Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Christian Mumsnetters

This board exists primarily for the use of Christian Mumsnetters. Others are welcome to post but please be respectful. For theological debates, please visit our Philosophy/religion forum.

Would Jesus have known who he was as a baby?

293 replies

FloralGums · 01/01/2025 21:52

I was pondering this following a sermon at Midnight Mass.
Was he a totally human baby or do you think he was more than that? Was he sentient?
I was thinking of the visit of the shepherd and Magi, and the flight from Herod and if he was aware.
When do you think he became aware of his true self?
I was hoping there might be someone knowledgeable or with some insights from clerical training or something.

For clarity (incase this comes up in Active) I am posting this on Christian Mumsnetters, which is primarily intended for the use of Christians. Yes I am aware it the internet and anyone can post etc etc but I am not interested in atheists posting about sky fairies or flying spaghetti monsters so won’t be responding to those posts. Feel free to start your own discussion on Philosophy/Religion.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
SensibleSigma · 04/01/2025 12:27

@CloseEncountersOfTheTurdKind that wasn’t God speaking, it was Paul. Speaking in a particular time and place. He also wants women to cover their hair and be silent in church, if I remember correctly.

Do you know how the writing in bible was curated? Why it exists in its current form?

SensibleSigma · 04/01/2025 12:28

Honestly the judgemental disrespectful behaviour here offends me far more than the occasional use of Christ’s title.

HaddyAbrams · 04/01/2025 12:31

SensibleSigma · 04/01/2025 12:28

Honestly the judgemental disrespectful behaviour here offends me far more than the occasional use of Christ’s title.

Same. And I don't believe the Bible is literally the word of God, so whatever is in Corinthians (or any other book) is man's interpretation. Not Gods actual words. Only in my opinion of course. Others believe differently.

CurlewKate · 04/01/2025 12:32

@Thegreatestoftheseislove
I was going to leave this thread, but I have to say that your last post has made me so angry that I can't leave yet. I think you said that you are a new Christian? If so, I think you really need to speak to your spiritual advisor. Your attitude is so rigid and unforgiving and lacking in empathy that you are going to make yourself and others very unhappy.

CloseEncountersOfTheTurdKind · 04/01/2025 12:52

WinterCoatsHelp · 04/01/2025 12:26

don't worry, I've had enough people with homophobic beliefs quote this at me. I could argue the toss with the clobber passages, but I can't be arsed.

I'd be interested to hear any Bible passages that say differently, as I'm not aware of any. Like I said, I believe what God says so if he says differently please do show me, as I'm willing to change what I believe if it's not in line with scripture.

CloseEncountersOfTheTurdKind · 04/01/2025 12:55

SensibleSigma · 04/01/2025 12:27

@CloseEncountersOfTheTurdKind that wasn’t God speaking, it was Paul. Speaking in a particular time and place. He also wants women to cover their hair and be silent in church, if I remember correctly.

Do you know how the writing in bible was curated? Why it exists in its current form?

But it's in the Bible, and the whole Bible is the inspired word of God. We can't pick and choose what to believe. And yes, I do believe that women should not preach in church and should cover their hair when they pray

MargaretThursday · 04/01/2025 13:06

I think there are too many people on this thread who are trying to wind things up for it to have any meaningful debate and the best thing for anyone who hasn't got that intention is to unwatch this thread and leave it.

Let's concentrate on what we all know to be true and not start arguing over the differences that any group will always have, and Christians are no different.

We are all flawed people, but the difference is we believe in God and that His son has given the way that we as imperfect people can be with our perfect God.

AlteredStater · 04/01/2025 13:12

HaddyAbrams · 04/01/2025 12:31

Same. And I don't believe the Bible is literally the word of God, so whatever is in Corinthians (or any other book) is man's interpretation. Not Gods actual words. Only in my opinion of course. Others believe differently.

If you take that view, then what can you truly take from the Bible? You can disbelieve any parts you don't like or agree with. I think it lands you on shifting sands. Just my opinion!

CloseEncountersOfTheTurdKind · 04/01/2025 13:17

AlteredStater · 04/01/2025 13:12

If you take that view, then what can you truly take from the Bible? You can disbelieve any parts you don't like or agree with. I think it lands you on shifting sands. Just my opinion!

Yes, I didn't realise that quoting the Bible on a Christian chat would be controversial! I know people interpret things differently, for example not everyone agrees with women covering their heads to pray, and I don't have an issue with this as it's not a fundamental part of the faith. But if you don't believe the Bible what is your basis for what you believe?

CloseEncountersOfTheTurdKind · 04/01/2025 13:19

MargaretThursday · 04/01/2025 13:06

I think there are too many people on this thread who are trying to wind things up for it to have any meaningful debate and the best thing for anyone who hasn't got that intention is to unwatch this thread and leave it.

Let's concentrate on what we all know to be true and not start arguing over the differences that any group will always have, and Christians are no different.

We are all flawed people, but the difference is we believe in God and that His son has given the way that we as imperfect people can be with our perfect God.

Absolutely, I wasn't trying to start an argument, just saying what I believe to be true based on what I've read in the Bible. 'Believe on the Lord Jesus and you will be saved ' is the fundamental belief of a Christian. I definitely have my flaws but I know I'm forgiven.

ueberlin2030 · 04/01/2025 13:20

ChristmasStars · 04/01/2025 10:08

Laughable? Interesting word. I don't think there was anything laughable in either of my posts that you laughed at. It says a lot about you and your attitude to a serious matter.

It was laughable because you suggested I said things I didn't actually say.

MrTiddlesTheCat · 04/01/2025 13:22

CloseEncountersOfTheTurdKind · 04/01/2025 13:17

Yes, I didn't realise that quoting the Bible on a Christian chat would be controversial! I know people interpret things differently, for example not everyone agrees with women covering their heads to pray, and I don't have an issue with this as it's not a fundamental part of the faith. But if you don't believe the Bible what is your basis for what you believe?

The basis for what I believe is my direct, personal relationship with Christ.

CloseEncountersOfTheTurdKind · 04/01/2025 13:24

MrTiddlesTheCat · 04/01/2025 13:22

The basis for what I believe is my direct, personal relationship with Christ.

A direct, personal relationship with Christ is vital. But the Bible teaches us more about him, doesn't it? Without the Bible I wouldn't know who Christ was or what he's done for me.

WinterCoatsHelp · 04/01/2025 13:25

CloseEncountersOfTheTurdKind · 04/01/2025 12:52

I'd be interested to hear any Bible passages that say differently, as I'm not aware of any. Like I said, I believe what God says so if he says differently please do show me, as I'm willing to change what I believe if it's not in line with scripture.

You might be interested in this video, which also has links to scholarly articles and further reading/ explanations on the clobber passages. It makes more sense for me to link to someone who's already explained it clearly, hope you find it useful

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xE9XRCJ_AFk

CloseEncountersOfTheTurdKind · 04/01/2025 13:28

WinterCoatsHelp · 04/01/2025 13:25

You might be interested in this video, which also has links to scholarly articles and further reading/ explanations on the clobber passages. It makes more sense for me to link to someone who's already explained it clearly, hope you find it useful

Thank you, I will have a watch and a read

WinterCoatsHelp · 04/01/2025 13:31

You're welcome, Close. Thanks for being open to different ideas

CloseEncountersOfTheTurdKind · 04/01/2025 13:33

WinterCoatsHelp · 04/01/2025 13:31

You're welcome, Close. Thanks for being open to different ideas

I think that's an important part of my journey as a Christian- not to be closed minded but willing to listen to what others have to say, and willing to change my beliefs, as long as it's in-line with scripture. The Bible is a big book and it's easy to miss things or to misunderstand them, so it's helpful to hear different views.

ueberlin2030 · 04/01/2025 13:36

CloseEncountersOfTheTurdKind · 04/01/2025 13:17

Yes, I didn't realise that quoting the Bible on a Christian chat would be controversial! I know people interpret things differently, for example not everyone agrees with women covering their heads to pray, and I don't have an issue with this as it's not a fundamental part of the faith. But if you don't believe the Bible what is your basis for what you believe?

The catholic and protestant bibles aren't the same - the catholic one has a few more sections. Different translations can also say subtly different things. Some christians pretty much ignore the OT, others say the NT cannot be understood without reading the OT. Some christians rigidly stick to certain parts of the bible and other christians select other parts as more important.
Some christians use proverbs to scold, others use them to encourage. Every christian picks and chooses, even if they think they don't.

ueberlin2030 · 04/01/2025 13:38

CloseEncountersOfTheTurdKind · 04/01/2025 13:33

I think that's an important part of my journey as a Christian- not to be closed minded but willing to listen to what others have to say, and willing to change my beliefs, as long as it's in-line with scripture. The Bible is a big book and it's easy to miss things or to misunderstand them, so it's helpful to hear different views.

We also have to remember the different cultural context that most of it was written in, there was so much not known that is known now.
I always found in interesting that there are several types of love referred to in the bible, but the simple word love is used every time, not distinguishing.

ChristmasStars · 04/01/2025 13:48

ueberlin2030 · 04/01/2025 13:20

It was laughable because you suggested I said things I didn't actually say.

Nope I quoted you both directly and indirectly. Are you able to indicate what you think I suggested that you didn't actually say? Or do you just have to resort to a laughing emoji?

ChristmasStars · 04/01/2025 13:49

ueberlin2030 · 04/01/2025 13:36

The catholic and protestant bibles aren't the same - the catholic one has a few more sections. Different translations can also say subtly different things. Some christians pretty much ignore the OT, others say the NT cannot be understood without reading the OT. Some christians rigidly stick to certain parts of the bible and other christians select other parts as more important.
Some christians use proverbs to scold, others use them to encourage. Every christian picks and chooses, even if they think they don't.

Not true. The Bibles are basically the same but the Catholic Bible also has the apocrypha. Other than that what's in the protestant Bible is also in the Catholic Bible.

HaddyAbrams · 04/01/2025 13:59

ueberlin2030 · 04/01/2025 13:36

The catholic and protestant bibles aren't the same - the catholic one has a few more sections. Different translations can also say subtly different things. Some christians pretty much ignore the OT, others say the NT cannot be understood without reading the OT. Some christians rigidly stick to certain parts of the bible and other christians select other parts as more important.
Some christians use proverbs to scold, others use them to encourage. Every christian picks and chooses, even if they think they don't.

Exactly. We often read the same passage from a different bible at one of the groups I attend. It's amazing how one or 2 words being translated differently can completely change the feeling of a verse.

And FWIW i only said that i don't believe that the Bible is the literal word of God. Not that I don't believe it at all. Although a lot of it is up for questioning and, as already said, what it might mean can depend on which version you read. Luckily my church is one that welcomes questions. It's the basis for the home group I'm in.

ueberlin2030 · 04/01/2025 14:52

ChristmasStars · 04/01/2025 13:49

Not true. The Bibles are basically the same but the Catholic Bible also has the apocrypha. Other than that what's in the protestant Bible is also in the Catholic Bible.

It is true.
They're not the same because one either has extra content or one has missing content.

MrTiddlesTheCat · 04/01/2025 15:00

It's all in the interpretation. Take the 10 commandments as an example. Do you know that they are different depending on if you are anglican or catholic? Same text, different interpretation.

ChristmasStars · 04/01/2025 15:50

ueberlin2030 · 04/01/2025 14:52

It is true.
They're not the same because one either has extra content or one has missing content.

Edited

Don't tag me any more. Your mocking laughter emojis and this attempt to disagree with me even though I've explained more or less the same point show who you are. I said the actual content of the two Bibles is the same but there is the extra of the apocrypha in the Catholic version. The rest is the same.

If you tag me again I won't even be looking at your post.