It's not catastrophising to say this govt doesn't respect the courts or the law, doesn't feel bound by them and may be able to delay obeying them for those crucial 12 days from 19 October
Indeed. BCF is right.
If you would like to explain why it is 'catastrophising' to observe how this government has behaved in recent weeks and how this might play out if they continue to act in this manner over the next few I'm all ears.
This government has acted beyond the limits of its power with proroguation and has said it doesn't respect the decision of the Supreme Court and is actively saying they will somehow get around the Benn Act by any means necessary.
Thats a serious undermining and challenge to the Rule of Law. Its open, deliberate and intentional. That alone raises risks. Even if they comply with the law. It has raised the stakes and is stoking political tensions. That has consequences.
We are hearing continual anti-EU sentiment. How do you think saying that there are people 'colluding' with the French government is going to play out? With an outpouring of support for the British position across Europe amongst politicians and the public???
Is that condusive to getting a deal or undermining our chances of getting a deal?
We also have the context of knowing that this government has a pattern of behaviour of being deliberately evasive or outright obstructive. Let me remind you, that if they are obstructive we have the danger of Accidental No Deal which is ALSO written into law, AS WELL AS the Benn Act being written into law.
We know there are 10 crucial days - after the EUCO summit - in which any deal must pass parliament. Yet we have a lot of evidence to say the UK isn't submitting ideas that are in anyway compatible with the Irish Border issue and we know that talk of progress has only come out of the mouths of our government. And we know that any legislation FOR a deal will struggle to pass parliament in just ten days, simply because there is so much of it.
We also know that to No Deal in a managed way we also need to legislate. If we don't legislate we face legal chaos with condictory law. Which is an additional crisis, in addition to simple No Deal. There is in fact Managed Planned No Deal and Chaotic Accidential No Deal, not just a mere singular form of No Deal.
If you weigh up the balance of obstacles to stop No Deal versus either an extension (which I've not even mentioned in this post) or a Deal, then the likilihood of No Deal is higher, yet to verbalise this and the possible consequences of the authoritarian tactics being used at the moment is being rubbished as 'catastrophising'.
If you want to feel better I'm guessing wearing blinkers is nice.
Otherwise observation of what is actually happening has legitimacy, even if it leads to concerns of a very bleak nature.
Bottomline is this government lacks empathy, competence and compassion. Without any of those it is a recipe for disaster in its own right. Brexit or No Brexit.