Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Black Mumsnetters

This board exists primarily for the use of Black Mumsnetters. Others are welcome to post but please be respectful.

Racists, you have been silenced... Bye Mumschat!

102 replies

PatricksRum · 12/10/2020 11:17

This is welcomed news.

It's a shame it was taken down so soon as I made a recent police report.

It's a tiny thing but I'm so happy to hear it's gone. The racism was like none other.

Only one person challenged the minstrel photo.

I'm still extremely wary as a lot of mc posters are here commenting on my threads and trolling the H&M threads.

Racists, you have been silenced... Bye Mumschat!
Racists, you have been silenced... Bye Mumschat!
Racists, you have been silenced... Bye Mumschat!
OP posts:
BIWI · 15/10/2020 14:23

Yep. I re-joined.

I joined when it initially started as I was curious to see how it would unfold. But when it became apparent how nasty, bitchy and racist it was becoming, I de-regged.

When I re-joined yesterday, I posted in support of those who were asking for the site to be more moderated, and for racism to be called out/deleted.

One poster in particular, TheLovelyJoanna, kept asking people to prove the point that it had been racist - despite people posting screenshots, etc.

In the end, after a one or two post run in with her, I was banned.

There's another thread on MN in which at least two other MNetters have been banned from there for making the same points I was making.

Seems clear it's being run now by the racist crew.

rainyoutside · 15/10/2020 14:25

Doesn’t bode particularly well, does it? I see the lovely Joanna has asked a poster if they are MichaelMumsnet. I wonder if she wants to link to her LinkedIn profile, too.

Compey · 15/10/2020 14:36

@EchoCardioGran

Hello you! There was a thread on this last night. I'm glad you made a police report. There were a lot of good mumsnetters genuinely shocked by what had gone on. A handful turned up to try and deny it all or saw nothing. I've never looked at the H and M threads on here, but slowly realising the bigger picture now. Horrible bunch of people. I got someone posting me a wikipedia explanation of " Identity politics" ( not a term I'm fond of) last night obvs because I didn't understand what I was talking about calling it racism and was a bit hysterical, as someone else suggested. So they are still about, just in another disguise.

As well as yourself, there seems to be a fair few other MN singled out for the hate trolling treatment as well as a mod. I think it was just good people who called out racism, including a lovely Coronation Street fan.

Not enough words really, for these people.

You see them exposed in newspapers sometimes don't you? Always a bit inadequate, and so very sorry when found out, blah blah.

I don't follow this. What are "H and M threads" ?
ThinSlicePizza · 15/10/2020 15:22

H and M are the harry and meghan threads.

Whiskyinajar · 15/10/2020 15:28

Ugh! I won't be trying to find it.

I'll stick to the Food and Drink threads on Tattle.

From what I'm hearing Tattle is just as bad but because I don't follow many posts I haven't seen anything horrible.

I wish people would leave Harry and Megan alone. It's why I made a commitment to not reading the threads... the media is bad enough.

PatricksRum · 15/10/2020 15:47

They've put it back up Ffs

Back to my police report.

The whole reason for the racism there is because it has little/ no moderation which is why they like it.

Offering themselves up as moderators.

How they are allowed to get away with copying MN's layout too, I have no idea.

OP posts:
breadbins · 15/10/2020 15:52

It doesn't look remotely like MN's layout to me.

Quaagars · 15/10/2020 17:37

The screenshot put up on the other thread was near enough identical, you seriously think it looked nothing like?!
What with a very similar name to MN, and what looks like a blatant rip off of the layout, it's a wonder they're getting away with it!
Unless it's changed from the blue and white background I saw, it was extremely similar.

HeIenaDove · 15/10/2020 19:04

Sites always need proper moderating. Basic i would have thought. I was only on there for five weeks. I dont have time to read all the posts on very long threads. So i didnt see it It was obviously there though.

rainyoutside · 15/10/2020 19:12

It’s certainly reverted to type!

maggiethecat · 15/10/2020 20:24

I had never even heard of that site but this is all so depressing. What must it do to a soul to be so full of hate.

breadbins · 15/10/2020 21:17

@Quaagars

The screenshot put up on the other thread was near enough identical, you seriously think it looked nothing like?! What with a very similar name to MN, and what looks like a blatant rip off of the layout, it's a wonder they're getting away with it! Unless it's changed from the blue and white background I saw, it was extremely similar.
I'm on a desktop because of my eyesight so maybe that explains it.

I am on several other (much more dull) forums - performing arts, gardening, birdwatching and a hobby one. Three are blue with a white background, one is green, which has a similar layout to here, the other three are more similar to MC.

HeIenaDove · 16/10/2020 00:07

all the old usernames are gone now Ive just checked. They all show as Visitor. Im not going back there. I have no idea if anyone would be able to use my username. I havent posted after Sunday 11 October just to be clear. Bit worrying I dont want someone pretending to be me. Though i dont know if thats possible. I hope not.

Giggorata · 16/10/2020 00:37

Apparently, it is possible for old user names to be picked up by new people, HelenaDove. Admin says if it catches anyone doing this, they will be banned. I'm not sure how they will know.

HeIenaDove · 16/10/2020 00:41

Yes thats what i thought and i was worried about. Sad

HeIenaDove · 16/10/2020 00:44

Hopefully my extensive posting history on this site would speak for itself if that happened. Though im not hopeful going by the way the other thread went.

PatricksRum · 16/10/2020 01:13

I'm still wondering who doctored that image of me pretending to be Ghana Girl. It was someone who moderates for Reddit.

Also have to beware that posters like Worra joined in with the speculation.

I hope no one takes your username *Helena.
*
I'm so wary of a site that has a Hotmail email address to contact admin by.

Racists, you have been silenced... Bye Mumschat!
Racists, you have been silenced... Bye Mumschat!
OP posts:
HeIenaDove · 16/10/2020 02:08

@PatricksRum Flowers

rainyoutside · 16/10/2020 08:53

Mn used to be horrendously racist. Oh, they’d quickly feign horror if someone said the N or the P word, but the following threads used to be at least weekly -

complaining about the poor English skills of foreign nurses or midwives

their toddler commented that a black person looked like chocolate or had a ‘chocolate face’ (some jumped the shark with this and chocolate was boosted to monkey, I remember the first time mn actually took a thread down on this basis.)
Some are even in classics

threads about why I wouldn’t find a black man attractive or AIBU not to want to date a black man

Enid Blyton books with dogs named N i double G er and darkie defended as lovely childhood memories

wonderful thread several Christmases ago with mixed shock and amusement at a black santa in a department store.

is a corker of a thread here “is Meghan markle black? Can’t say I’ve noticed” (because if you don’t notice someone’s colour, that’s the actual height of non racism, so nonchalant, chilled.)

Oh they’ll feign horror over Emmett Till, Stephen Lawrence, they cried at To Kill A Mockingbird, they really reeeeeally aren’t racist. But mn historically was both white and middle class. White middle class people aren’t racist. No indeed. I mean, if they’d gone to St Andrews instead of Durham, or Bristol or Edinburgh, Kate could easily have been one of them. There’s no offence in William choosing her. And they party hard in London in their twenties but then once the children are school age move out to the Home Counties.

Someone on the place for mums where they ... talk ... complained racism was everywhere - you can’t even say you have a white cat. Let’s try and break it down for the idiots a bit.

Racism is a sense of superiority. It is not ignoring someone’s race altogether. Historically, white people enslaved black people. Now while this might seem light years away for you and for me, actually, in historical terms, it is not. In historical terms, it is recent.

Some slaves were horrendously treated. Some were actually treated very well, even better, than some poor white people. Why - well they were worth something. Just as you wouldn’t deliberately mistreat your house or car. Some of the southern plantations in America genuinely held the belief that freeing their slaves would not be in their best interests. Of course, the primary motivation was money but there was a concern that stretched beyond this.

Emmett Till was murdered in 1955: that is only about twenty or thirty years before most of us were born FGS. And Mumsnetters bloody love to be high and mighty about the Daily Mail but I’ll remind you now they were the only paper to challenge Stephen Lawrence’s murder. That nice middle class Guardian didn’t, did they?

I genuinely think a lot of people have these attitudes ingrained into them. I also think more people are waking up to them which can only be a good thing.

It doesn’t surprise me at all to see what took place on that website and what continues to do so.

rainyoutside · 16/10/2020 09:01

Still don’t believe me? Look at this

Isn’t it HILARIOUS and WITTY?

Roussette · 16/10/2020 09:12

To be fair, that thread is nearly ten years ago, and I do hope that MN has cleaned up its act since then. Personally I think so, but the abuse PatricksRum received was vile, it was good to see it being stamped on.

With reference to your post , I so agree with this...
"Racism is a sense of superiority. It is not ignoring someone’s race altogether. Historically, white people enslaved black people. Now while this might seem light years away for you and for me, actually, in historical terms, it is not. In historical terms, it is recent."

Thanking about how recent it is really hit home for me last night. I watched the most enlightening and thought provoking film about Harriet Tubman, she was an American abolitionist and activist who was born into slavery.
It was moving, emotional and I hope it's OK for me to recommend it on this thread.

It's called 'Harriet'.

Here's and IMDB link about it.

Roussette · 16/10/2020 09:14

I genuinely think a lot of people have these attitudes ingrained into them. I also think more people are waking up to them which can only be a good thing

^^ Yes to this

rainyoutside · 16/10/2020 09:16

It was 2011, and 2019 seems light years away at the moment so indeed Grin

But and let’s be frank here many of the posters on it tittering with glee about how many posters had complained about racism that day are some of MNs best loved and most well known. It shows, doesn’t it, a bit of an uncomfortable history.

BIWI · 16/10/2020 10:30

But that thread was clearly in response to another one - and without seeing that one, it's very difficult to judge the tone.

My take on it is that they were taking the piss out of people who had been denying racism.

BIWI · 16/10/2020 10:31

That aside, I thought your earlier post was fab, and very insightful.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread