OvO that is lovely and got me properly choked up reading it. Sorry for your loss and I think it's wonderful how you've managed to make a positive out of what must be a very difficult time of year. Your story highlights how new Christmas traditions are born. I personally find it fascinating reading what different families do, but then I must confess I love Christmas.
We did a Christmas Eve box last year after I'd read about them online. It was a bit last minute but I just thought it was a lovely idea. We'd already decided to do the Elf as my nephews (who were born in the US and are a little older) have one and get so excited about him coming. My youngest was only 1 then and it was lost on her really, but my eldest was 4 and understood. I wasn't sure what she would make of him but she absolutely loved him. He shows up around the time we put the tree up, which traditionally would be the weekend closest to the 12th in our house (although it happened a little early this year as we were travelling last weekend). Then he goes home the night before Christmas Eve and leaves a box for the kids to find Christmas Eve morning to say thank you for letting him stay and taking care of him. It was all a bit experimental last year and I wasn't sure if we'd do it again but when we hit December my eldest asked when the Elf would be coming. I wondered if it was because she remembered he left presents but actually she seems to be genuinely delighted finding him in the morning before they have their advent chocolates.
Last year it was a single box, undecorated, that I bought from hobbycraft for £8. We repurposed it after Christmas and it's currently an odd sock box. This year hasn't been a very good one in our household. I had a miscarriage at 12 weeks during the New Year, my best friend passed away suddenly in January and my MiL has been very poorly and spent most of the year in hospital. It's really made me think about life. Long ago I used to be quite crafty and arty. I had big sketch books that I drew in most days. In the last 10 years I've found less and less time to do these things until I have found myself not doing them at all ... and I genuinely miss it. It's all taught me you really don't know what is around the corner and I've been trying in small ways to make more time for myself to have fun.
With all that in mind the Christmas Eve boxes became a bit of a project for me this year. I decided I would decorate them myself and I have had so much fun doing it. They're simple wooden boxes, painted white, red and green with the girl's names on the front and a few small jingle bells on the side. They look a bit, erm ... rustic. But they were made by Elves so that's my excuse.
Inside they will get things that they will use on Christmas Eve. So no toys, that's for the big day. They will get PJs (yes, we are those sort of people apparently), a new dressing gown and slippers. None of these are Christmas themed but they are things they like. So Hey Duggee PJs for the youngest and The Little Mermaid PJs for the eldest etc. Then they each have a story book, an activity sticker book, a cup with hot chocolate and a few cheap Christmas DVDs I've spotted when shopping.
We don't do the key, reindeer food, Christmas plate etc. I think they're a lovely idea but just not for us.
Each to their own I say. It's Christmas, box or no box do what makes you happy.