On one level I know it doesn’t matter. I know I’d say happy mum and happy baby to one of my friends, but on a deeper and rawer level than that I just feel so sad and to be honest embarrassed and frustrated, my body isn’t doing what it should be, and it’s harming my beloved baby.
I empathise with this so much - I always said it didn’t matter if I couldn’t breastfeed but when that at actually happened I was devastated and felt so guilty. It felt like the most important thing in the world at the time, which is why I kept pumping for so long and so often. All I had was some people saying why was I bothering, and others saying I hadn’t tried hard enough to feed him - definitely no one understood how hard pumping was.
I would ask for a follow up call / Zoom with the IBCLC and tell her how much you’re struggling still and can’t do the things she suggested.
Your body isn’t failing or harming your baby - it’s just a complex thing for some mums and babies. I know many EBFing mums who say things got easier with latching as their have got bigger, but obviously that ideally means you’ll pump as much as possible until then. There are several pumping bras on Amazon with next day delivery - that will help you to still do things while pumping. Pumping won’t have to be this frequent longterm (well it was for me but that’s a long complicated story) - once your supply is established you will be able to cut down.
Do you have a partner and any chance they’re off over Christmas? If so this is a good opportunity for you to pump whenever your baby feeds, which will boost your supply - these times where they are feeding more often is what increases your supply.
I asked earlier whether your pump has variable speed and suction - using the technique I mentioned upthread where you start fast and low suction then switch to slow and high suction really increased my supply.
I know it’s heartbreaking and you feel so many crappy things right now. If you don’t want to keep going, it’s okay - pumping is so hard while taking care of a newborn too. I understand though that you probably don’t want to stop and that’s okay too. You will adjust to it.
If your nipple is pointing down you may find the laid back feeding position helps. Breastfeeding can involve a lot more boob manhandling than we realise too, especially with small babies.
I know how desperate it feels when you just can’t get things to work. It massively affected my mental health and I became quite obsessive (tracking pumping volumes and feeds in an app, as well as every nappy change). Felt like I was always pumping or feeding or washing up ready to pump again. So I understand what you’re feeling now and your feelings are valid. It’s awful when you just can’t make it work. I would definitely try calling the National breastfeeding helpline, and more IBCLC support if you can afford it -did they watch a feed, adjust positioning and attachment etc, or did they mainly just come for a tongue tie? I’m friends with an IBCLC who says many of her seasons involve just small changes to these things which make all the difference.