Kiwi take on it. Not pulling any punches.
Hey ! Where's all the Leavers gone ? They used to be all over these threads telling us to suck it up and how they won.
Article in whole ....
i.stuff.co.nz/world/europe/111909319/brexit-lessons-from-britain-now-a-global-laughing-stock
i.stuff.co.nz
Brexit lessons from Britain, now a global laughing stock
Peter Hartcher16:33, Apr 09 2019FacebookTwitterWhats AppRedditEmail
8-9 minutes
OPINION: Now that Brexit is indisputably established as one of the most monumentally stupid pieces of self-inflicted injury by a developed nation this century, other nations are learning key lessons from its mistakes.
The concept behind Britain's decision to leave the European Union was that it would recover its sovereignty.
On the day that Britons voted by 52 per cent to 48 in favour, its main cheerleader, Nigel Farage, declared it "independence day". That was nearly three years ago.
Today the country is a global laughing stock. It's in an interminable dead-end, neither able to move forwards nor back. It's lost investment and jobs, political stability, national credibility and, perhaps worst of all, it's inflicted new anger and division within British society.
READ MORE:
- Brits living in France could be sent home under Brexit
- Brexit: May reaches out to Labour, asks EU for delay
- Brexit's toll: UK economy at weakest since financial crisis
Brexit has been described as a crisis of national identity, a crisis of leadership under Theresa May, a crisis of the Tory party, a crisis of British politics, a crisis of democracy, and a constitutional crisis.
ALASTAIR GRANT/AP
Brexit has been described as a crisis of national identity, a crisis of leadership under Theresa May, a crisis of the Tory party, a crisis of British politics, a crisis of democracy, and a constitutional crisis.
Across the other 27 members of the EU, the main lesson learnt is that it'd be a bad idea to follow Britain out the door. In one country after another, the political parties that were inspired by Brexit have dumped their campaigns.
Two years ago, the French far-right leader Marine Le Pen was demanding a referendum on whether to leave the EU, a Frexit, as was known. Today she speaks of making the EU work better.
Italy's Matteo Salvini of the League ran a right-wing nationalist campaign to reject the EU common currency, the euro, but now, as deputy prime minister, he has stopped using the hashtag #BastaEuro – enough of the euro. The idea is now effectively moribund.
In Austria, the Freedom Party dropped its call for a referendum on dumping the euro and joined a coalition government that favours the status quo
Britain's experience with Brexit has shown the world such pointless ugliness that it has boosted support for the EU to its highest in 35 years. Specifically, according to a Eurobarometer survey last year, two-thirds of Europeans say that their country has benefited from EU membership.
Populists offer emotional appeals that lead to dead ends, just as Nigel Farage led Britain to Brexit.
JEFF SPICER/GETTY
Populists offer emotional appeals that lead to dead ends, just as Nigel Farage led Britain to Brexit.
In Canada, Brexit is being used as an object lesson for secessionists in the French-speaking province of Quebec: "It has given us a picture of what actual attempts to withdraw from a long-established legislative union, as opposed to fantasies, look like," says the National Post's Andrew Coyne.
"In particular, it has permanently discredited once-common claims that secession from Canada would be a quick and relatively painless affair."
This point carries particular force for any Australian thinking of voting for Clive Palmer, who is running candidates across the country for the federal election in a shameless attempted comeback even as his creditors try to recover hundreds of millions from his collapsed Queensland Nickel.
Palmer proposes that North Queensland break away and form a separate, new state.
Ironic, perhaps, for his so-called United Australia Party. Palmer has learnt nothing from Brexit. He is either a buffoon or an irresponsible populist.
And this is the first lesson that Australia, like countries everywhere, should learn from Brexit. Populists offer emotional appeals that lead to dead ends, just as Farage led Britain to Brexit.
Marine Le Pen, seen here with former Donald Trump advisor Steve Bannon, has gone from demanding a 'Frexit' to talk of making the EU work better.
SYLVAIN LEFEVRE/GETTY
Marine Le Pen, seen here with former Donald Trump advisor Steve Bannon, has gone from demanding a 'Frexit' to talk of making the EU work better.
There are many definitions of populism. The one I prefer is that populism offers unworkably simple solutions to complex problems. Palmer is not the only populist on the ballot paper at the federal election. One Nation is another standout. Single-issue parties are no better.
Brexit has been described as a crisis of many types. A crisis of national identity, a crisis of leadership, a crisis of the Tory party, a crisis of British politics, a crisis of democracy, a constitutional crisis, and so on. And you can make a solid case for each of these claims.
But, at its broadest, the Brexit dead end is a crisis of overpoliticisation. That is, every realistic and practical element of the national interest is lost to a self-interested free-for-all, like hyenas preying on the body politic.
The triumph of Farage's populist "Leave" campaign dealt Britain a jolting blow to the head, disorienting the political system and signalling to the politicians that it was time to let their inner hyenas out.
Italian Interior Minister and Vice Premier Matteo Salvini has stopped using the hashtag #BastaEuro – enough of the euro.
CHRISTOPHE ENA/AP
Italian Interior Minister and Vice Premier Matteo Salvini has stopped using the hashtag #BastaEuro – enough of the euro.
Overpoliticisation is not simply where a government can't get its way in an unco-operative parliament. That is standard in a democracy. It will often occur for perfectly legitimate reasons of difference over principle or policy.
As the chaos of the British parliament demonstrates, overpoliticisation is where there is a breakdown of any goodwill or discipline within the parties themselves.
It can't happen in Australia? It already has. In Australia's case, it was not as all-encompassing as Brexit.
Brexit has shown the world such pointless ugliness that it has boosted support for the EU to its highest in 35 years.
FRANK AUGSTEIN/AP
Brexit has shown the world such pointless ugliness that it has boosted support for the EU to its highest in 35 years.
But the pathetic tale of climate change and energy policy in Australia over the last decade is a clear case of overpoliticisation. The net result so far is a policy dead end, where a government of six years is about to go to an election without an energy policy.
Electricity prices have soared, companies are being put out of business, Australia's carbon emissions commitment is in doubt, and the entire power grid is approaching collapse.
As the Australian Energy Market Commission reported last week, "the grid is holding up but only because the energy market operator is intervening on a daily basis to keep the lights on". And this in a country that is an energy superpower.
The triumph of the Leave campaign signalled to the politicians that it was time to let their inner hyenas out.
PEtER SUMMERS/GETTY
The triumph of the Leave campaign signalled to the politicians that it was time to let their inner hyenas out.
This national failure didn't happen because of the routine operation of Australia's political system. First a Labor government, and then Coalition ones, proved unable to cohere around a policy.
The parties fractured within. Labor struck down its own prime minister over an emissions trading system, pitching the Rudd and Gillard governments into a disarray that neither recovered from.
Then it was the Coalition's turn. Even after Malcolm Turnbull got his National Energy Guarantee through the Liberal party room, a revolt detonated the policy and destroyed the prime minister.
Brexit is one of the most monumentally stupid pieces of self-inflicted injury by a developed nation this century.
FrANK AUGSTEIN/AP
Brexit is one of the most monumentally stupid pieces of self-inflicted injury by a developed nation this century.
In the cases of Labor and Liberal, it was a free-for-all, without the party discipline that a Westminster system requires or the goodwill to agree on a compromise. No democracy can function without compromise.
The hyenas fed amid the chaos in a frenzy of self-interest and self-indulgence, and the Australian electorate was disgusted. Labor paid the price, and now it seems the Coalition will pay the same price at next month's election.
Britain's madness is broader, deeper and more intractable, but Australia has shown over the last decade that it, too, is capable of ruinous over-politicisation. No matter how bad the tragi-comedy of Brexit, Australia cannot be smug.
- Peter Hartcher is the Sydney Morning Herald's international editor.
Sydney Morning Herald