Please or to access all these features

Dadsnet

Speak to new fathers on our Dads forum.

No idea what to do child maintenance

24 replies

Beaker38 · Yesterday 23:26

Very long story short I have 2 children the oldest lives with his mum permanently because she told him when he was 16 if he did he would get an iPhone and ps5 and said horrible things about me so he said he was 16 and allowed to decide where he lives, I had no choice as court agreed once he was 16 it was his choice. He is now 18 and his mum makes him go to college that he hates so she doesn’t lose the full child maintenance that I pay. His sister my other child tells me he hates it and wants to leave but won’t. I have tried a million times to explain to him what his mum is doing but because he gets everything he wants with her he won’t stay with me. I’m at the point where my debts from home are overwhelming and I just can’t afford to pay it but she won’t listen, because my Wageslip shows a certain amount it doesn’t take into consideration other bills. I have been on the phone a million times to child maintenance and they said nothing they can do.
Im at breaking point and the lowest point of my life I don’t know what to do, can anyone advise?

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · Yesterday 23:29

Where does your daugher live and don't you pay maintenance for her ?
CMS is only a % of your income, how come you can't afford it any more.

CharlotteSometimes1 · Yesterday 23:30

What are you hoping to change?

Beaker38 · Yesterday 23:32

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · Yesterday 23:29

Where does your daugher live and don't you pay maintenance for her ?
CMS is only a % of your income, how come you can't afford it any more.

My daughter lives 50/50 but she’s been telling me her mum is trying to get her to live with her when she turns 16 (next year) it is a % but with everything going up I’m not making enough money, I’m selling everything I own just to get by and I’m dreading Christmas

OP posts:
Beaker38 · Yesterday 23:34

Can I also mention she makes 3 times more than me in her job so she doesn’t even need the money (plus she lives with her fiancée he also has a good job)

OP posts:
maggisimpson · Yesterday 23:35

Of course he should stay at college and finish his qualification.
Lots of teenage boys want to quit and stay at home but in the long run he will be better off with a qualification.

If you have a lot of debts have you tried getting some debt advice?

Beaker38 · Yesterday 23:36

I am not saying I shouldn’t pay anything I have always paid the correct amount and always on time but she’s forcing him to attend college he hates and I don’t get a say in what he does or where he lives as he’s over 16

OP posts:
maggisimpson · Yesterday 23:37

Stepchange is a charity and can give you free debt advice https://www.stepchange.org/

StepChange Debt Charity. Free Expert Debt Help & Advice

https://www.stepchange.org

NoNathanielNoThereMustBeMoreToLife · Yesterday 23:38

She is forcing an 18yo to stay in college just so she can claim maintenence, despite earning 3x more than you?

And you want him to quit college so your maintenence gets reduced?

Beaker38 · Yesterday 23:38

maggisimpson · Yesterday 23:35

Of course he should stay at college and finish his qualification.
Lots of teenage boys want to quit and stay at home but in the long run he will be better off with a qualification.

If you have a lot of debts have you tried getting some debt advice?

He wants to be a carpenter and he’s in college studying physics and sociology which he hates he just does what she asks because he doesn’t want to lose his free phones and clothes etc

OP posts:
Beaker38 · Yesterday 23:39

NoNathanielNoThereMustBeMoreToLife · Yesterday 23:38

She is forcing an 18yo to stay in college just so she can claim maintenence, despite earning 3x more than you?

And you want him to quit college so your maintenence gets reduced?

I want him to live with me I miss him terribly I have always paid the correct amount and never missed a payment

OP posts:
Quitelikeit · Yesterday 23:40

I thought cm stopped at 18th birthday regardless of the educational status of the child

Beaker38 · Yesterday 23:41

Quitelikeit · Yesterday 23:40

I thought cm stopped at 18th birthday regardless of the educational status of the child

No it carries on until they are 21 or 22 I believe if they are in full time education

OP posts:
maggisimpson · Yesterday 23:41

Beaker38 · Yesterday 23:38

He wants to be a carpenter and he’s in college studying physics and sociology which he hates he just does what she asks because he doesn’t want to lose his free phones and clothes etc

If he's capable of studying physics then he should, don't discourage him because it will be cheaper for you.

Heatedblankettime · Yesterday 23:41

It won't do him any harm to get some academic qualifications.

And I have two 16 year old boys and I think you are kidding yourself if you think he's been lured into not seeing you by promises of iPhones.

NoNathanielNoThereMustBeMoreToLife · Yesterday 23:42

Beaker38 · Yesterday 23:39

I want him to live with me I miss him terribly I have always paid the correct amount and never missed a payment

The 'correct' amount will barely touch the sides of what it costs to raise a child.

If you cant afford maintenence how will you afford to fund him living with you?

StreetFighter16 · Yesterday 23:42

Maybe, get a grip? To summarise, your ex makes your son do what millions of parents in the UK do every day - go to an educational setting. I’ve 4 children and none of them wanted to go but it’s tough shit, they’re being educated. If you’re in England he has to keep going anyway, he can’t just leave, he would need something else lined up. She’s got his best interests at heart. You can’t do anything, no judge in the land would force a parent to make their child leave college because the other parent doesn’t think they like it. If he’s 18 he must be leaving this academic year anyway, suck it up, get a Saturday job until then.

sesquipedalian · Yesterday 23:42

I don’t understand why you would want your DS to leave college, as surely it’s in his interests to finish and get some qualifications, whether he likes it or not, and he’ll be glad of them later. You do know that children have to stay in education or training until they’re 18, and that you are financially liable for them until the end of August of that academic year? If your wage slip shows a certain amount, I assume it is the basis for your contribution, and it’s supremely irrelevant how much your ex earns. If CM have said there’s nothing they can do, then there’s nothing to be done - if you are falling into arrears in your other bills, the only thing you can do is look for supplementary work to augment your income. It’s not reasonable to economise on your children just because you’ve taken on too many outgoings. You seem very put out that your son lives with his mother - surely it would cost you a lot more if he were to live with you?

maggisimpson · Yesterday 23:43

Quitelikeit · Yesterday 23:40

I thought cm stopped at 18th birthday regardless of the educational status of the child

Children are entitled to financial support until they finish A-Levels or equivalent, or turn 20.

Beaker38 · Yesterday 23:47

Thank you all for your help and advice, I just came here to see if there was anything I could do to maybe see if it’s worth me carrying on. I have never done a single thing my children’s mother has claimed I swear that on their lives and I honestly believe they will be better off financially and have so much more security without me. Take care and thanks again

OP posts:
KnitOneSlipOneKnitOnePassSlippedStitchOver · Yesterday 23:49

Beaker38 · Yesterday 23:34

Can I also mention she makes 3 times more than me in her job so she doesn’t even need the money (plus she lives with her fiancée he also has a good job)

It’s not your ex-wife’s fiancée’s responsibility to pay for your children’s costs, so leave him out of the equation.

Your ex-wife must be earning very well if she’s earning 3x your wage - even if you make minimum wage, that would put her earning over £80k. But it’s irrelevant. You made two children, so each of you is equally responsible for their costs. CMS rates are not generous, so making the payments they mandate is the very least you can do. Your child doesn’t cease to cost anything just because he doesn’t want to live with you.

Encourage him to stay in college so he is set up to support himself in adulthood. Don’t make your debts your child’s problem.

MotherJessAndKittens · Yesterday 23:50

You need to separate your debts from his well being. He is 18 so in law an adult. It would be counter productive for him to leave college without a qualification as then what would he do? If he really hates it then if he is 18 he could leave without his mums say so but then what would he do? Currently there is a huge issue with young people who are not in education or employment. Maybe try to find out what work he would like to do and help him find out how to get a job, apprenticeship or similar?

CherryKerry · Yesterday 23:57

Beaker38 · Yesterday 23:47

Thank you all for your help and advice, I just came here to see if there was anything I could do to maybe see if it’s worth me carrying on. I have never done a single thing my children’s mother has claimed I swear that on their lives and I honestly believe they will be better off financially and have so much more security without me. Take care and thanks again

Sounds like CM is one of many outgoings you have and there is a bigger overall issue.

Can I suggest popping onto Money Saving Expert debt free wannabee forum (Google it) and you'll find really good help and advice there if you reach out. Mumsnet isn't the place for a man to get financial advice when it comes to child support.

Quitelikeit · Today 00:00

Surely he is due to leave college though?

also taking two a level classes may not meet the 12 hour weekly requirement for csa

WaneyEdge · Today 00:10

StreetFighter16 · Yesterday 23:42

Maybe, get a grip? To summarise, your ex makes your son do what millions of parents in the UK do every day - go to an educational setting. I’ve 4 children and none of them wanted to go but it’s tough shit, they’re being educated. If you’re in England he has to keep going anyway, he can’t just leave, he would need something else lined up. She’s got his best interests at heart. You can’t do anything, no judge in the land would force a parent to make their child leave college because the other parent doesn’t think they like it. If he’s 18 he must be leaving this academic year anyway, suck it up, get a Saturday job until then.

No he wouldn’t need something else lined up. Nothing happens if they become NEET. No fines, no one checks. Just can’t claim benefits.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page