Please or to access all these features

Divorce/separation

Here you'll find divorce help and support from other Mners. For legal advice, you may find Advice Now guides useful.

Could I even afford to leave?

24 replies

JohnnyMcGrathSaysFuckOff · Yesterday 13:48

I'd appreciate kindness and honesty here as this has been a raw and painful journey.

Long story short: DH and I seemed very solid. Till we had kids. Slowly over time, a pattern of real selfishness emerged. This manifested in relatively minor and much more serious ways, from being shit about housework and support when I was experiencing PND and struggling with BF, to arguing with me down the phone when I was stuck in hospital after a traumatic twin birth to relegating me to sleeping on a camping mattress when we decided to separate beds, to failing to do pretty much ANY housework when he had 18 mos as a SAHD. The 2 big showstoppers though were him confirming he now has zero sex drive so our intimate life is done, and, repeatedly mismanaging money such that a large chunk of our savings have gone on his credit card bills.

I am therefore thinking about building up to leave.

But, I've always assumed I couldn't financially as although I earn a decent salary I cannot fully fund our mortgage plus a whole second household. Until recently, DH wasn't earning at all. Basically, the only way to split seemed to involve selling our house and moving to a different area. I would not do that as it would mean moving the kids and I am not happy to do that.

However, he now has a job and just on spec, I ran some queries through ChatGPT. I was surprised to see it recommended I could split without selling and I might be able to buy him out of the house.

These are the raw numbers, is this even a remote possibility?

  • I earn £5200 pcm net (after pensions)
  • DH earns £1400
  • Mortgage is £1500 and we have almost 50% equity in house bought for 600,000
  • ChatGPT (I know....) reckons I might be able to remortgage such that I pay off DH share of the equity and take on an enhanced payment
  • This would admittedly leave me with a BIG chunk of my salary going on the mortgage, around 40%

This feels to me at the limits of viability. But, previously I thought I couldn't do it at all!

He's just announced for third month in a row that he can make no contribution to bills/ joint account. I am desperate to have some type of off ramp.

Can anyone advise? Can include more detail as needed.

OP posts:
millymollymoomoo · Yesterday 14:26

On these figures you have a mortgage of 300k and equity of 300k so if you were to buy him out at 50% you’d need a mortgage of 450k. Can you pass affordability tests at this level ? What would happen if you lost your job ?

things to consider

he may be entitled to higher than 50% as a much lower earner.
what will the child arrangements be?
with much lower earnings his needs will arguably be higher than yours as his mortgage raising ability is poor
what pensions do you have ? That will also be due to split ( along with his if there is one)

not trying to stop you doing it but think you need to ensure to understand the full landscape of what a financial separation might look like like

how old are your children now ?
can you sell and buy a smaller house ?
why does he earn so little ?

JohnnyMcGrathSaysFuckOff · Yesterday 14:34

Hi, thanks. Yes this is exactly what I am thinking through.

He earns that little because he took a career break to look after the kids - on paper - but in fact, our kids were well into school age when he did that, so in reality he was home by himself most of the time. He spent it basically doing SFA which was when things really became tense, as I was earning all income, doing all housework and doing all bedtimes and 50% of weekend childcare at least.

I would seek to remain in the house with the kids. Buying him out would ideally leave him with a cash lump sum for a rental or mortgage deposit plus I might be able to offer small amt of spousal maintenance.

OP posts:
JohnnyMcGrathSaysFuckOff · Yesterday 14:37

Children are nearly 9 and nearly 12.

Finding somewhere else is unlikely to save money when moving costs factored in.

It's just the instability killing me. He presents me with these insane credit card bills every month so it's virtually impossible to budget or save for retirement.

OP posts:
summitfever · Yesterday 14:44

Op you need to get away. Everyone has this delusional phase of thinking they need to stay in the big house etc, you don’t. Moving house isn’t the end of the world and you would absolutely make it more affordable to move despite “moving costs”. The fact is this marriage is eroding your human and material resources and if you leave it much longer there won’t be much left to split by the sounds of it. And don’t think it’s not affecting your kids, it is. Speak to a mortgage broker and see what they can do to help you split, whether that’s in this house or another one.

Ponderingwindow · Yesterday 14:46

Is he spending on valid things for the family and he just happens to have a low income because he was a sahd or is his spending frivolous? That might factor into a financial split. If his debt is because he appears to have taken a pay cut to parent and also primarily spends on the children, that would be household debt.

have you accounted for childcare costs? The children are older, but not without cost.

unsync · Yesterday 14:48

What is the credit card situation? Is it in his name? Is he continuing to use them? What has he been spending the money on? This sounds borderline financial abuse. I would start keeping very detailed records, get your hands on as much paperwork around this as possible.

My ex was (amongst the other types of abuse) financially abusive. The Judge in our divorce called him out on it and awarded him nothing bar a sum that went straight to his solicitor.

Gather paperwork and go and see a good divorce solicitor. You need to know what is and isn't possible for your situation. If he's still young, he'll likely be expected to support himself after the first 12 months post separation, especially if he's not having the children 50:50.

JohnnyMcGrathSaysFuckOff · Yesterday 14:56

Thanks @summitfever I'm just a bit paralysed atm, being honest

@Ponderingwindow I don't see his CC bills so it's hard to say. My instinct, he is not spending on "illegitimate" things but that he is unable to stick to a budget.

For example, I asked him when he stopped work to draw up a household budget. He wouldn't. So I did one on my own time and sat him down and asked him to agree, change.

He agreed. Then, just didn't stick to it.

Things like, we had a £240 weekly grocery spend. That should be plenty for 4 people on a budget. He would routinely go over that. Or, instead of being mindful of fuel costs, he'd decide to fill up the 7 seater like 2 days before payday and "just stick £100 on my credit card". Lots of micro decisions like this would mean he ended up with CC bills of £100s every month, often up to £1000. That he would then just announce and take money from joint savings to cover. I asked him to stop using his CC and just use joint acct like I did, so we could budget fairly, but he'd often "forget".

This month e.g. he had a CC bill of £1350 against his income of £1400 so I have zero help with mortgage, bills, car payments.

OP posts:
JohnnyMcGrathSaysFuckOff · Yesterday 14:58

Sorry typo above, "5 people on a budget"

OP posts:
LadyGardenersQuestionTime · Yesterday 15:09

He will not qualify for spousal maintenance. The living needs of the kids are top priority so your equity split is likely to depend on what the children's arrangements are (will it be reasonable for them to share a room at his place?). But whatever happens you will be so much better off not funding this drain on your resources.

Remember he is freeloading on your children, not just from you. Stay tough.

millymollymoomoo · Yesterday 15:42

He’s unlikely to qualify for spousal but he is very likely to be awarded a higher than 50% share of assets ( which includes pension) as he’ll claim he sacrificed his career and earnings to be a sahd - just as women do - whether that’s reality or not. And as the lower earner regardless he’s in a much worse position hence that may be offset with higher capital and share of assets

LemonTT · Yesterday 16:50

The divorce will aim to make you both “equal”. Given he has a substantially lower income he may get more than 50% of the assets because he is the weaker party. A larger share of the assets as part of a clean break is going to be preferred by him and the courts. You won’t be funding two households. But you might be funding a smaller home for yourself and your children.

GPT chat won’t give you reliable advice. It will be based off opinions it can scrape from social media. The best thing you can do is consult a solicitor and to present relevant facts for the discussion. The relevant facts will be details of the marital assets and maybe pertinent information about his career history. The later may inform whether you can argue he could earn more either by working longer hours or to his best earning potential.

The answer to your question is that yes you can afford to divorce. But it will result in a reduced standard of living and/ or a smaller home.

JohnnyMcGrathSaysFuckOff · Yesterday 18:08

Thanks everyone and def not relying on AI, was just a starter point!

The thing about a smaller house is, it would mean moving the kids' schools and I'm not prepared to do that for any reason. We moved to this area 2y ago and they are happy and settled so I won't risk that. This area is expensive and there just aren't substantially cheaper houses in this catchment.

However that does let me put a timeframe on it, in years not decades, which is something.

OP posts:
JohnnyMcGrathSaysFuckOff · Yesterday 18:11

As for could he earn more, yes easily. He decided to take a career break when we moved. There were jobs available round here but he didn't apply. He then only applied for PT work in very niche areas, which is what he is doing now. This is absolutely not necessary for childcare as DD1 walks to and from school, has her own key, and is okay to be on her own after school. Our younger children have a fab afterschool club. We don't need him ti be PT, it's absolutely his choice.

OP posts:
FennelSnack · Yesterday 18:21

I agree with others that, once you're this far into needing to leave, you will make it work whatever the numbers are. But given what you say, here are my thoughts-

  1. how are your pensions? It's possible you could agree to something other than 50-50 on the house if the split on pensions ends up more generous to him. (NB he will need to be able to house himself)
  2. house prices have dropped in a lot of the country, especially south east. This could make it an advantageous time to be working out the split- if your house is worth 10% less that's 5% you don't have to give him.
  3. The best budget calculator I know is this one https://www.moneysavingexpert.com/banking/budget-planning/ It's pretty comprehensive. Put absolutely everything in (based on having split) and see how much it comes to.
  4. Any sense of whether he will want 50-50 with the kids?
  5. Is there any reason he's been PT eg ill health? If not that court will expect him to get a full time job.
Marmight · Yesterday 19:11

Can you take at least half of the joint savings to protect them and put them in a separate account in your name only?
If not he is going to use them all.

Brentinger · Yesterday 20:08

Following - I could have written the exact same post myself with an almost identical situation....although months into asking for a divorce.

Passaggressfedup · Today 08:17

Ultimately, your roles are reversed as the standard set up. He could make the same argument in court than most mothers make.

That he has and always been the main carer for the children. A court might agree to 50/50 but would be highly unlikely to give you full residence.

That you were financially controlling. That by giving up his career, it helped you advanced in yours.

That he could go back FT but would still be limited in his earning compared to yours.

He would get at least 50% of all the assets and you might need to pay 50% of his debts if he can show the money was spent on the house and family. He could convince a judge that he needs more to house the children even on a FT salary.

Your argument and frustration are the same than those of men usually who want to separate.

JohnnyMcGrathSaysFuckOff · Today 09:39

Oh I can see all that, I really can.

And I don't deny he has helped my career, and I don't want to shaft him.

A judge might well not listen, but my responses would be

He did not need to stop working and whilst he has always earned less (he did when we met as he has lower qualifications) he only stopped work entirely when kids were in Ys 2 and 5, respectively. I find it hard to see that makes him primary carer as basically it involved him having them 1530 to 1800 after school. I still did my share of drop offs, every bedtime, and weekends.

Re being financially controlling, I honestly think it's the reverse! I have put together a budget and ensured we saved. He persistently took/ takes money from savings and advocates for raiding kids' savings too. Which I refuse. One of my low points was one month, I'd looked through the figures and could just make the budget work. Then he announced casually, "okay but you'll need to pay my credit card bill, and it's £900."

Which is huge in the scale of our income.

It was right before Xmas too, so I ended up foregoing presents amongst other things to make it up.

I just honestly don't think I'm the bad guy here.

OP posts:
BingeleyBingeleyBeep · Today 09:48

Advice: GO SEE A LAWYER!

Google Says this may be an option.
The Mesher Order
When divorcing in the UK, if you have dependent children under 18, the family courts prioritize the welfare and housing needs of the children above an immediate property split.
A common legal mechanism used to handle this is a Mesher Order:

  • Deferred Sale: The sale of the family home is legally postponed (deferred) until a specific "trigger event" occurs—most commonly when the youngest child turns 18 or finishes full-time secondary/higher education.
  • Retaining Equity: Both partners typically retain their agreed percentage share (equity) in the property during the delay, meaning the partner who moves out does not lose their stake.
  • Trigger Events: Aside from the youngest child turning 18, a Mesher Order often specifies that the house will be sold earlier if the resident parent remarries, cohabits with a new partner, or voluntarily moves out. Once the trigger event happens, the house is sold and the equity is divided according to the court-approved

Hope this is useful

LemonTT · Today 11:17

BingeleyBingeleyBeep · Today 09:48

Advice: GO SEE A LAWYER!

Google Says this may be an option.
The Mesher Order
When divorcing in the UK, if you have dependent children under 18, the family courts prioritize the welfare and housing needs of the children above an immediate property split.
A common legal mechanism used to handle this is a Mesher Order:

  • Deferred Sale: The sale of the family home is legally postponed (deferred) until a specific "trigger event" occurs—most commonly when the youngest child turns 18 or finishes full-time secondary/higher education.
  • Retaining Equity: Both partners typically retain their agreed percentage share (equity) in the property during the delay, meaning the partner who moves out does not lose their stake.
  • Trigger Events: Aside from the youngest child turning 18, a Mesher Order often specifies that the house will be sold earlier if the resident parent remarries, cohabits with a new partner, or voluntarily moves out. Once the trigger event happens, the house is sold and the equity is divided according to the court-approved

Hope this is useful

The OP is the stronger party, she is a high earner and may have a 6 figure settlement to secure a new home. Her husband earns much less and is not likely to be able to afford to rent in their high cost area. Unless they both agree to one, the OP is unlikely to be able to get a court to agree to it. He has more chance of getting one and that isn’t even likely.

I agree she should see a lawyer.

LemonTT · Today 11:34

JohnnyMcGrathSaysFuckOff · Today 09:39

Oh I can see all that, I really can.

And I don't deny he has helped my career, and I don't want to shaft him.

A judge might well not listen, but my responses would be

He did not need to stop working and whilst he has always earned less (he did when we met as he has lower qualifications) he only stopped work entirely when kids were in Ys 2 and 5, respectively. I find it hard to see that makes him primary carer as basically it involved him having them 1530 to 1800 after school. I still did my share of drop offs, every bedtime, and weekends.

Re being financially controlling, I honestly think it's the reverse! I have put together a budget and ensured we saved. He persistently took/ takes money from savings and advocates for raiding kids' savings too. Which I refuse. One of my low points was one month, I'd looked through the figures and could just make the budget work. Then he announced casually, "okay but you'll need to pay my credit card bill, and it's £900."

Which is huge in the scale of our income.

It was right before Xmas too, so I ended up foregoing presents amongst other things to make it up.

I just honestly don't think I'm the bad guy here.

Divorce is no fault in the UK. There are limited circumstances in which conduct would impact the outcome but none apply here. The entire process will be about sharing out the marital assets and agreeing on co-parenting. The purpose of no fault divorce is stop blame and mud slinging which is detrimental to children. A judge won’t listen to it and a solicitor will charge you for every hour you talk about it.

Unless he lacks capacity in some way you won’t be able to shaft him. You won’t be in control. English divorce laws protect the financially weaker party. You need to minimise the impact of this. Which is why you need to be able to argue he can earn more money.

One other factor that may be useful to you is that judges don’t like situations where children have to move school during their key exam years. Arguing the house sale should be deferred until the exams are done can work. But your kids would need to be 15/16 or 17/18.

millymollymoomoo · Today 13:02

Ops ‘ex’ is the more likely to get a mesher if either was !

agree, go see a laywer but be prepared…. You are the stronger party and divorce typically ‘favours’ the weaker one in terms of asset division

GrumpyOleEyeore · Today 13:39

I was in a similar situation and would suggest you don’t get mesher unless last resort because every mortgage payment you make while that’s in place you are gifting him 50% When the mesher ends people often find their share isn’t enough to buy what they need. It really is better to take the financial hit while you are working and young enough to rebuild.

I bought ex out and my mortgage is 40% my income and I make it work. I will downsize and pay it off not hold the mortgage for full term. I remortgaged to age 70 to make payments manageable until dc leave.

My family house has gone up a lot in value so while things are tight month to month and I’m paying stack interest it’s still a good investment. If I couldn’t manage I could sell up and move as it’s a desirable house / area.

Don’t waste time arguing about the past the court isn’t interested in litigating people’s marriages they will say past contribution was 50:50 and even if it wasn’t you accepted that by staying. They aren’t there to resolve marriage disputes only future finances.

There was a gap between separation and settlement so it was established ex had done limited childcare and had moved away and didn’t intend house dc except weekend and holidays.His housing need was found to be less than mine. This was one factor in him getting less than 50%. Judge also found dc shouldn’t be disrupted. So even though I earned more I got more than 50%.

If he’s lazy and selfish the chances are he won’t do much childcare. And you won’t be able to rely on much if any CM. However you will save a lot by having control over finances. I was so much better off financially when exh moved out he hadn’t been covering his basic expenses let alone contributing to bills for a long time. He would also run up expenses for his hobbies etc (when he should have been working). You will probably find you can run your household on a lot less.

If he will do some childcare make sure that means he’s covering share childcare costs and it covers before and after work on ‘his’ days.

There are so many variables that can move the dial from 50:50 no one can advise without knowing the full details. Generally if one parent has dc much more they can expect 55-60%. Your salary isn’t that huge if all dc costs fall on you.

Pension will also be an issue and if yours is more you will have to share this.

At this stage you also don’t know if he will insist on 50:50 £ or more, some dads will put the dc first and accept less. Especially if legal and moving costs were deducted as that would reduce the pot.

Do you think he will want to live locally and share childcare? Be prepared that the total opposite may happen and he may do nothing. The one shock of separating was seeing exH ditch our dc to live the bachelor lifestyle. I really hadn’t anticipated that even though I knew he was lazy and selfish.

Rather than thinking can you afford to leave work out what it’s costing you to stay. Not just the uneven bill share month to month but the fact every mortgage and pension payment you make you are gifting him 50% of those savings. When you retire if he has no pension of his own you will be sharing yours every month knowing he did SFA to earn it.

millymollymoomoo · Today 18:30

You’re not gifting the other party anything - you are trying up their capital so they cannot use it to their win benefit or invest it elsewhere so you are simply paying them back their capital investment with appreciation that they would get had you not had the benefit of tying it up for years.

however, I agree with the sentiment of the rest of the post and would usually say Meshers only work for a very short period or as absolute last resort yes

New posts on this thread. Refresh page