why current discussions about it on Mumsnet and elsewhere on UK sm and in the press, are not more focused on what the UK will be doing after 1st January when the transition period comes to an end should we have no deal, and even if we do? (I'm thinking more about policy and direction rather than possible goods delays at borders but those are important too.) Is anyone who voted for Brexit prepared to admit that they are worried with the New Year looming so close and so little information coming from the government?

Some regular pro-Brexit posters on here seem to have blind faith in Boris Johnson's government and a strong belief that life will automatically be better outside the EU despite the fact that, apart from a few vague witterings about greater flexibility and increased sovereignty, we almost have next to no detailed information about it. The lack of detailed facts available is scary actually. As far as I can understand it, Brexiteers voted for a "vague notion" sketched in the briefest of terms by a proven liar and his cohorts with next to no detail or shading. If you think this interpretation is unfair, can you give me more details as to why? What concrete things did you vote for as opposed to the things you voted against?

To date, the UK government have been very vocal about what they don't want and how they don't want to be shackled to EU rules, but have been less forthcoming about what they do want and how these changes wiil translate in to legislation. We've rejected rules and policies that are roughly aligned with a Christian liberal, centre-leaning social democratic model that focuses on high product standards and good basic employment protections, so where will we go now? In a different direction presumably?

So what will the laws and policies be that distinguish ourselves from this EU mould? 52% of UK citizens voted for them so can any of you please explain them? We will presumably be steering to the right of where we are now? Given that Brexit was championed by the right wing of the Conservative party who want lower taxes, less state intervention, I would say that that's a logical conclusion, but is no one particularly alarmed by this prospect? Can anyone who voted for Brexit but doesn't view themselves as particularly right wing , explain this to me?

I know it is said that some Brexiteers voted for improved public services, and for more money being invested in the NHS etc? Can anyone explain how Boris will manage to recruit more nurses, more police, and have better environmental standards, while presiding over a low tax economy or "Singapore-on-Thames"? Does no one recognise a potential conflict between these two positions?

And now we want to trade more with non-EU countries that are geographically further away, how will be, practically and logistically, manage to do this without undermining current UK efforts to be more environmentally friendly?

And what about the "small" matter of Scotland voting to remain by 62%? And Northern Ireland by 55.8%? Is anyone who voted for Brexit even mildly concerned about what affect a Conservative government, based in Westminster, imposing a divergence away from Europe they didn't want, on citizens of Scotland and N.Ireland, will have on the unity of the UK ?

It's probably too much to hope for but I would love some non-goady genuine pro-Brexit posters to explain some of this to me. As I love and miss the UK, and have lots of family there, and there are 20 days until the new year, these questions are occupying my thoughts and keeping me awake at night.

OP posts:
jasjas1973 · 15/12/2020 15:39

There is a huge shortage of Social carers, councils & agencies will pay around 12 ph, they can't get staff.
To put that in context, we pay for 15 ph for a network technician, he/she will get a van but less for a smart hands one ie rings up for remote support.

This idea that there are all these unemployed people turning down employment is for the birds, refuse any job (without good reason) and you will lose your benefits.

If the poor don't give a fuck about the better off losing out through Brexit, then don't be surprised if they don't want their taxes going to the poor.
In that regard, i might even vote tory in 2024, i'm sure they'll keep them where they belong

Europilgrim · 15/12/2020 15:54

But do you vote for someone who says they are going to do what was agreed,
I wouldn't vote for someone who has a track record of not doing what he says just because he says what I want to hear....

TomMarvoloRiddle · 15/12/2020 15:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TomMarvoloRiddle · 15/12/2020 16:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

bellinisurge · 15/12/2020 16:51

Last year's GE was as much about not trusting that gobshite Corbyn as anything else. And for the Oven Ready Deal to get this shit over with. If you think the vote was wholeheartedly for the Tories and for Brexit you're as deluded as you were in 2016.
But carry on in your happy place. Shit us coming and you can take responsibility for it.

ListeningQuietly · 15/12/2020 16:52

Sadly many of those who voted for Brexit will never get what they thought they want

because they elected a government whose vested interests
are to keep the poor people that way
to allow more profit to be extracted

the EU as a bloc tried to

  • restrict Zero hour contracts
  • restrict false self employment
  • improve maternity pay
  • improve employee dismissal rights
  • restrict working hours
it also
  • cleaned up beaches
  • cleaned water
  • cleaned air
  • improved food quality
as well as
  • improving health and safety for all
  • restricting the opportunities for tax avoidance by the rick
  • improve personal data security for all
BUT the UK politicians and press told lies about the EU and tried to take credit for the work of MEPs rather than MPs

so the British people will lose the rights the EU gave them
and the UK politicians have no incentive to replace them
which is sad

Andante57 · 15/12/2020 17:04

In that regard, i might even vote tory in 2024, i'm sure they'll keep them where they belong

I thought you were moving to France, Jasjas?
Apologies if I’ve got you mixed up with someone else.

jasjas1973 · 15/12/2020 17:38

Thats the plan...Figeac, been waiting to be made redundant, which has now happened, i being a little goady!

jasjas1973 · 15/12/2020 17:42

Ask yourselves why you failed so dismally?

No remain party was in power, May even lost her majority, forming an alliance with the even more right wing DUP.....but she soldiered on for a hard brexit regardless.

Poll after poll now shows a significant lead for Regrexit.

CherryPavlova · 15/12/2020 18:01

I think remain lost through complacency and corruption mainly.
The ultra rich like Rees Mogg were averse to the EU trying to address tax avoidance and evasion so sold the xenophobes all sorts of myths and false promises.
Many championed Brexit for political power despite knowing it was a very bad idea - Cameron, May, Johnson were all originally remain supporters, who decided they personally would gain from swapping sides.
There was poor leadership of the Remain vote - Corbyn was never going to convince people and Sturgeon only really impacts on Scotland. Many remain voters felt certain there weren't possibly enough right wing, xenophobes who would buy into the whole sovereignty rubbish. Sadly those voters who follow Farage didn't realise they were being led into a blind alley as turkeys voting for Christmas. Strong leave areas such as Skegness, Cornwall and parts of Kent will suffer most; polls show Cornwall has woken up and would now come out as a remain area.
I can only imagine how badly people in Thanet, Medway and Dover areas are going to be affected. Despite it being a very poor choice, I can't help but feel sorry for those already living in communities challenged by coastal deprivation.

DonkeyMcFluff · 15/12/2020 18:12

If the poor don't give a fuck about the better off losing out through Brexit, then don't be surprised if they don't want their taxes going to the poor.
Poor people don’t want handouts (well, most of them don’t). They want fair treatment and opportunities to earn their own money in decent jobs.

bellinisurge · 15/12/2020 18:51

Which will happen in a Brexit/Covid fucked economy? Seriously?

LouiseCollins28 · 15/12/2020 18:58

Thanks spittingchestnuts masterful job of multi quoting you've done there. I'm not going to try and respond point by point but a few things jumped out, the Uber (and similar) question being one. I mentioned this in my "hopeful" scenario but omitted it from my "realistic" one, draw your own conclusions from that Smile

While hosptiality is basically on it's knees nationwide I can see the sense in allowing Uber eats and the like to continue operating. Once Covid is over will they stop? No chance IMO!

If anything I would expect many people's employment (very general terms here) to get more precarious post Brexit not less, though I'm not convinced Brexit is to blame for this.

People will need jobs and if this kind of "gig" work is all that is available then they'll have little choice. The other scenario is that such arrangements are prohibited by law and the risk is that Uber and co decide their business model is unsustainable like that. Might be good in one way but lots of lost jobs in the meantime.

FreshFreesias · 15/12/2020 19:05

You keep talking of ‘goady Brexiteers’ but there are plenty of ‘goady’ remainers - especially on Mumsnet.
I hardly think you will get the information you claim you want here. Why not try Twitter?
As an environmentalist and animal lover (I have a dog sanctuary), I’m thrilled that the UK has banned live animal export, something that we were unable to do while a member of the EU.

jasjas1973 · 15/12/2020 19:14

As an environmentalist and animal lover (I have a dog sanctuary), I’m thrilled that the UK has banned live animal export, something that we were unable to do while a member of the EU

UK has not.... just for slaughter, not for stock or breeding but most importantly doesn't cover the huge numbers transported in this country for slaughter 100s of miles from where they were breed.

Its also a consultation only not a definite & opposed by the NFU.

Personally, i'd like more local slaughterhouses and far less animals breed in the first place, we all need to eat less meat.

Schehezarade · 15/12/2020 21:54

Poll after poll now shows a significant lead for Regrexit.

Yeah, but it could be like the fact no one claims to vote Tory - or the fact that it was assumed no one would vote Leave. People have more sense than to admit to something which will only get them lectured.

jasjas1973 · 15/12/2020 22:10

@Schehezarade

Poll after poll now shows a significant lead for Regrexit.

Yeah, but it could be like the fact no one claims to vote Tory - or the fact that it was assumed no one would vote Leave. People have more sense than to admit to something which will only get them lectured.

The polling around in 2016 was very close, just as it was with Trump vs Clinton.

Pollsters aren't going to be lecturing anyone, its not MN.

Peregrina · 15/12/2020 22:30

I can't help thinking it's a bit like votes for Thatcher. Back in 1979 and up to the mid 80s people were more than happy to admit that they had voted for her. By 1989 it was a different story.

yellowspanner · 15/12/2020 22:42

JasJas, I voted for Brexit and I voted Tory and I am sick of getting lectured and called names on MN
I don't regret either.
But I have been called thick, ignorant, stupid and racist on the Brexit threads on here. Remainers ask a question and over the last 4 years I have answered many but when posters don't agree they name call. That's why few Brexiteer come on these boards any more.

ListeningQuietly · 15/12/2020 22:45

yellowspanner
Are you happy with how Brexit has met your hopes and dreams ?

FUSOI · 16/12/2020 04:28

@Europilgrim

But do you vote for someone who says they are going to do what was agreed, I wouldn't vote for someone who has a track record of not doing what he says just because he says what I want to hear....
But you would instead vote for somebody that says they are going to do the opposite of want you want.

Yeah because that happens all the time.

Oh dear Oh dear Oh dear. Add that one to teh ever growing list of spurious reasons.

FUSOI · 16/12/2020 04:31

@jasjas1973

Ask yourselves why you failed so dismally?

No remain party was in power, May even lost her majority, forming an alliance with the even more right wing DUP.....but she soldiered on for a hard brexit regardless.

Poll after poll now shows a significant lead for Regrexit.

80 seat majority tends to suggest otherwise.

Shame the pools didn't turn into votes then.

FUSOI · 16/12/2020 04:36

@bellinisurge

Last year's GE was as much about not trusting that gobshite Corbyn as anything else. And for the Oven Ready Deal to get this shit over with. If you think the vote was wholeheartedly for the Tories and for Brexit you're as deluded as you were in 2016. But carry on in your happy place. Shit us coming and you can take responsibility for it.
Not in traditional areas. The clip on question time when the lady a daughter of a ex labour councillor was crying because she voted Tory because of Brexit was the rule rather than the exception

If it wsa that cut and dried and so many wanted to Remain, what happened to the Lib Dem vote, the cOrbyn effect again.

FUSOI · 16/12/2020 04:39

@Peregrina

I can't help thinking it's a bit like votes for Thatcher. Back in 1979 and up to the mid 80s people were more than happy to admit that they had voted for her. By 1989 it was a different story.
Maybe in the South, never in the North would anybody admit to Thatcher The Tax Dodger.

Strangely people who would have been hugely upset if you had of told them 5 years ago thet they would vote Tory are more than happy to tell you thats exactly what they did and why - Brexit.

jasjas1973 · 16/12/2020 06:31

Fusio

Leaving was a done deal by the time of the 2019 election, i thought you were referring to the period after vote?

The 2016 result had to be implemented after DC made his promises that it would be - thats why the LD vote collapsed, of course had the country voted LD, Swinson would have had the mandate to cancel Brexit but that message didn't come across.

May was in thrall to her party where the majority wanted a hard brexit, she couldn't get the country behind her and lost the majority in 2017, so i don't think the majority you think there is for Brexit actually exists, just 37% of the electorate voted for this change.

That was the time for opposition to seek a softer brexit but they couldn't get behind JC, he wouldn't step aside, so we had years of dither, in 2019 people thought BJ had a deal to go and voted on that basis, he lied.