Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Brexit

The Brexit Arms goes forth! All welcome. Leavers, Remainers, Couldn't give a Tossers, & openly gay athletes.

1005 replies

surferjet · 04/11/2016 22:41

Welcome Wine

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
vulpeculaveritas · 06/11/2016 16:07

"Parliament can think what it likes. It would be hypocritical and undemocratoc."

No it wouldn't in a parliamentary democracy, an advisory referendum, which even Farrage admits it was, Parliament is still sovereign.

"What I wonder, is if Cameron had kept his promise and triggered a50 straight after the election, what would the situation be?"

Legally it would be the same Cameron didn't have the right to do that, and the challenges would have been the same. It would also have been invalid as Art 50 needs the country declaring to have gone through its own constitutional process.

surferjet · 06/11/2016 16:11

This is not about getting the best deal for Brexit, it's about stopping it altogether. Do you think we're stupid?
They'll do to us exactly what they did to Ireland & any other country that's tried to leave.
The rich & powerful will always crush us, & they've got millions of pathetic little remainers helping them.

OP posts:
vulpeculaveritas · 06/11/2016 16:16

The irish deal got reforms before they voted on it again, that's perfectly legitimate.

The rich and powerful point? I really don't think this can be given as a a victory of the poor over the rich at all. Especially looking at those backing the leave campaign and there reasons for it.

To do so in profoundly dishonest.

Further, in a representitive democracy this issue needs further debate, especially as the result was so close.

Use the "will of the people" clap trap all you like, its incorrect and a hyperbolic appeal to emotion.

surferjet · 06/11/2016 16:20

The rich crushing the poor.
& you're doing their dirty work.
Congratulations - you must feel so proud.

OP posts:
MangoMoon · 06/11/2016 16:24

I don't get why it can't go straight to a vote this week:
Uphold the referendum result: yes / no

It's the most obvious course of action.

vulpeculaveritas · 06/11/2016 16:25

I'd call it the upholding of democracy and sovereignty.

WinchesterWoman · 06/11/2016 16:28

Will of the people claptrap? Have yourself away there

Hypocritical because their very existence as MPs is predicated on the legitimacy of the majority vote.

To reject the referendum decision would be to deny the legitimacy of the majority vote.

WinchesterWoman · 06/11/2016 16:30

Anti democracy Vulpa: you missed off the anti from your post.

surferjet · 06/11/2016 16:33

I'd call it the upholding of democracy and sovereignty

Well you would wouldn't you.
17 million people think otherwise.
Not that you give a shit about them or democracy.

OP posts:
jaws5 · 06/11/2016 16:35

The rich & powerful will always crush us, & they've got millions of pathetic little remainers helping them
Do you realise how populist politicians like Farage and Trump are the ones who've come up with this dichotomy, "the people vs the elite"? They are multimillionaires but somehow you place them alongside the "us" and against "the rich and powerful". We (remainers) are not pathetic, or little, and more importantly don't follow or applaud every utterance of rich psychopaths.

surferjet · 06/11/2016 16:37

WW - they're just a load of foot soldiers for the elite. They'll be on an anti capitalism march next month prentending they hate them.
They must have a headache with all the personalities they've got.

OP posts:
WinchesterWoman · 06/11/2016 16:37

Surfer too right

SeekEveryEveryKnownHidingPlace · 06/11/2016 16:37

This is not about getting the best deal for Brexit, it's about stopping it altogether. Do you think we're stupid?
Probably best left unanswered.

The rich & powerful will always crush us, & they've got millions of pathetic little remainers helping them.

Brave brave Boris, defying the rich and powerful for you! Farage and Gove, they had barely two farthings to rub together, but gladly did they give them for the little people! The devastating effects on the least advantaged are what remainers were concerned about - how do you think life in Sunderland and Doncaster and Dover is going to be better when we flounce out of the EU?

vulpeculaveritas · 06/11/2016 16:38

MPs are elected as part of a representative democracy, not direct, its why the referendum was advisory.

I think its far more anti democratic to illegally use royal prerogative which you favour. In a representitive democracy it is far more undemocratic to push the vote through parliament without debate, especially when the majority won was so slight.

I think its funny that the right wing press are seeking to bully and put political pressure on the independent judiciary, which is also nondemocratic.

You use emotive hyperbole well though.

autumnintheair · 06/11/2016 16:40

Great post Infinite Corbyns latest antics just show his true colours: professional protestor with no actual morals or beliefs

jaws5 · 06/11/2016 16:40

foot soldiers for the elite, you're evidence that ignorance is bliss and always will be....

surferjet · 06/11/2016 16:42

You think I'm stupid?
Fine, I'd rather be stupid than a back stabbing traitor.

OP posts:
vulpeculaveritas · 06/11/2016 16:42

"17 million people think otherwise.
Not that you give a shit about them or democracy."

So what about the 16 million people who voted the other way? What about the fact that we have a representative democracy held in check by an independent judiciary and you seek to subvert both of those things.

As another poster has said, the leave vote was not homogeonous, so even for the leave vote to have democracy work for it properly we need parliamentary scrutiny.

Your elites argument is just Trumpist rubbish btw, laughable.

vulpeculaveritas · 06/11/2016 16:44

"back stabbing traitor"

Ahhh, to 48% of the population are traitors now, or how about the leave voters that didn't vote to leave the free market?

They all traitors?

twofingerstoGideon · 06/11/2016 16:45

Seek You forgot poor Iain Duncan Smith who lives in a mansion with his wife, who is the daughter of a baronet. Very obviously a man of the people.

jaws5 · 06/11/2016 16:47

I'd rather be stupid than a back stabbing traitor well, not only stupid but dangerous too.

SeekEveryEveryKnownHidingPlace · 06/11/2016 16:49

A back stabbing traitor? In what possible way?

If anyone's stabbed anyone in the back, it's the peevish ill-informed leave voters who didn't have the wit to understand that the things they were angry about were the result of Tory austerity, not 'immigration' or 'EU red tape'. They stabbed industry, research, universities, anyone who doesn't look obviously 'English' in the back because they wanted to send a fuck-witted 'message'.

jaws5 · 06/11/2016 16:49

Ah, yes. Those egalitarian freedom fighters, Farage, Trump, IDS, Johnsson, Gove.... all men of the people.

vulpeculaveritas · 06/11/2016 16:50

I'd also say that all of this calling for insurrection stuff is very anti democratic too.

surferjet · 06/11/2016 16:54

This is like the miners strike & you'll forever be known as scabs.

Live with it.

OP posts:
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.