Name for dd3 or ds1

[SpottySlippers]

I would welcome your feedback on the following:

Beatrix Rosa if it is dd3 or
Jonty William if it is ds1

I already have two dd's:

Emilia Olive
Florence Alice

Thoughts welcome or any other suggestions as I am struggling.......

They're not my personal taste but there's nothing wrong with them.

Emilia will get confused with Amelia a lot (ie, you will be correcting people a lot on that one).

Emilia is her existing DD

I prefer Beatrice - Beatrix seems to be trying too hard. Not keen on Jonty at all, it sounds like a nickname.

Thanks for your replies; yes dd1 is Emilia (nn Millie/Mimi) and dd2 is Florence (nn Floss). Would shorten Beatrix to Bea. Would not shorten Jonty.

Can't decide which is nicer Beatrix or Beatrice.......

beatriCE is my pref, millie, floss and bea sound nice together. jonty is also nice, it will be jon when he is older tho.

I like Beatrice but not Beatrix. I like William. Don't like Jonty.

I love Beatrix or Beatrice (the -trice ending is a bit softer like your other DDs' names) and William too but I dislike Jonty.

I like Jonty. We almost used it for DS1 as nn for Jonathan.

Oops, sorry for my confusion earlier! .

Beatrice is nicer but perhaps too similar to Florence?

Prefer Jonathan with nn Jonty.

i just think of that beer-tricks potter joke....Beatrice is much better....Jonty is nice but not nice enough to actually call a child in real like i think....

Beatrice is nice but not sure about Beatrix.

Dont think Jonty really goes with your dd's names though

I love love love them all !

I like them as a set, think they go well together too.

Thanks for all your replies!

Any other suggestions that work with my existing dd names are very welcome.......I also really like:

Sophia (but is this too popular?)
Isabella (again perhaps a bit too popular?)
Clementine (but is this too now?)

With regard to boys names.....help???

Y Y Y to Sophia

Isabella lovely but too popular unless you really love it

Not that keen on the name Clementine

For a boy, I think a traditional short name would work well with those sisters' names e.g. Mark, John, Sam(uel), Dan(iel), George etc.

beatrice and florence were my grandmothers middle names - i think they go really well together although i think Beatrix Rose sounds better than Beatrix Rosa.

Also prefer Beatrice.

Harriet?
Cecily?

I like Jonty.

Hamish?
Arlo?
Rufus?
(All with William as middle name)

I love Clementine.

I like Beatrix and Clementine. Isabella and Sophia are indeed very (too) popular imo.

For boys, I like Jonty (Jonathan). How about Quentin, Tobias or William?

Oh, sorry, just saw that you'd like William as a middle name