Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Infant feeding

Get advice and support with infant feeding from other users here.

Read this shocking article about the damaging effects of formula and the immoral practices of the companies who peddle this junk.

542 replies

moondog · 28/07/2006 17:36

From The Ecologist magazine.

Here.....

Grim reading.

OP posts:
Feistybird · 28/07/2006 17:42

Formula = baby junk food??

agree 'breast is best' but to call it junk food is absolute twaddle and a slap in the face to anyone who has simply never been able to breastfeed.

Makes me want to effing spit, frankly.

tiktok · 28/07/2006 17:47

moonie - sorry, but you have to be careful with words. It's hurtful for mothers who use/used formula to hear it termed 'junk'....and you should know that. It reduces the chances that anyone will read the link, too.

Feisty, you are right to be angry at the thread title.

Jimjams2 · 28/07/2006 17:48

oh FGS Moondog, get a grip.

mimitwo · 28/07/2006 17:48

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

Littlefish · 28/07/2006 17:49

Moondog - I really don't think you needed to post this link with such an inflamatory thread title.

motherinferior · 28/07/2006 17:49

And frankly I am not going to read anything published by Zac bloody Goldsmith.

Jimjams2 · 28/07/2006 17:50

A case of being deliberatly provocative I think.

tiktok · 28/07/2006 17:50

moondog - can you edit/delete the thread title and post again without upsetting people?

The article has some important things to say, and people should be aware of the issues, but not like this.

spidermama · 28/07/2006 17:50

Uh oh Mooners. A willfully kamikaze OP.

Littlefish · 28/07/2006 17:50

I agree with tiktok - it's really hurtful. I have enough guilt about failing at breastfeeding without crap like this!

PiccadillyCircus · 28/07/2006 17:51

I support breast feeding a lot, but why give your thread that sort of title? Unless it is just to provoke a breast and formula feeders battle?

Callisto · 28/07/2006 17:51

What is wrong with Zac Goldsmith? (genuine question)

FrannyandZooey · 28/07/2006 17:51

Jesus, moondog, have you got a death wish or something?

motherinferior · 28/07/2006 17:53

Oh, it's the poshness combined with the preachiness I can't be dealing with. Sheer mindless prejudice on my part, but I like my ecological types a bit, you know, earthy.

psychomum5 · 28/07/2006 17:56

I breast fed all my five, but for some reason my milk wasn't suitable for my youngest and he had to go on to a 'predigested' type of formula (prejomin) from the age of 3mths (I actually mixed fed him until 6mths as I was unwilling to totally stop breastfeeding bacause the closeness, for me, was a huge part of it).

Same child now has been found to have a dismotile bowel which was probably the cause of his feeding issue, but NOT caused by them tho I believe.

Now had I read something like this at the point in time when I was in the process of having to swap him over (and so feeling very guilty already and low too to boot), I would have been very distressed......VERY.

Articles like this don't IN ANY WAY help mum who already, for one reason or another, feel guilty over whatever milk choice they make for their beloved child.

and for what it is worth......i breast fed exclusivly my three daughters yet they, without exception, all suffered from gastroentoritis, pnuemonia's (x 3 for DD3..), reflux (severe for DD2 & DD3), virus's, and many other illnesses that required many many hospital admittances. YET, my friends who ALL bottle fed theirs (I was the unusual one in breastfeeding and late weaning!!!!), never once had theirs kiddies in hospital....unless for broken limbs or accidents.

For me, that was a type of 'smack-in-the-face' for me being the 'natural' feeder, yet mine were the ones who had all the illnesses I was hoping to avoid.

oh yeah.....mine have asthma and excma too.....DD2 needing nebulizers and is on serotide steriod inhaler and the becotide does nothing. DD3 also is asthmatic.
DS2 by contrast, altho ending up on bottles and having a bowel disorder, has neither!!!!!

This article I am afraid doesn't help mums who have feeding issues already

batters · 28/07/2006 17:59

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Angeliz · 28/07/2006 18:01

Crap title moondog!
Anyway, i'm trying not to bite as i'm a sinner!

batters · 28/07/2006 18:02

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

FrannyandZooey · 28/07/2006 18:02

I haven't actually read the article yet, but am wondering if people think that factual information about formula should be suppressed to avoid upsetting mothers who couldn't / didn't breastfeed?

Some of the posts on this thread seem to suggest that to be the case.

Callisto · 28/07/2006 18:03

Maybe you should all give Moondog the benefit of the doubt - formula is junk food was in the article after all so she is probably only quoting from that.

Feistybird · 28/07/2006 18:04

I would implore people (no offence meant to psychomum and others) not to indulge this crap with their sometimes genuinely sad stories about being unable to or simply wanting to breastfeed.

Callisto · 28/07/2006 18:04

Been wondering that myself for sometime F&Z.

batters · 28/07/2006 18:04

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Feistybird · 28/07/2006 18:05

simply not wanting to....am so at this, I can't bloody type.

motherinferior · 28/07/2006 18:06

I have now skimmed the article (which is apppallingly subbed - quotes within single quotes take double quotes, a point of pedantry one would expect a journalist to observe, frankly) and see it also makes some delightful links between medicalised birth and breastfeeding.