Last year I got my dd7 the following:
Piranha Panic game (she asked for this)
High School Musical 1 and 2 film DVD (HSM)aand also both the soundtracks too
HSM Mic
Sticker Refill Cello
HSM drinks bottle
HSM Sticker book
3 Jewellery sets from Monsoon (necklace / ring/ hair clips)
HSM Flip phone
Top Trump HSM
20 Q Gadget (she asked for)
Makeup case with makeup in
Aquabeads
HSM Annual
42 books (all Enid Blyton - she loves reading)
HSM costume
Rainbow Fairy Jigsaw book and 4 reading books
HSM Nail set
HSM Dance mat
10 other HSM reading books
Other presents she shared with her sister (5)
are
digital camera vtech zoom
Box set of disney shoes (they both asked for)
Dressing Table (asked for)
Pink Monopoly
Polly Pocket Jet plane
Disney Pop up chest
Helly Kitty Boombox
Musical Pom Pom HSM
Mys other 5 year old dd had her own presents (approx 16)
All this sound a lot but their birthdays are aalso on Christmas Eve and 19th Dec so I tend to spoil them a bit.
Also in their stockings were HSM watches, Keyrings HSM balls, toothbrush holders, Aautomatic pencil sharpener, socks and sweets.
Out of all of these, the boombox which I got from Smyths was the best. They use it all the time. The camera is very good too. The love all the soundtracks of HSM. Shes got through a lot of books already. Aquabeads were good too.
One good idea was that I bought both of them a locket and necklace from Monsoon and put their other photos in there so dd7 has dd5 in hers and dd5 has dd7 in hers.
When she has friends round, the Dance mat and Piranha Panic comes out. Also the Monopoly set and disney shoes.
Make up sometime used and also 20Q when she remembers to play them.
The worse one was the Polly Jet which I paid £30 for and bought 3 that day (2 for other friends).
Now this year, I am stump.......sorry so long, hope there are a few ideas in there!