Full disclaimer - I love this stuff but know it does some people's heads in so no offence if it's not for you (or everybody else already knows this and it's just me)
Stumbled onto a 2008 research paper on hCG after implantation & thought it was fascinating and helped me understand a bit more and hope it will now save me a tonne of dough on early testing
Started a new thread so it doesn't clog up any existing buses or discussions, hope that's OK.
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5330618/
Key bits -
You can have an existing level of 1 - 5 hCG miu/ml without being pregnant
hCG development varies a lot from woman to woman but as a general rule levels double every 48 hours post-implantation
Implantation can be as early as 6dpo and as late as 12dpo; mean & median is 9dpo
Implantation at 10dpo or later shows a slower rate of increase in hCG levels overall
So, the following examples assume the same 28 day cycle and the same ovulation date but show very different length of time to BFP:
if a woman implants at 8dpo, with an existing non-pregnant hCG level of 1 miu, it would rise as follows
8dpo - 1miu
10dpo - 2miu
12dpo - 4miu
14dpo (AF is typically due) - 8miu
16dpo - 16miu
So a FRER (needs 6.3miu for a line) couldn't show this lady she was pregnant until 13dpo and a one-step (needs 10miu for a line) 15dpo. If she implanted at 6dpo a FRER could read pregnant 10dpo; if she implanted at 12dpo she couldn't show a positive on a FRER until 18dpo, several days after AF was due in a standard cycle.
if a woman who implants at 8dpo and has an existing non-pregnant hCG level of 5 miu, it looks like this:
8dpo - 5miu
10dpo - 10miu
12dpo - 20miu
14dpo (AF typically due) - 40miu
This lady would read pregnant on a FRER at 9dpo and on a one-step at 10dpo. By the time AF is due, most tests would tell her she was pregnant. If implantation occurred at 6dpo, a FRER could show pregnancy at 7dpo; if she implanted at 12dpo a FRER could show pregnancy at 13dpo, or when AF was due.
If you've managed to read this far there's a calculator here that allows you to play with starting hCG levels & earliest possible testing whenmybaby.com/implantation-doubling-calculator.php