Blue I'm glad you got some answers. I'm sure it's a great comfort!
Stripey Welcome! and Chip Welcome back!
I'm wanting a hospital birth. Having hd a massive pph with my first when I needed 6 units of blood, I don't feel safe anywhere but in a hospital. My experience has been such that I generally rate midwives much higher than obstetricians in hospital. It was an incompetent doctor pulling sharply on the cord like it was dog refusing to heel that caused it to snap and my massive bleed. My best birth was number 3. I'd warned the midwife that my placentas just don't want to come away, and that she'd be unlikely to manage it without a manual removal, and she said "Ha! Never beaten by one yet!" She then did have some trouble and said " Well, it is a really tricky one, but I still think I can do it." And did. Wish I had her again this time. Last time I got through labour without needing pain relief, despite DS2 facing the wrong way round, but then had to have an epidural for a manual removal of placenta. Sigh. With a trainee doctor trying hard to put the needle in, but getting wrong twice with all the risk of a dural tap and the blinding headaches that causes. I'm very composed during labour, and try to relax into the pain rather than fight it, but I was very rude and gobby at that point! I said " Can the person trying to get the needle in step back now, and the person giving the instructions step forward and actually do it." I'd already had a midwife who didn't know how to support a woman giving birth on all fours (she tried to persuade me to lie on my back, to suit her!), so I felt I'd already done my bit that day to further training of staff!
I also hate the idea of a birthing pool. I can't shake the vision of it being filled with my blood - I'm very squeamish to the point of phobia when it comes to blood. And in any case, as someone who spends labour on all fours, I can't help but feel very little of me would be in the pool, and my arse would be cold!
I think it's true that our past experiences and fears have a huge impact on what we want from our birth experience. I don't feel at all that other women should choose as I do, that my way is the right way - it's only right for me! I shall be on my way to hospital the second I'm in labour, as I get anxious at home, and my labours are fast. As soon as I arrive they open up a vein and attach me to a drip to save time if I need blood again. It doesn't stop me from moving around as I need to. I hate being examined in case I have a contraction whilst lying on my back, cos it really hurts in that position! I find it perfectly bearable if I can rock with my bum in the air!