Your opinions please

[Lola11]

For our first child we chose the name that is not very obvious how to spell /pronounce. But it is unusual and I still like it.
Can you please help with suggestions for our second. Not sure if this one should be the same or something more popular although we prefer unusual names. Or are all of these becoming popular and some maybe overdone (i.e. Ruby,Poppy) Thanks!
Our short list is not that short any more:

Imogen
Mabel
Olive
Freya
Melody
Kitty
Charlotte
Lilla/Lila
Isla
Ines
Maia
Annabel
Amber
Poppy
Scarlett
Hannah
Ruby
Sienna
Thea

isla is very common around my way....lots of them seem to have sprung up recently. i know three under a year

I don't like Kitty on its own - really think it is just a NN...

Ines is the most original on your list....Violet is lovely tho. Amelie is boring i think....

Imogen - I like it i think but would never use it.
Mabel - nope.
Olive - nope.
Freya - no no no.
Melody - nope.
Kitty - nope.
Charlotte - ummm tis ok.
Lilla/Lila - nope.
Isla - I quite like but wouldn't use.
Ines - OK
Maia - OK
Annabel - can't decide.
Amber - nope.
Poppy - nope.
Scarlett - OK.
Hannah - Nope.
Ruby - OK.
Sienna - Nope.
Thea - Like.

ROFL at Imogen being a strippers name. If someone asked me for a stripper name Imogen would not be one I gave.

Effie is nice.

are we allowed to ask what your other DC is called so we can suggest some names?