Which advent calender should I get - please choose one!

[rebelmum72]

Ds is 20 months, and I think will really enjoy Christmas this year.
I would like to get a wooden drawer-type advent calender which we can use every year.
These are the two nicest ones that I have found, and I cannot decide between them:

train advent calender

or

box-type advent calender

(I'm in Germany, hence the links being in German!)

Please help me make a decision - I've been trying to pick one for two weeks now!!

Hello. They are both nice but I prefer the train as I think it looks more festive

I really wouldnt get the train one, although it is the nicest one.
Ds was given a similar one, but naturally, he wanted to play with it and push it along, and all the drawers kept falling out!
Have put it away this year and hope he has forgotten about it (but i'm mean)

Ah, that is a very good point, flipflopper, I hadn't thought of that...

what about this from amazon?