Although the school does have banding, with only 25% of places going to high achievers.
I'm not an out-and-out Michael Gove fan, but can the man win? If he'd sent his dd to a private school - well, that would have been suicide. And to a poorly-ranking comprehensive? Would any other middle-class parent do this if they had any choice in the matter? Of course not.
I never understand what is wrong with being "sharp-elbowed middle class". I really don't. Surely the opposite is not caring too much about your dcs' education. And I think the sharpest elbowed of the lot are actually Indian, Chinese and (lately) Nigerian families. We wouldn't castigate them for settling for less. We applaud their commitment and ambition for their dcs.