Quality street vs Roses vs Celebrations vs Heroes

[Jesscarbqueen87]

How would you rank them?

For me, it would have to be

• Roses
• Celebrations
• Heroes
• Quality street

Although for me quality street is the most ‘Christmassy’ of the 4 and I still buy a tub every Christmas

Completely agree with your rankings although probably wound have heroes on there at all - too many of those bloody eclair ones

I find quality street a bit over hyped these days - we got a tin of Sainsbury version the other day £3.50 and tasted better

Probably:
Heroes
Celebrations
Roses
Quality street

@ivfbeenbusy Totally agree, too many eclairs in heroes, plus I’m not a fan of the cream egg one either. I think I only buy quality street because I like the packaging 🙈 oh and the green triangle! The green triangle is amazing

Mine would be
Celebrations
Quality Street
Heros
Roses

Heros have too many of the creme egg ones in
Roses used to be nice but the chocolate became awful
Having said that, they all used to be much better than they are now.

Quality Street
Roses
Heroes
Celebrations

Although really, it would be:

Quality Street
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
Roses, Heroes, Celebrations - all on the same bottom tier because they are all rank.

Roses
Quality street
Heroes
Celebrations

Quality street
Celebrations
Heroes
Roses

Especially as you can buy quality street that only has the nice ones in. Green triangle and orange creams. Yum.

I’ve never had roses or heroes and wasn’t sure what they are (not much of a sweet tooth).
Blimey !
Celebrations.
Quality street
Heroes
Roses - based only on description and look though.

Quality street then Roses. you can keep the others. Small versions of bog standard chocolate bars don't excite me. Well apart from the Malteser ones, they are good.

Quality Street have really upped their game at the same time those Roses have taken a nose dive. I love the fudge QS.

Celebrations
Quality Street
Heroes
Roses

Quality street
Celebrations
Heroes
Roses

Not sure why, but not terribly keen on Roses. QS comes top because The Purple One.

Celebrations
Quality street
Heroes
Roses

Celebrations come out on top because there’s not one chocolate I don’t like in them!

Heroes up top IMO because they are just normal chocolates made small.

And celebrations obvs

Quality Street only here. Even if they aren't great anymore. I tried the M&S equivalent one year and even though the chocolates were actually nicer it just wasn't the same. Growing up my Grandma used to buy us a tin, back when it was a huge tin, it used to sit under the tree until we were allowed to open it. Such a treat. Quality Street is Christmas for me.

I would buy all four and be done with it!

Quality Street, but wish they would bring back the toffee deluxe sweetie

Don't like Quality street or Roses any more. I bought a large 2.4 kg box of Celebrations and they were mostly all Mars and Milky Ways which have just been left.

Roses
Heroes
Quality Street
Celebrations

None. Don’t buy any of them anymore, and haven’t for the past 4 or 5 years.

At Christmas we just have a smaller selection of much nicer chocolates.

Heroes
Celebrations
Quality Street
Roses

Quality Street
Roses
Celebrations
Heroes

Just Quality Street. In a proper tin, not a plastic box. I love the smell as you lift the lid, and the glint and rustle of the wrappers.

Roses were my favourite as a child, but they have changed so much - hate the boring wrapping, hate the cheap tasteless chocolate inside.
Though my local supermarket is stocking some in gorgeous retro-style tins - half tempted to buy them just for the tin and get rid of the chocolates!

Heroes are horrible too, even the crunchie ones aren't worth eating.

Celebrations, meh, the Malteser ones are nice, but I wouldn't bother with any of the other flavours.

Roses /Quality Street or quality Street /roses
Heroes
Celebrations

None
All dreadful