Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Covid

Mumsnet doesn't verify the qualifications of users. If you have medical concerns, please consult a healthcare professional.

Todays u-turn from DfE, key workers working from home should NOT send kids to school

371 replies

Esmerelda01 · 09/01/2021 21:20

In case you've not seen.

Could cause a lot of people issues on Monday

www.theguardian.com/education/2021/jan/09/school-guidance-for-children-of-key-workers-changes-again?CMP=twt_a-education_b-gdnedu

OP posts:
HikeForward · 11/01/2021 14:49

ITS NOT ABOUT WHAT IS BEST FOR YOU ITS ABOUT WHAT IS BEST FOR EVERYONE AS A WHOLE, IF THERES A PARENT AT HOME THEN THE CHILD NEEDS TO BE TOO. END OF!

Not if the parent at home is the main earner and cannot supervise/home school (to allow the lesser earning parent to go to work). A consultant or lawyer working from home is not going to quit her job or take unpaid leave so her husband can keep working part time as a hospital porter. On his salary alone how do they pay the mortgage, bills, secure decent futures for the kids and put food on the table? Either they use keyworker places to cover the days he works, or he leaves his job in the NHS.

Do you really think families will sacrifice their income, home and children’s futures for the good of society?

OverTheRainbow88 · 11/01/2021 14:58

@HikeForward

That’s no different to a family with two workers neither key workers.

ceeveebee · 11/01/2021 15:04

Generally the more well paid and senior an employee is, the more autotomy and flexibility they have over their diary. I know many many lawyers, accountants, other professionals who are making homeschooling work despite being in main breadwinner roles

Anonandonandonandon · 11/01/2021 17:29

Ugh. I’m so conflicted by all of this, it’s making me ill. The constantly changing guidance just makes it worse and I’m having to make a judgment call as to whether sending my child to school has a greater negative impact than me not doing my job to the best of my ability.

I have a 5 yo and a 3 yo. DH and I are both genuine critical workers. Nobody would want us to stop doing what we do. Last time around both kids (then 4 and 2) went to school / nursery part time, on the 3 days I was on site working for the NHS. DH took all his remaining leave to keep them home for all but 2 days for the majority of that time. There were a maximum of 5 children across the whole school attending at any one time.

DH cannot work from home. I am working from home 95% of the time, playing a significant role in NHS Covid testing. I was asked to increase my hours because of Covid so now work 3 x 9 hour days and 1 x 3.5 hour day around my 3 yo’s (expensive) nursery hours.

School have given us a place for our 5 yo but have said it must be full time.

There are SO many children in school that I’m considering pulling my 5yo old out. Not because I’m concerned about him individually, but because I want to see the numbers reduce. I just can’t see how I’m going to manage to achieve my hours when I’m already working significant unpaid overtime to keep up with what needs to be done.

I read these headlines and think everyone must think I’m taking the piss.

I’ve shared my frets (probably came out as a ramble!) with the headmaster. I’m hoping he will at least consider allowing us to send the 5yo in only when needed, which would realistically be my 3 x 9 hour days. It’s so difficult for the school to know what to do as they were advised full time for anyone who qualifies.

Jetatyeovilaerodrome · 11/01/2021 19:47

@Anonandonandonandon seriously, just do what is best for you and your child, don't mind a fuck what anyone else thinks, it's none of their business. You don't have to justify anything to anyone, if the school is happy to have you child and you are happy for him to attend and will make your working day much easier, then send him. These threads on MN are getting ridiculous now.

studychick81 · 11/01/2021 19:54

[quote Jetatyeovilaerodrome]@Anonandonandonandon seriously, just do what is best for you and your child, don't mind a fuck what anyone else thinks, it's none of their business. You don't have to justify anything to anyone, if the school is happy to have you child and you are happy for him to attend and will make your working day much easier, then send him. These threads on MN are getting ridiculous now.[/quote]
Probably not best for the child though if the get covid or pass it to one of your family members. What's best in nearly all cases is for the child to be at home if they possibly can, obviously not if they are vulnerable, or parents are out at work.

ceeveebee · 11/01/2021 19:58

There are SO many children in school that I’m considering pulling my 5yo old out

And this is the problem. An actual real critical workers who is critical to the COVID response, is considering not sending their child because the school is full of those who bend the rules...

3littlewords · 11/01/2021 20:29

probably not best for the child though if they get covid and pass it to one of your family members. What's best in nearly all cases is for the child to be at home if they possibly can, obviously not if they are vulnerable, or parents out at work

This!
Obviously apart from those who are special, are covid immune or just can't be bothered in general to try and work out flexible options with their partners and employers to support keeping their child at home where its safer for everyone. No one at all said its easy because it really isn't, but there does seem to be some arrogance from some posters that because they are entitled to a school place due to loose rules by the government that they shouldn't try and work out some kind of compromise.
If this new varient is as highly contagious as they say its unlikely that many children will be in school long before the bubbles burst anyway and then no one is in school at all regardless of keyworker or vulnerable status. Reducing the amount of dc that attend reduces the likelihood off bubbles closing and those who do actually have to work out side the home from taking time off in the peak of the pandemic.

Jetatyeovilaerodrome · 11/01/2021 23:29

My point was that no one should base their decision about what to do with regards to schooling their child on what people on Mumsnet will think.

HikeForward · 12/01/2021 06:40

That’s no different to a family with two workers neither key workers

It’s different because the Porter is needed by the NHS for the covid response. Hospitals are desperately short staffed (including lower paid jobs like porters, security guards, healthcare assistants, IT staff, ward clerks).

If he can’t work because his wife is the breadwinner and can’t supervise kids without jeopardising her job, and school has denied them a place because wife is WFH; the NHS loses another desperately needed member of staff!

HikeForward · 12/01/2021 06:42

probably not best for the child though if they get covid and pass it to one of your family members

What if a child has recently had confirmed covid so is immune and can neither catch nor transmit the virus? A lot of children of keyworkers have already had covid.

Nicknamegoeshere · 12/01/2021 11:34

Why on earth do people believe if you've had Covid before you're immune?! YOU'RE NOT!!!!

whittystitties · 12/01/2021 16:05

@Nicknamegoeshere

Why on earth do people believe if you've had Covid before you're immune?! YOU'RE NOT!!!!
You have an unknown quantity of immunity, could be months, could be years. I don't think it's unreasonable to want normality back if you've already had it.!
Parker231 · 12/01/2021 16:33

A study released in July suggested Covid antibody levels fall over a period of three months, in some cases becoming undetectable. Research has also suggested that the speed and scale of this decline may differ between men and women. The level of antibodies produced, and the length of time they hang around for, seems to be linked to the severity of the disease.

GypsyLee · 12/01/2021 16:40

@HikeForward

ITS NOT ABOUT WHAT IS BEST FOR YOU ITS ABOUT WHAT IS BEST FOR EVERYONE AS A WHOLE, IF THERES A PARENT AT HOME THEN THE CHILD NEEDS TO BE TOO. END OF!

Not if the parent at home is the main earner and cannot supervise/home school (to allow the lesser earning parent to go to work). A consultant or lawyer working from home is not going to quit her job or take unpaid leave so her husband can keep working part time as a hospital porter. On his salary alone how do they pay the mortgage, bills, secure decent futures for the kids and put food on the table? Either they use keyworker places to cover the days he works, or he leaves his job in the NHS.

Do you really think families will sacrifice their income, home and children’s futures for the good of society?

I'd expect him to take leave or give up his job, surely the lawyer is making enough to not want other people to risk their lives to provide their childcare. Two parents no excuse. It's the sp with no help with childcare and vulnerable children who should be allowed to attend schools and nurseris.
mumwalk · 12/01/2021 23:33

The way I see it is that people should not be attempting to secure places that they would "like" but don't actually "need". The more children that go into schools the more likely it is that the children of critical workers will catch and transmit it to their parents. Not only might the critical worker get sick themselves, but even if they don't, they won't be able to do their job. This in turn impacts us all. We all need to do what we can to minimise this possibility.

TableFlowerss · 13/01/2021 00:04

I'd expect him to take leave or give up his job, surely the lawyer is making enough to not want other people to risk their lives to provide their childcare.
Two parents no excuse.
It's the sp with no help with childcare and vulnerable children who should be allowed to attend schools and nurseris

@GypsyLee

Oh yea, course a solicitor and main bread winner will give up they job in order to hone school their children for a few weeks/months.

As if someone is going to sacrifice an income like that for the ‘good of society’ 🙄

Folk don’t even help themselves, flouncing the rules here there and everywhere.

ceeveebee · 13/01/2021 10:31

I think “he” in this case was referring to the hospital Porter, not the lawyer...

3littlewords · 13/01/2021 11:26

@ceeveebee

I think “he” in this case was referring to the hospital Porter, not the lawyer...
I'm sure porters don't only work school hours either so could ask for only evening or weekend work for the time being . Its tough but you'd think the NHS would be the most flexible as they can be with their staff to reduce community transmission. I know its not always that simple to change shifts etc but its certainly an avenue people should explore between them rather than just dismiss it altogether
HikeForward · 13/01/2021 12:52

I'm sure porters don't only work school hours either so could ask for only evening
or weekend work for the time being. Its tough but you'd think the NHS would be the most flexible as they can be with their staff to reduce community transmission. I know its not always that simple to change shifts etc but its certainly an avenue people should explore between them rather than just dismiss it altogether

Porters work shifts, but with so many off sick with covid or isolating I don’t think working only evenings or weekends would be permitted, he’d be expected to cover whatever shifts he’s on the rota for, including daytime shifts. Same if he were a nursing assistant or worked in the hospital canteen or as a ward clerk or cleaner.

My point was, if mum is a full time lawyer and dad is a part time hospital porter, they are likely to prioritise her job as it pays the bills. Dad could leave his NHS job and home school the kids without risk of the family losing their main income.

But do we want porters and other lower paid NHS staff leaving their jobs in a pandemic?

If the kids got keyworker places due to dad being a critical worker, it would allow him to work his shifts, provided mum had flexibility to drop off and pick up the kids most days.

IndecentFeminist · 13/01/2021 13:02

This wasn't really a u turn was it? Our school always approached it that a school place was absolute last resort

New posts on this thread. Refresh page