Should I return the favour?

[MrsSnape]

I sold a dvd box set a few weeks ago. Buyer sent it back saying it was damaged (it wasn't). Anyway after a load of faffing about, I managed to re-sell it and didn't hear from previous buyer again.

So sent the box set off to new buyer yesterday and today received positive feedback for it. Ironically, an hour or so later, the previous buyer (who got a refund and returned item) also left me positive feedback!

So co-incidence or has she been watching my auction since I re-listed it and saw the feedback for the item?

Anyway, do I return the + feedback for her?

I wouldn't, simply because it wasn't a positive transaction and she claimed your goods were damaged when they weren't. Any positive comments you make about her will be misleading to the next seller.

She gave you +ve feedback because you actually did something good (and she probably felt guilty for messing you around).

As a seller, you can only leave positive feedback! So id leave none at all, she doesnt deserve it